ILikePie5

Lunatic is VERY much known for giving traditional roles for town/mafia as a town flavor. He did it in a game once with Popular. 

The question is, why would I fake claim something that I knew is scum affiliated according to that post

I am against this idea, but since my role is a passive role, I see no reason as to not claim since I don't have anything

Why didn't you SOP claim this?

np1 I watched whiteflame, no one visited 

The only way ComputeNerd could be mafia is if he’s telling the truth on his character but not on his character’s affiliation or role. Bam but based on theme analysis. I don’t think Roy Petty is mafia. What mafia role would one even give him? To me, every role that makes sense for this character is a town one.

Please explain the need for me to claim

It was a tough call, though I did it by PoE. I didn’t want to pick someone who may not demonstrate that they couldn’t vote, so that left ComputerNerd out. Didn’t want to pick anyone who was a target for claims/lynches in the last DP since my goal was not to obstruct efforts to get them to claim, so Max and Sui were out. GP will eventually be a necessary lynch, so he’s out. From there, I just removed everyone in my uncertain pile in case their claims became reasons to FoS them, which left Mharman, DD and Badger. That choice was random. Glad I didn’t choose DD.

4. Can you please vote anyone to confirm that you haven’t stolen Badger’s voter

Sure. I think it’s also worth confirming that Badger can’t be voted for, so I’ll do that if someone else doesn’t.

VTL Max

There's no world in which we don't mass claim here. 

My character is Russ Langmore. My role is the Emissary. It’s not really much of a power role if you can even call it that, but I was given knowledge at the start of the game that Roy Petty was in the game and ComputerNerd was the player who got him as a character. I realized based on game theory that there was likely a reason why I was given that knowledge, so I concluded he was a power role, cop being the most likely one. Although the prospect of him being a vigilante did cross my mind at one point. In one post I did mention bomb, but that was more just advice for future games since ComputerNerd is a noob.

Also, I’m confident Disc sacrificed himself for ComputerNerd.

Alright, just saw this come up. I’ll full claim:

I’m Charles Wilkes and I’m the Magistrate. I picked someone who I knew would vote and was not either Sui or GP (given that they were targets at the end of the last GP) and ended up picking Badger. In this DP, he cannot vote and no one can vote for him.

Mainly doing this for POE reasons. Unless someone thinks I’d do this as a scum Magistrate, it stands as confirmation of my role and a pretty good indication that I am town. Given that we just mislynched an important PR and lost a protective role (who was hopefully protecting someone else), we need to start figuring this out.

I speak Spanish fluently dumb ass. As well as German. 

Pie's parents are immigrants and he has Trump as his profile picture. 

Not American. Why must all the votes occur during the same day? Why is it not a specified range, for example, 3 days?

Sorry about the hasty unvote. Was just trying to be fast given the small amount of time.

That may not be enough for some but given the amount of time left it’s enough for me for now. 

Last vote count earth had one vote on them and it was me. Since then, computernerd and Mikal have added votes on them. 3/7 for Earth

We need some pressure on Earth. If we can’t get any active pressure on him we’re basically forced to go for Grey. I am okay with a Grey lynch, but we at least need to get full claim from Earth and Airmax.

Looking back I don't think badger is suspicious for disagreeing with pie on lynching less active players, just a difference in philosophy.

These dudes have made 0 posts and somehow you're still reading them. I think lurking is scummy. I think these dudes are not playing the game. 

I don't really want to second guess at this point. This DP will be over soon. I've outed my reads. There's some I've grown a little more uncertain of.

I want Sui. 

I think there should be forced activity. I think Max and ComputerNerd are just not playing the game. Whether they're mafia or not. 

It's a guess. And the rest of us making all these posts for us to then just guess on two inactives... is fucking sad. 

to random to read or have coherent thoughts 

I'll tell you what. Let's lynch Sui. If he's not mafia I self-vote D3.

Not D2 for reasons, but D3 I self-vote, no backpedalling, I'm dead. 

We can vote Greyparrot D2 or something. That's not a mafia deal, right? One ML on an unclaimed townie for a mafia. 

No there isn't. He hasn't posted. Am I gonna click on his profile and see if he was online and lynch based on that and call that a game? No. I would be fucking embarrassed to lol.

Yes that's so fucking boring. Can you not see that? What are we even doing in this game if we're sitting around talking about people who literally haven't made a post?

No it wouldn't. Mhar's posts are transparent af. He entered an empty game and made the only posts available to him to make. 

The logic for mafia is that they'd sit quiet. Every post a mafioso makes is just another to give them away.

Lynch an inactive and they turn mafia, it's a fluke. That's a boring game, dude. 

Go with your gut on any active player here, and maybe let's have fun, and maybe let's learning something about actually reading people. There's literally nothing to read about Max.

I have largely townread around him + that thing I wrote about his first posts.

I think we're not even attempting to play this game like it should be played if we're lynching inactives or obvious survivors. It's just a roles lottery then. 

I think this DP is going to end on a NL. Vote Sui. Lynching someone who's not posted at all is no fun, mafia or not. 

I want to pressure Max. He's had the time to post his tourney and do live mafia but no time to commentate on mafia. Seems lurkish