ILikePie5

Unvote right now on the off chance scum has the politician vote.

When can you claim? Give a time.

Also Casey was like everyone's top town read and scum likely needed a fake claim ASAP. So it's not unbelievable that even a pre-2000 claim would kill Casey and janitor them.

Actually no. Anyone could use the role, they just need to choose a different show for it.

Because of pre/post 2000 thing, correct? Noted

Pie pops to to ask who won the cop, I answer and he disappeared. Hmm.

I did, I submitted daycop because I didn't think sensor was a daytime role.

Also, in response to your question to me earlier, I already fullclaimed, I'm family Feud which is before 2000.

This mathematically makes it impossible for scum to manipulate the vote to a different result than what town agrees to.

Thoughts?

There's a chance scum would fake the use of a cop if they won, but I think this still increases Earth's odds of being town.

Is a politician vote a vote thief? If so, in case mafia won, we should all agree on a lynch through non-official voting before anyone submits an official vote.

Game for today: Today's game idea will not be trivia this time, instead the prize for todays winner will be selected by all of the players. All players can choose to submit three names. The person with the most votes at the end of the day phase will be the winner of selected prize.

Votes must be listed 1-3, one being the strongest, 3 being the weakest. Votes in the number 1 will count heavier than number three votes for example.

1. Playername

2. Playername2

3. Playername 3

The mafia team will submit votes together, not separately. 

Prizes:

The winner will be distributed at the end of the day phase.

For town: a choice between a 1x watcher/tracker will be given

For mafia: 1x vanillizer (Can permanently turn someone into a vanilla)

Discussion about votes can happen, but no requiring proof of votes IE screenshots etc. If people wanna lie about who they voted for, they can, whether they are town or scum. 

Good luck all, and have fun!

I know after that claim I would be lynched it's precisely why I wouldn't make that claim as scum. I would just take the provided fake claims.

This looks opportunistic on your part. Why would I claim something this ridiculous as scum?

I thought we were getting one claim.  Are we just mass claiming this DP now?  I can if it's a popular enough thing but WF essentially stopped one step short of claiming which is good enough for me. I can see me claiming and then all of a sudden we have people be retarded and then say "well we did agree to one claim and even though whiteflame is really easy to guess and even though wylted full claimed AI guess we go after mharman now"

At some point we have to stop giving the scum team information and just fucking lynch somebody. Fine whiteflame seems confirmable enough we can wait a day but we need to lynch somebody and my vote is Earth or Moozer given he is merely claiming his role is confirmable but not affiliation

Who's the third besides WF and Mharman?

Mikal's thoughts feel really close to my own right now, and given that I know my perspective on claims is coming from a town place, I also feel like he's playing in a pretty pro-town way. Him, Savant, and Casey are probs my strongest townreads right now, don't see myself being easily wrong on one of them.

I don't really support a whiteflame claim, I don't see what he's done that's scummy and getting a claim just for the sake of getting claims feels pointless.

Claims are meant to be a situational tool for the rest of the game to improve their read on the player who's claiming, not as something that's arbitrarily applied to players who aren't being townread.

If you are asking potential combos. Off hand I have no clue. I just am posting an order based off who I consider more towny to not. 

I think it’s unlikely Austin and Wylted are scum 

It’s more like they are town on town or scum vs town. 

That is the only major dynamic between two people I’ve picked up on enough to say I think there is a possible either or 

No I’ve said this above

Earth 

Bananna 

Wylted 

Mharm 

Moozer 

Is prob my Poe order right now. I just am Semi confident with the front two. Not that I think another claim is bad but doing this all on dp1 seems risky. I still want to revisit earth and read through like I said but today has been shit and trying to get on the computer to do that. 

I mean, I’m not surprised you’re sussing me, I just don’t love the reasoning. You know well by this point that indecision, particularly in DP1, is not at all unusual for me. I’m presenting my reads differently than normal, but that also includes last game where I was scum. As for the frustration, it’s your perception I guess. I’ve said my piece on that front. 

With all the soft claims and hard claims at this point, I think we have enough.

Just picking someone who hasn’t claimed to claim and then using that as something to pick a lynch off of feels bad.

On god would rather pick someone that feels bad, claimed or not and just lock in and send it. We are giving out so much info with more claims. 

I really don’t like this