-->
@Zaradi
Also if you acknowledge that Coal was indeed setting you up conveniently to draw the night kill, why did you keep pretending to sound perplexed when Danielle pointed it out?
Also if you acknowledge that Coal was indeed setting you up conveniently to draw the night kill, why did you keep pretending to sound perplexed when Danielle pointed it out?
That, after the nonsense he pulled last night, keeps him as a scum read. Also, he says we should be treating him like he's dead. Why, because he knows there's not a doctor? Did he maybe not think about that when claiming what he did? But the fact that he says that there is nothing that can save him implies that he knows that there's not a doctor in the game; just like he knew the setup based on the knowledge of his scum-mate's role.
Why does me wanting to draw the NK mean I have to believe theres a roleblocker?
Why cant vanilla's try to draw the NK regardless of setup?
Also, I object to vanilla's trying to draw the NK as anti-town. Vanilla's dying over a town PR is pretty fucking beneficial for town. You are correct, however, that it is a risk, hence why I didn't come into the game wanting to do that.
Did you have a reason to doubt Ragnar's claim of having knowledge of the existence of a roleblocker?
You would have known that playing along with the "draw the nk" strategy could potentially mean you would get CC'ed. If you are town you would know that's anti-town.
I don't buy that you really took a risk here either,
I was perplexed. I didn't think I had softed anything that day phase (still don't). So I wanted to know what she saw (which makes no fucking sense for me to ask if I'm actually a PR, btw. I'd be either ignoring or trying to stop as much discussion of me being a PR as reasonably possible).
You were perplexed but also acknowledge you took a risk by playing along with coal's insinuation you were a power role?
And then when I tried to figure out what was going on, you shut me down
But this question is strange. Are you saying you weren't trying to do the thing I town read you for?
Did you have a reason to doubt Ragnar's claim of having knowledge of the existence of a roleblocker?No?
You would have known that playing along with the "draw the nk" strategy could potentially mean you would get CC'ed. If you are town you would know that's anti-town.That is the risk associated with vanilla's trying to draw the NK, yes. That's if I get CC'd though. If I dont get cc'd, though, and I draw the NK, it's a massive win for town in that the PR's get night actions off. Town PR's getting night actions off = pretty fucking pro-town.To be clear, again, I didn't come into the game wanting to soft a PR.
I don't buy that you really took a risk here either,The cognitive dissonance to say that drawing the NK risks outting a TPR while also saying that I didn't take a risk is staggering.
So I'll give both of you two the same challenge I gave coal: find a post where I'm softing having a PR pre-ragnar softclaim. You won't be able to, because that wasnt my gameplan coming into the game.
Also, I object to vanilla's trying to draw the NK as anti-town. Vanilla's dying over a town PR is pretty fucking beneficial for town
You were perplexed but also acknowledge you took a risk by playing along with coal's insinuation you were a power role?Yes? I could've said I wasnt a pr to shut down that entire conversation and give mafia zero reason to NK me. But I didn't. So I played along with it.
Where are you at? I'd expect you to be pushing me by now
ou thought Coal (and Dani for that matter) was going too far by digging for information and openly speculating about power roles right? It's the one thing we agreed on last day phase. But then you are suddenly okay with risking outting the other PR by going along with it? It's hypocritical for one thing, but then I don't think you really thought of the negative impact of what you were doing, because you could still potentially just claim ignorance to ever softing in the first place...
I repeat: if Zaradi was vanilla, he had no reason to accept Ragnar's declaration of having a power role.
What's the alternative world; he hammers Ragnar and the cop flips town?
Zaradi as scum should have jumped on that wagon at some point.
So you're letting one thing you read townish outweigh the 3 anti-town things he did?