ILikePie5

WHY DIDN'T Y'ALL LYNCH PIE

why not? is that SOP? I was happy with this play. It had a pretty big town benefit. 

Been through enough games back to back that I think I’ll sit this one out.

Even with less than 10 minutes left in the DP1, I was sweating that whiteflame was going to get lynched.

I just want to say that I've played in like 4 games with Water and I've scum read him in every single game, and in every single game he was town. I've scum read Water when I was scum and knew he wasn't scum. I've even scum read Water while I was MODDING and thought... am I tripping? Did I make him scum by accident? He's scum, right? That's happened twice lol. He is one of a kind. 

Watch/tracker are useless cause of the ninja.

Well damn. I thought I played well this game too :(

Yeah maf was OP. They would have controlled the day after a SINGLE mislynch with the hated townie. Which is exactly what happened. 

I also cannot read Pie for shit lol 

I did vote drafterman DP1, I was willing to work with you on that. then no one joined and someone suggested White again so I changed back. But I was always willing to lynch drafterman or White and read them scum for most of the game. I probs never would have lynched Pie though had he not done what he did to Water, which I assume he only did because scum knew they had the win no matter what

You are VERY hard to read. I'd have town piled you for so so long. 

I would love to go back to White's prior games to see if he did that many scummy things. The list was extensive and was not limited to the low profile thing that you all were focused on. I also noted his logical inconsistencies, 180's avoidance, pushing lynches that he wouldn;t join etc. No one cared though. 

Honestly Pie threw me. Pie was playing town as hell. I was so confused when he came on and challenged Waters. But I was like wtf would waters lie about that knowing Pie could immediately say it didn't happen, which is the only reason I help onto the town read of Waters. 

WTF would scum Water's motive have been to claim Pie visited Supa, if he didn't actually see Pie visit Supa! It's immediately verifiable and would result in his lynch.

Nice extra dig Scum to have me vote for myself with your vote steal. 

i watched supa np1 and he was visited by pie and speed. speed prob used vig on him but was then killed by maf. idk what pie was doing there

i'd like to clarify the full claim i made last dp. i am not a tracker i am a WATCHER. 

did you visit supa?

Water is lying.

I am Yukon Cornelius. In the Rudolph movie, I spend my life looking for ”silver & gold” (in reality it was peppermint, but this isn't revealed until later in the movie). I’m a kind man, and I do not mind using my skills to help navigate others & save Christmas. I am a tracker & win with town.

You win if the cult is the dominant party at the end of the game. 

Fake character claim options: XX, XX

Fake role claim options: XX, XX, XX, XX or XX 

Speedrace: You are RALPHIE PARKER. Sure 

So there is nothing inherently town about this behavior from white, seems to be what you are conceding. 

last game it didn't matter that there was an innocent child but this game it does so that's why i'm questioning the role itself

Your basis for suspecting Bullish is silly. Do you know how many games i have been in where scum said, in response to a valid role claim of an otherwise non suspicious townie, "oh but could be X twist to the role, or could be TP, or could be totally random game mechanic," just to undermine the townread in hopes of a mislynch.

I have cited the inconsistencies and how you are behaviorally playing as someone scared to fall on anyone's radar, even when you fall on it non-threateningly

I think one of Whiteflam or Bullish is likely scum, but not both. White because he's contributing regularly in a non-contributory way. It feels forced, like he's playing narrator without actually hunting scum. He echos obvious observations or statements and anything remotely novel he says he seems willing to backdown from immediately as almost a gut reaction to realizing he's drawn attention to himself. I have never played with White before, so this is based on no prior information.

Conversely, if White is town, I think Bullish is scum because he jumped on White so fast and almost came across like he saw White as an easy target. 

Didn't you just vote pie for fluff posting?

but you pre-empting the argument that danielle had to have randomized gives credence to the theory that you pre-empted the argument.

why would you want a third claim? Unless you have reason to suspect Supa, giving more info to scum is not helpful. Speed would be my only exception in this regard. ;-)

can you character claim, i want some more information before going any further with my theory.

i mean, we already have an anti town role (innocent child) the chances of having a 3rd party right now aren't as low as the chances of having a two anti town roles.

Pressure for what?

That1 is sus for bring up jester. Bringing up 3rd parties is a classic scum tell.