-->
@whiteflame
lol
Avatar The Last Airbender Mafia DP1
Posts
Read-only
Total:
504
-->
@BearMan
I still don't understand why mafia would make it obvious that they liked the post. You claiming mafia is already weird.
*facepalm* Just... Read the day phase, I can't talk to you about something if you have no clue whats going on lol
-->
@Lunatic
Did you take your screenshot before or after you realized someone unliked it?
-->
@Lunatic
Why did Oro hard claim?
-->
@ILikePie5
Did you take your screenshot before or after you realized someone unliked it?
After.
-->
@Greyparrot
Why did Oro hard claim?
That was the previous game when he was scum. Not sure why.
-->
@Lunatic
After
How long after u realized?
-->
@ILikePie5
Literally right after reading your post where you said I could jave been the one to like it. I am MST utah ntw so the time on my phone should line up with the posts time of when we had that convo.
-->
@Lunatic
Literally right after reading your post where you said I could jave been the one to like it. I am MST utah ntw so the time on my phone should line up with the posts time of when we had that convo.
You could’ve been the one to unlike it lol is what I’m trying to say. There were 2. Now there’s one.
-->
@ILikePie5
Because thats the Wifom that you choose to believe not that it reflects reality.
Me unliking my post is a little too elaborate for no reason. Your arent spinning a compelling narrative here. Explain what mu motivation is as scum. Dont just say town cred either. I wasn't scum read.
-->
@ILikePie5
I don't read Luna as scum at this time.
VC
Lunatic [1/6] Pie
Speedrace [1/6] Lunatic
Greparrot [1/6] skittlez09
-->
@skittlez09
thoughts?
-->
@warren42
By the way, the profile picture is not necessarily a hint toward my identity. . . (Since this was a big deal in the last game)
Well I was right :)
Re: liking Luna's post, I agree with Bearman and Speed that liking a post (especially if you thought it was a joke) is not indicative of being mafia - at all. But I also agree with Luna that if you liked his post and want to fess up to it, that's fine, but I find it very odd that no one admitted to liking it. Had Speed or Bearman (or anyone) said "I liked your post cuz I thought you were kidding and that doesn't mean shit" I would fully understand and agree with that logic. But the fact that they're disagreeing with him and they nor anyone else will admit to being the one to like his post has me thinking that the person that liked the post WAS in fact acknowledging being a scum partner. Of course we have no idea who that was, but if Luna says he can deduce by time frame I would give that enough credibility to pressure them for a claim. @Luna, do you wanna pressure one of them in particular? I can look back and see what I think. I don't know Bearman so I'd probs have a harder time reading him than Speed.
It doesn't look like Bearman had posted yet when Luna made that "I win with the mafia" post. Do we suspect he was online?
The thing is if Speed was scum and liked Luna's post as a hint, I don't see why'd he follow that up with "Huh" and draw attention to it. If he is scum and believed Luna was scum with him, he'd want Luna to shut up and stay under the radar (unless he knew Luna was lying and was trying to get info about his role which is possible). Hmm.
Vtl Speed
-->
@Danielle
@Luna, do you wanna pressure one of them in particular? I can look back and see what I think. I don't know Bearman so I'd probs have a harder time reading him than Speed.
Speed so far is pinging me based on the omgus, it was reminiscent of BAMF mafia where I was town and called him as scum out dp1. I don't wanna tunnel it, but I also feel it's weird that it seemed he was trying to say I was contriving a gambit when only a few players had posted, but didn't say anything or press it. If he thought I was his scum partner I think it makes sense, but it didn't come off as particularly townie. Speed is my biggest read, and misterchris's post is up there based on trying to dismiss every option except for the one where I would actually have been scum. Seemed like he was trying to joke it off. Bearman and croc are noobs, they both have played a lot but generally post one liners, and nothing incredibly helpful most of the time so I would say they are "noobs" by those standards, though technically misterchris is newer, he is very smart and a big poster, I don't consider him a noob. That said I think judging bearman I am a little unsure whether to consider his reaction like a noob scum thing or just a noob town thing.
Btw, I am so glad you are on board here, I was losing my mind to these braindead townies before you got on lol.
-->
@Lunatic
Btw, I am so glad you are on board here
Aww thanks - we'll have a great day phase together and then you're on your own lol. I hope you're town.
I'm voting for Speed cuz everyone has posted and so far he's the best person to pressure for a claim.
I only know MisterChris from DP1 of last game but I didn't think anything was weird about his A.B.C. comment.
-->
@Danielle
Why are you acting like me and Bear are the only ones who could have liked the post?
And why would I like a post as a "hint" when the person who posted can't see who liked it?
-->
@whiteflame
thoughts on the phase so far?
-->
@Lunatic
Largely what I expected: a lot of accusations with little evidence. Enjoy watching it play out, though.
-->
@Speedrace
Why are you acting like me and Bear are the only ones who could have liked the post?
I didn't say that. I said you're the best person to pressure and I maintain that now.
And why would I like a post as a "hint" when the person who posted can't see who liked it?
I don't know if you liked it or not, but #1 Luna might assume it was liked by a player that was actively posting (which was you, Chris, Croc and Pie at the time) and #2 maybe that's what the "Huh" reply to him was for in response to draw attention to it. Not sure. Why would mafia make their profile picture their fake character claim? Scum misfires sometimes...
-->
@whiteflame
Largely what I expected: a lot of accusations with little evidence.
Haha
-->
@whiteflame
Largely what I expected: a lot of accusations with little evidence. Enjoy watching it play out, though.
You have no suspicions or reads?
-->
@whiteflame
Largely what I expected: a lot of accusations with little evidence. Enjoy watching it play out, though.
I'm glad you are enjoying yourself :) Now tell us how you will make yourself useful.
-->
@Danielle
@Lunatic
I have some suspicions, though nothing solid just yet. And to your question, Danielle, I think I’ll learn more from seeing how this round plays out than from trying to dissect each individual interaction. I haven’t had much experience in this, but I plan to develop it quickly.
-->
@whiteflame
I have some suspicions, though nothing solid just yet. And to your question, Danielle, I think I’ll learn more from seeing how this round plays out than from trying to dissect each individual interaction. I haven’t had much experience in this, but I plan to develop it quickly.
By round do you mean the entire game, or the day phase? The hard part about letting you do that, is if your mafia we have no way to identify you via behavior.
-->
@Lunatic
End of DP1. And yes, I recognize that. If people want me to establish my behaviors ahead of that point, they’re welcome to push on me. Not likely to say much to satisfy them, but the opportunity is there. If the goal is just to see how I puzzle through behaviors, then I can be much more thorough after I’ve gotten a chance to see how people vote and not just how they portray themselves in this forum. Any information we get will be suspect.