ILikePie5

So lynching the Hated or letting it live is mechanically the same.

If you are jester then this a genius move, Danielle hates jester so I highly doubt you are one unless Danielle really feels like fucking with us for Christmas

I guess that's an anti-town role to counter balance the innocent child. Depending on if we get a lot of anti town roles claimed or not, I buy it for balance purposes. The obvious statement here is that the longer the game goes on and you aren't killed, the more likely it is we don't make it to lylo since hypothetically scum could insta hammer you.

Character claim?

I think my role is an SOP, but I am unsure. Erring on the side of it being one, I am hated. I disagree with my character being hated since they are an x-mas fav. of mine, but alas Danielle must have bad taste. 

Be happy to recommend some fantasy books if you're interested

yes, please

So you recommend the series?  I haven't found a new fantasy series that I liked for a long time.  I didn't really the Game of Thrones, even, though I eventually got into the TV series.  I hear Hulu is working on a TV series.

Any preferences? I'm leaning toward Christmas or 2020 to be festive  cuz I could do WIFE Mafia at any time :P 

I was upvoting some of your posts where you were on track and hoping you would push it harder lol. It was frustrating to watch at times. But you did well over all and had pretty good reads after dp1.

I think on balance mafia might have been a bit more powered, but keep in mind we didn't have a fake role claim for whatever that's worth. Supa gave us Cop which I thought was too risky to use in a game with a Dreamer and Bride. It did help that we could claim our real characters and such (I didn't)  but not having to struggle for that should be standard for themed games IMO. I will say that including so many n00bs made this a difficult game for town which I really did believe from the start, though warren and Ragnar could have alleviated that had they participated more.  

I'd say ragnar, speedrace and whiteflame did alright for the most part til they got distracted with that1 last phase. They got scum read or drowned out by worse reads alot unfortunately.

I resent this.  I posted the majority of analysis in the game and came up with like 5 fake role claims all on my own lol pfft. Pretty sure we woulda done just fine. 

Surprise surprise, there was no theme split. I did not make a noticeable theme for any characters that were in here. In regards to the characters, only 1 character per show was given. There were not more than 1 character from each show, so if anyone were to claim 2 characters from a show, that should’ve been a reason to FoS them out. But the relation from characters to alignment was non-existent.

Pie using his Vig Shot x1 on Speed was stupid as FUUCK. You’re using your only shot on someone in DP1 when you haven’t listened to any others in DP. I’m glad that Water got the redirect and targeted the Hated, but TBH I don’t think he knew about Pie’s role and just got a stroke of pure luck. He says he was sus of Pie, but didn’t target other people on the Speed wagon. Pie was extremely tunnel vision the entire game, and for no reason. 

Given that it is MYLO the question is, do we have enough of a read on someone to risk a mislynch or do we No Lynch and let Mafia narrow things down. One less person means greater the odds of getting scum.

However, with a known killing role, a redirector, and a motivator, there is also a risk in NLing. If pie kills a townie, or is redirected to a townie, that's game over. If Ragnar motivates mafia, that's probably game over depending on their abilities. But also if Pie is - for example - a third party killing role, Town can't afford to lynch him anymore meaning we have to hope Mafia takes him out at some point.

All that said, I'm fairly prone to go policy on this one.

VTNL

I could see that. So could Vigilante/Serial Killer :) 

Hi shit are we at the point where I should full claim?

On NP2 I chose Pie.  If he visited me I wanted him to die for obvious reasons. I was told this action was "confirmed." 

Speed said he saw roles for whitelfame, right? So one of those roles had to be tracker. But tracker isn't an exclusively Town role, so I'm not sure what Speed was buying.

In fact, since the roles should be roles from the game, I'm wondering what three roles he saw that are exclusively town. Vig and Beloved Princess and Motivator are the only ones that are exclusively (or near enough so) to be Town. All the rest could very well be maf sided.

8. WaterPhoenix- scum: trash player trash scum trash town

The Motivator may each night target a player, allowing them one extra use of any action available to them on the following night. Why would he target drafterman?

It's hard to explain my role PM without wording it verbatim. Removing fluff stuff about my character: I'm Albedo from Overlord. Basically I have a high defensive power which allows me to transfer damage onto my armor instead. Because I am a very powerful winged beauty that can deflect kills, I am a Siren. I can target a player and if they target me that night, they die. On NP1 I was role blocked. On NP2 I was not role blocked.  @warren are you a Jailkeeper? Cuz if not I have a theory about who scum might be. Gonna post the rest of my reads now. 

redirector is usually town and bus driver is usually maf apparently

He did not say either way. My understanding of the role is that the default is people are notified.

He should have received the result that he is motivated. The lack of an extra action to use, doesn't change the fact that he is motivated and can do twice as much of nothing.

That is very true, he apparently does not. Yet, he should still have one result to share all the same.

Actually that was my thought too. Vote Thief seemed anti-town to me at first, but thinking about it further, I suppose it can be actually pretty helpful in a situation such as now where a quick mafia hammer is all it takes to end the game. 

BTW, if I were scum making up a role, I definitely wouldn't choose something as scummy as that. 

Please share the results you got last night.