ILikePie5

If he’s the Bomb, then that’s not the worst thing to lose, and I’m not seeing enough reason to go for Disc at this point, though I will note that his absence from the lynch (when he is the only other viable choice) is stark.

VTL Pie

They might kill me tonight.

Essentially, I just don't think it makes for this game to have a bomb . We have a 3xcop and a tracter + doc. To have a bomb that kills lethal actions w/o a Vig seems very overpowered

What do you think of Whiteflame's backdown?

Nah this Disc train is pretty fucking stupid

1. Cop is in this game. It would make sense for there to be a Miller in this game. Works better than a Bomb claim

2. Pie was originally claiming only scum can kill him until I asked about vig

3. Pie was originally hesitant and refused to mass character claim because he hadn't thought of a claim yet

Sorry, I'm not hopping on Disc

That bomb claim is suspect and lunatic did want to vote pie. I guess I will honor lunatic and do what he would have wanted, if he were still alive. Let's lynch pie in honor of our fallen comrade

Unvote VTL Pie

Would a Mafia!Pie fakeclaim Charzard?

Pie repeatedly said that he wouldn't have claimed Charzard if he's mafia because Voltorb would be better. That is WIFOM.

This is clearly WIFOM. 

The Disc lynch is still on the table. I’d like to see someone other than Pie and Evil support it, but I’ve been on Pie because I feel the reasoning there is slightly stronger. Asked you a bit ago why you voted Disc, would appreciate an answer.

Is disc a viable target still or do I need to lynch pie to end the dp?

If it's Disc or Pie or don't really have a strong conviction either way.   Based on characters, Mewtwo still seems scummier than Charizard.  However, I don't know Pokémon.  Lunatic was convinced Charizard was the scummier claim. 

Whiteflame seems to feel the same way. 

I think Supa has a pretty good gut when it comes to Pie.  I don't have a strong argument here, I am more trusting Whiteflame & Supa's convictions.  

Charzard would work for something like odd night PGO or something. Voltorb would work better. Bombs kill themselves along with who tried to kill them. Charzard doesn't work like that.

Its funny that you say Mewtwo's justification for being miller is odd when you are Charzard claiming to be bomb.

Additionally I still think you been trying to buddy with me the whole game.

This isn’t good reasoning, Evil. It’s good reason for being frustrated, but it’s not going to recruit anyone to VTL Disc. At least with Pie, he’s giving me some utility-based reasons to vote, though that doesn’t really tell me why Disc is more likely to be scum (looks a bit like weak bussing to me). It’s not at all unusual for someone to sus another player on the basis that they are largely absent from the game. Hell, we did it last game and landed on scum (Poly) partially as a result of his inactivity. Anyone can come up with any excuse for not being around. We can’t verify it. You may have been absent for perfectly good reasons, and even if you we’re, the VTL functions as a way to  push you to increase your activity. It didn’t start a substantial wagon so you weren’t in danger of actually being lynched, either.

I am going to lynch Pie. The circumstances around Evil voting Discipulus_Didicit and the fact Pie is always on mind keeps me from voting anyone else 

Vtl Pie

Why are we on Disc

I'm currently most sus of Pie and Disc. I still think their Pokémon claims stand out too much to ignore. If Evil remains intransigent when it comes to providing his claim, then I'll have to change my vote and reconsider a possible Oro/Evil pair. But for now, I'm sussing Pie just a bit more than I am Disc. I think that both his role and claim stand out as odd enough to set them apart, and given that we know there was a Cop, I think there's at least more reason to believe there is a Miller than that there is a Bomb.

VTL Pie

We do still have time in the DP and I want us to use it, but for now, I think Pie is the best pick.

I'll need to sleep on it.

While I tend to lean left socially and politically, I almost get more pissed off by ultra libtards like Brie Larsen then I do by  the dumbass redneck conservatives. I refused to watch Captain Marvel after she displayed her retarded views on gender equality. But she also isn't really an actor worth watching. Kind of like Kristen Stewart, just seems dead in the face and feels like she's reading lines on a paper/ 

We also need to consider that mafia might be fakeclaiming their characters.

He isn't. I just put up a reads list in haste. 

But that might not make sense. If Miller is "Seems to be like X (mafia), but isn't." then that implies the theme is Good vs evil, but that might not be the case. The theme could be anything. Gary would be a better miller pick.

Maybe the theme is good vs evil and mafia is team rocket.

0

You don't watch comedy!? I mean that explains some things ;-)

jk 

Townreads

Whiteflame

Supas

My justification is that is I am in every city healing pokemon, but only Pokemon. I am going to be irritated if I am flavored to only heal pokemon.

I disagree with the Mewtwo thing. It would not make sense if there is a "Villains mafia"  theme where villians are town and good guys the mafia. Depending on what the theme is, whether or not Mewtwo learns what friendship is from Ash is pointless because the theme could be something completely unrelated to the fact that Mewtwo is evil or not.

scum team have no reason to let that reveal happen. Docgor is probably dead np2, and I will die np3

Wylted's claim

Don't rely on justification. My Justification is short and Mewtwo doesn't make much sense either.

Evil genius blocking me is Indicative of him being some sort of alt. He probably has more experience than he is letting on. 

Not sure if he is pretending g to be a noob to disguise his identity or disguise that he is scum though.

you totally discarded my reasons for being a newbie..now that has totally given me full confidence that you are scum .. you have outed yourself and you being mewtwo doesn’t help either

That wasn’t part of the hypothetical. I always find it telling when someone cannot answer a hypothetical without concocting new factors to suit their position and then bootstrapping them onto the original question.

You understand full well that this hypothetical was intended to be as simple as possible in order to focus in on a very simple idea which you are not trying to obfuscate, so this is just dishonest.

As far as you can tell, all doctors are of equal qualifications. Now what?

I’m not playing the ‘what if’ game.

Read what I said to Athias. In general, quantity of professional opinion is quality. 

How is 9 doctors telling you that you need surgery indistinguishable from 9 friends telling you that you won’t be harmed if you stab yourself in the eye?

Are you saying its better to self-diagnose when it comes to serious health problems? Let’s run your logic to its conclusion. 

I was just thinking we should all agree there's too many VANILLAs.

If you are selecting from a cast of characters for VANILLA-like qualities, does rival Gary Oak or Narrator really qualify as VANILLA. 

I'd say no but MISTY is like his best friend- she doesn't seem very VANILLA either.

I don't know.  If I had to pick between WhiteFlame and EG, I'd probably pick Whiteflame- his character claim is off-brand and his play has been quite reserved, in spite of being the subject matter expert. No real scum hunting.  WF is probably also liklier SCUM than any first-timer game mechanic wise.

My justification is that I am popular and help a lot of people. I know it doesn't make sense, but that is the paraphrased justification 

I really hate that it is the same role 2 games in a row, but I have no control over that

I really wanted to wait a day, but since everyone else seems to be claiming. Innocent Child dp4. It's why I thought a cop made no sense.  The tracker on top of that seems really town sided