3RU7AL's avatar

3RU7AL

A member since

3
4
9

Total posts: 14,582

Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Tarik
does your god believe it is moral to extend the current 20 years of patent protections to 100 years of patent protections ?
🤷🏾‍♂️ 
so, in practical terms

how do we know which laws are "moral" and which are "immoral" ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Tarik
how do we translate that into practical terms ?
Love is practical.
does your god believe it is moral to extend the current 20 years of patent protections to 100 years of patent protections ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
SEIGNIORAGE
coinage has an interesting history

in india, when the foreign invaders wanted to control the population

they minted new coins

but nobody used them, and that makes a poor system of control

so, they did some research

and minted new coins with the image of a luck god that was popular in that region

and spread rumors about how lucky things happened to people who carried these lucky coins

people then wanted these coins, because, who doesn't need more good luck, and apparently, the more coins you hold, the more luck you get

they of course also cornered the market on wheat (leveraging physical force, aka, soldiers) and set an exchange rate of X number of coins for X measure of wheat
this gives the coin practical utility

but to really get things started, they need the broadest possible USERBASE

and that's where the "air-drop" comes in

representatives traveled the countryside, making sure every village gets some free coins and spreads the word about how lucky they are

and just like cocaine

once you get them hooked

the system becomes self-sustaining
Created:
2
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
do you consider yourself an atheist ?
No.
if you're not an atheist, how do you know what atheists believe ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Tarik
what does your god want me to do ?
Love
oh, good

how do we translate that into practical terms ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Double_R
LOL, nope, I'm still not playing your puerile game here, I'm simply stating the fact that it's innane to say Atheism "has absolutely nothing to do with  ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions".
So in other words; you are making a claim, on a debate site, and then when that claim is directly challenged with a counter argument your response is to dismiss it as a game and restate your original assertion “as fact”.

Why are you here then?

I'm not talking about your little Atheism cult with it's dogmatic beliefs, it's rituals and it's childish burden of proof game
I understand that it must be frustrating to hold a position which you cannot justify. If I held into such a position I’m pretty sure I would hate talking about the burden of proof as well. But it is a real thing that matters in the real world.

What’s ironic is that you claim to be seeking a better understanding of epistemological and ontological questions and yet you avoid one of the most basic concepts within it as if you owed it child support.

I also know what skepticism is, it is not a philosophic system that only applies to Theism, that's just your kiddie game, I'm talking about real world philosophical issues. 
I never suggested it only applied to theism. You made that up completely out of thin air, and in doing so demonstrate a remarkable level of close mindedness and confirmation bias.

Again, if you’re not interested in understanding the view points of those who disagree with you then why are you here?

And as far as “real world philosophical issues” goes, skepticism is again, one of the most basic ones. You are not actually seeking the conversation you claim to be seeking.
well stated
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
do you consider yourself an atheist ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
in the same exact way, you do not feel compelled to explain why you don't happen to believe in grondrakmorph the immortal
In the same exact way, I do not feel compelled to explain why you don't comprehend basic philosophy.
explaining your own beliefs

is one thing

explaining someone else's beliefs

is something else entirely
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
Being Gnostic Deist does not demand any philosophical comprehension.
do you have a specific question ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
the minimum qualification is simply

to be unconvinced of the reality of any specific gods
OK, and that has something to do with epistemology.
being unconvinced does not demand any epistemological explanation

in the same exact way, you do not feel compelled to explain why you don't happen to believe in grondrakmorph the immortal
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
You got your answer.

Yes, You have convinced me your lord nanabozho is a real god to you.
the question is about whether or not you feel the need to explain why you are unconvinced

your opinion about whether or not i am personally convinced

is not part of the question
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
Yes, You have convinced me your lord nanabozho is a real god to you.
i thought you said you needed to explain the epistemological and ontological framework that informs your belief on this particular manner
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
Which God are you Deist about, be specific.
NOUMENON
Yep, another one of your oh so kewl words, I happen to know what it means, so I know it is a non-sequitor, maybe you should go look it up.  
some people call it, EIN SOF
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
Atheism has absolutely nothing to do with  ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
Yes, You have convinced me your lord nanabozho is a real god to you.
why do you not feel the need to explain WHY ?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
Yes, You have convinced me your lord nanabozho is a real god to you.
do you feel the need to EXPLAIN why ?
Created:
1
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Shila
Alluri Sitarama Raju and Komaram Bheem were real-life Indian freedom fighters, albeit ones who lived decades apart and never actually met. [**]
Created:
0
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Shila
Like the Americans that withdrew from Vietnam and Afghanistan without firing a shot so did the British leave India without firing a shot.
shots were fired in all of your examples
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
Which God are you Deist about, be specific.
NOUMENON
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
You have convinced me your lord nanabozho is a real god to you.
do you feel the need to EXPLAIN why you do NOT believe our lord nanabozho is a real god to you personally ?

(please answer with a "yes" or a "no")
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
do you routinely feel the need to EXPLAIN why you are UNCONVINCED that our lord nanabozho is a real god ?

(hint, this is a "yes" or "no" question)
You have convinced me your lord nanabozho is a real god to you.
is that a "yes" or a "no" ?
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
You have convinced me your lord nanabozho is a real god to you.
but not real to you
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Double_R
None of this is atheism. All of this is in the realm of skepticism.
atheism is what you have before you LEARN about a god and or gods and or the goddess and or goddesses 

that's my point here

you don't have to "justify" atheism

because it is where everyone starts
Created:
1
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Shila
India gained its independence from Britain without firing a single shot.
not exactly

i think the brits might have fired a few shots
Created:
0
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Elliott
Although I do find all the pageantry and ritual fascinating in a surreal sort of way.
hypnotic even
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
do you routinely feel the need to EXPLAIN why you are UNCONVINCED that our lord nanabozho is a real god ?

(hint, this is a "yes" or "no" question)
Created:
0
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Shila
India gained its independence from Britain without firing a single shot.
not exactly

Created:
0
Posted in:
How do you define "God"...
-->
@Shila
If the truth is not found in the Bible then Gnostics  believe in a different source like special knowledge. That special knowledge must be superior than the word of God.
GNOSIS = DIRECT EXPERIENCE
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
do you routinely feel the need to EXPLAIN why you are UNCONVINCED that our lord krishna is a real god ?

what about PANGU ?

why don't you believe in PANGU ?
I have not touched topics on Krishna or Pangu or other gods.
You are claiming you god is Krishna. “why you are UNCONVINCED that our lord krishna is a real god ?”
Your profile says you follow Taoism. Are you lying or just confused?
try answering at least one of my two questions first
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
To prove there is a rationale behind their lack of conviction.
Same reason why Theists are are asked to prove or show evidence there is a god.
do you routinely feel the need to EXPLAIN why you are UNCONVINCED that our lord krishna is a real god ?

what about PANGU ?

why don't you believe in PANGU ?
Created:
1
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Shila
India gained its independence from Britain without firing a single shot.
not exactly
Created:
0
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Elliott
that's what they want you to think
Can you elucidate on that?
only SOME members of the royal family are required to "show up" for SOME ceremonies

and there is a lot of activity that does NOT get reported in the press
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
Most Atheists are better informed and educated knowing what they are up against having declared they are nonbelievers or Atheists. They have to be prepared to answer why they chose atheism and why they are going against conventional beliefs and what are the rational and bases for their atheism.
In short they knowledge base is questioned, which is the very roots of epistemology.
why does any atheist need to "justify" what they are merely UNCONVINCED of ?
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
I know what the principles of your religious faith are, and I know just how important that innane burden of proof game is to your fundamentalism, I but you don't have to let it make you completely incoherent about everything.   

Out here in the real world,it is a nonsense statement to say that the subject matter, Atheism, "has absolutely nothing to do with  ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions".   You can redefine words all you want, your deeply held religious convictions don't change the factthat Atheism entails ontological and epistemological questions.  

But don't worry, you can still turn Atheism into a religion if you want, you haven't lost your ability to blather on about the childish burden of proof game, you can be as irrational as you want,  nobody expects more from you, you can even evangelize your faith here, but you don't get to insist that we join your cult.
i'm not "preaching atheism"

i'm a gnostic deist
Created:
1
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@Elliott
You are permanently under the scrutiny of the media
that's what they want you to think
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Tarik
what does your god want me to do ?
Created:
1
Posted in:
The Queen
-->
@zedvictor4
What would life be like if we got up every morning and had to rethink everything.
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
In these debates and others, epistemology aims to answer questions such as "What do we know?", "What does it mean to say that we know something?", "What makes justified beliefs justified?", and "How do we know that we know?".
anyone can self-identify as an "atheist"

the minimum qualification is simply

to be unconvinced of the reality of any specific gods

being unconvinced does not REQUIRE any understanding of epistemology

epistemology is more specifically about HOW you know what you know

with emphasis on the LIMITS of what a human can know
Created:
2
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
The word "Atheism" has to do with what someone "believes",  "Epistemology" is the branch of philosophy that involves "knowledge" and "belief", note that both definitions involve the word "belief", so it follows that the word "Atheism" has something to do with the word "Epistemology".  
anyone can self-identify as an "atheist"

the minimum qualification is simply

to be unconvinced of the reality of any specific gods

being unconvinced does not REQUIRE any understanding of epistemology

epistemology is more specifically about HOW you know what you know

with emphasis on the LIMITS of what a human can know
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
Atheists like Christians have to deal with ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions to make clear their positions.
how do you use ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions to make your position clear ?
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Double_R
This is the exact same thing as arguing that something is wrong because it’s illegal. In that example, according to your logic, the state would be the “objective standard” for morality.
moral legalism
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
If you think ATHEISM has absolutely nothing to do with  ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions then you don't know what the words ONTOLOGICAL and EPISTEMOLOGICAL mean.
please explain
Oh pulease, just get a dictionary,  look up all three words, try to understand the definition of all three words and you will see that the statement "ATHEISM has absolutely nothing to do with  ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions" is simply an innane statement.
i know the definitions

please explain specifically how these concepts are REQUIRED 
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
If you think ATHEISM has absolutely nothing to do with  ONTOLOGICAL and or EPISTEMOLOGICAL questions then you don't know what the words ONTOLOGICAL and EPISTEMOLOGICAL mean.
please explain
Created:
1
Posted in:
How do you define "God"...
-->
@Tradesecret
And it was then that truth as it were "dawned on me". 
GNOSTIC
Created:
1
Posted in:
White Privilege - Fact or Fiction
-->
@Shila
White privilege is a fact.
if it cannot be measured scientifically, and is not logically-necessary, it does not qualify as a fact
Created:
1
Posted in:
The Interaction problem and Dualism
-->
@Shila
the automatic behavior of the moth appears to demonstrate a LACK OF CONSCIOUSNESS
Created:
0
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
Even Christian’s need to know what their metaphysical beliefs are.
Even Christian’s need to know the distinction between knowledge and beliefs.
maybe, but it is not a PREREQUISITE
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Sidewalker
I know that, there are plenty of people who don't know what the words "ONTOLOGICAL" and "EPISTEMOLOGICAL" mean, but you don't usually see people like that using them in a sentence.   
what is your specific claim ?
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Shila
By giving them the definitions, at least they will know what they mean.

Ontological definition: relating to the branch of metaphysics dealing with the nature of being.

Epistemological definition: relating to the theory of knowledge, especially with regard to its methods, validity, and scope, and the distinction between justified belief and opinion.
none of these have anything at all to do with "being a christian"

in the exact same way

none of these have anything at all to do with "being NOT a christian" (NOT a theist)
Created:
1
Posted in:
Atheism and humanism are completely contradictory
-->
@Double_R
After all this time you have finally made your position clear; your only conception of morality is that which aligns with god.
even if we accept this as 100% TRUE

how the heck do we know exactly what god wants us to do ?
Created:
1