-->
@Barney
Is the Abraham Lincoln thing a reference to something? I believe Austin claimed the Immortal.
Invincible Mafia Day Phase 1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
689
-->
@Barney
@Vader
@whiteflame
@JoeBob
Given the theme, how does Atom Eve connect to the doctor role?
-->
@Savant
Thats her preliminary power she has and what’s kinda known for so I guess it makes sense. She also have other abilities. I would see her more as a Bodyguard
-->
@Savant
I have never watched the show so i have no clue
-->
@Savant
It’s a trivia reference, to when The Immortal used to dabble in politics.
-->
@Barney
How is austin "abraham lincoln??"
-->
@Barney
also, can we kill Pie or Vader today?
-->
@Greyparrot
@Barney
@whiteflame
@ILikePie5
@AustinL0926
Send two probes out tonight. One to me and one to Savant. If I die, which I most likely will, then savant can confirm you as town. Savant also said he can confirm him as well, so we can confirm two people tonight, which helps us incredibly.
What do you think of this idea?
-->
@Greyparrot
Nevrmrind, I think I misinterpreted your role.
-->
@Best.Korea
If you are doctor, heal JoeBob tonight.
-->
@Greyparrot
@Barney
@Vader
@whiteflame
@JoeBob
I'm not clear on how GP's role is confirmable. Do we know if a probe visits us?
-->
@Savant
I don’t think we do, which is why I said never mind
-->
@Savant
Either me or BK is dying tonight I’m willing to bet.
-->
@Savant
You mentioned this just as I was ready to post.
Part of the problem with all these roles (Doctor, Commuter, GP’s role) is that verifying them gets tricky. We need a Watcher (preferably) or a Tracker to monitor who they visit. We would not do much be determining what they did as where they go. In that sense, while these are “confirmable,” none can be fully confirmed. The Watcher is ideal because we know they can target whoever made the claim instead of guessing what they’re going to do, and in GP’s case, if he targets two people, the Watcher would get both results. That’s a good deal harder to fake.
All of this assumes we have informational roles that could be used for this purpose.
-->
@Savant
As for how Atom Eve’s role connects to her character… pretty poorly, but given what Luna said in the OP and the apparent need for a protective role, I’d say there’s a decent chance it’s real.
-->
@Barney
I strongly sus BK even with the doctor claim. But a NP or two will prove which side he’s really on.
I’m of the same mind. Even if I buy that it’s a viable claim, his behavior keeps me second guessing myself.
-->
@whiteflame
When BK is town, how seriously does he take the game? I mean this is the user who started debates called "Anyone who is not a Christian is on the path of sin and sodomy." and cited a Quora answer as his only source. Trolling doesn't always mean scum.
-->
@Greyparrot
The Immortal = President Lincoln
It’s one of my favorite little details.
-->
@whiteflame
im probably just gonna send out all 5 to those who I dont think is scum
-->
@Savant
Variably. He was unusually taciturn and frustrated for a lot of the last game, but that was after being sussed. He sometimes takes things seriously, though usually that takes a DP or two. I can’t say I’ve seen him behave this specific way before, particularly buddying the most townie players, so it’s setting off alarm bells.
-->
@Barney
The Immortal = President LincolnIt’s one of my favorite little details.
Yep, that was a fun revelation. Started squinting at my screen to see how he’d look in a stovepipe hat.
-->
@Greyparrot
im probably just gonna send out all 5 to those who I dont think is scum
Good to know, though that wouldn’t prove you’re innocent without some kind of validation. Some of those dying might be enough to do the bare minimum since you could confirm visits, though you should mention who was visited as early in the next DP as possible.
-->
@whiteflame
I don't care. After you killed me as TP it's clear you just don't like me.
-->
@whiteflame
I guess that’s true, though notably you’d have to survive out to that point to achieve either of those goals and your decision not to claim might have just hampered that. Honestly, you could’ve gotten away with the character claim alone or just claimed normal Bleeder to invite the quick hammer. Its oddly anti-town to specify the flavor.
Yeah, I didn't really think that one through, although I think that's how Bleeder is usually flavored anyway, based on my research. I had like 5 minutes before a class and I wanted to out my role so I didn't get quickhammered.
IMO BK is being sus not because he's being anti-town, but because he's being anti-town in a way that deviates from his meta.
In his previous games as town, he usually just gets upset and attempts self-destruction when people sus him. Instead, here, he's trying to push the lynch onto someone else, and it doesn't quite feel right.
-->
@Savant
@JoeBob
Pretty sure that GP mentioned the person who gets probed gets notified.
-->
@AustinL0926
Pretty sure that GP mentioned the person who gets probed gets notified.
Did he? Can't find it.
Intuitively I feel that either Pie or BK is lying about their role. Doctor and Commuter are basically the strongest possible protective roles (unlimited protection of others and unlimited self-protection respectively). A Bodyguard or Jailkeeper would make more sense imo. Not really any actual evidence, just my feeling in terms of game balance.
-->
@Savant
I command 5 Kates Every night I can send out any number of these duplicates to probe another player The targeted player will get a message saying they have been probed... If anyone visits the probed player that night I will know there was a visit but won't know who it was from and the Kate used for probing will be lost.... If all five Kates are lost I will immediately die and lose the game so I must use my probes wisely. I can send out multiple Kates each night but I can't call them back until the next night and can only do so if the probed player was not visited...
-->
@Greyparrot
I don't care. After you killed me as TP it's clear you just don't like me.
…I’m sincerely so lost reading this.