I think the best bet is to lynch Austin and confirm his role. This to me would put Pie back in the POE for sure. Right now from a character perspective and what info we do have, I think mechanically it would be difficult to put Pie in my POE right now. I think DP2 depending on Austin's turn he's back in for behavior.I'm personally just at a roadblock between Pie. Maybe I am overthinking (which is likely), but the fact that off of a role hint alone with only 1 claimed character, he had the balls to claim Mark, I mean, damn. That's the only barrier from preventing me from going at Pie. It's just a big claim with no CC to it while being the first member (besides GP) to do so, makes it so hard for me to read him as scum. Not to mention I think Pie as scum tends to play it a bit more safe with claims.I do wonder, is there a Luna game where he was scum? I think looking back at that could be helpful
Savant is the only one I haven't had deep analysis on but fmpov he just moves into the FoS because of whiteflame to me being more town read IMO. I also think him being on a lot of the wagons is a bit suspicious. When I first played mafia and was mafia back on DDO, I used to hop on every wagon known to man to try and get a vote. But at the same time he's not at the top of the scum list because I think his analysis and taking some analysis from other games, like Town of Salem, etc, make me feel he's new trying to use his analysis he knew about other games into forum mafia
I think the best bet is to lynch Austin and confirm his role. This to me would put Pie back in the POE for sure. Right now from a character perspective and what info we do have, I think mechanically it would be difficult to put Pie in my POE right now. I think DP2 depending on Austin's turn he's back in for behavior.I'm personally just at a roadblock between Pie. Maybe I am overthinking (which is likely), but the fact that off of a role hint alone with only 1 claimed character, he had the balls to claim Mark, I mean, damn. That's the only barrier from preventing me from going at Pie. It's just a big claim with no CC to it while being the first member (besides GP) to do so, makes it so hard for me to read him as scum. Not to mention I think Pie as scum tends to play it a bit more safe with claims.I do wonder, is there a Luna game where he was scum? I think looking back at that could be helpfulI see your point. I also have a hard time believing that Pie would be that ballsy with his claim. I have the same reservations about BK - it's not like Atom Eve is a particularly safe claim with several people left in the game who haven't character claimed.
Honestly, the more we keep going back and forth on this, the more resigned I feel to the Austin lynch. I still can't say I buy that he's scum, but PoE alone puts him in a bad position, and he might just be more helpful to us after he's confirmed town and we run through a NP.
Honestly, the more we keep going back and forth on this, the more resigned I feel to the Austin lynch. I still can't say I buy that he's scum, but PoE alone puts him in a bad position, and he might just be more helpful to us after he's confirmed town and we run through a NP. [WHITEFLAME]
There's a phenomenon in psychology called "the temporal pattern of regret", where new actions that lead to negative consequences tend to be viewed with more regret than inaction that leads to negative consequences. When town gets to MYLO because oopsies-doopsies, we mislynched a townie on DP1, y'all will be kicking yourselves
I’m convinced Austin is town at this point. Scum have a bigger duty to each other to not be lynched. And lynching him today gains less than it costs us.
As much as I know this won’t go anywhere,VNTL
His behavior. In include preferring his own head on the chopping block to mine.
We’re in DP1 so what actions has he done which make you think he’s “definitely scum”?
Just get your scumbuddy to hammer,VTNL
but I'm annoyed that town isn't seriously considering other options.
