ILikePie5

Should I full claim at this point? I basically have already heavily hinted that I am a strong kill choice at this point, so I guess I might as well

I was just about to ask you that

I don't like the ideal of a mass claim after seeing what earth revealed. That is something where we can have a lot of confidence in a lynch and I wouldn't be surprised if we have more roles that can give us a lot of confidence that a lynch is scum and if we put these people up as easy pickings for the scum team than it will give us less confidence in our lynch choices

Interesting idea. I can see that being the split, though the problem with this kind of theme split analysis is that you have to assume that at least one member of the scum team did not fake their character claim, and that more often than not does not happen. That's the problem with theme analysis when you don't have are least one scum flip. 

They have one night kill

Remember that dead player still vote. If we all agree beforehand on each vote randomly, then the last person alive is a matter of random chance. If there are 2 mafia, we then have 80% odds of victory.

I feel like in this game, the more information we have in this game, the better our outcome is going to likely be. When we lack flips and there is only 2 NP's that can have actions, I think this is a rare occasion that I think we could force mass claims. Normally everyone knows my meta and this is going against my meta, but from what I'm collecting there's only 2 phases where roles can be used. The rest comes down to behavior and such. Giving scum time to think of claims would be detrimental and we do know that role PM's did not go out til today and the DP came out right after meaning scum have not given time to give claims. I am all for it  due to the nature of this game

Was hoping to take a break to work on the design for the next game. I'll consider it, though.

I get like I was playing out of my mind in some areas this game, but I could’ve done so much better smh.

Wrong actually. We asked Wylted about that he said a lot had them but many also didn’t have them. As soon as he said that I just disregarded that reason as bad wifom that it was, since town also had people with no brackets 

I’m not banning Greyparrot from my games. Dude just needs to adjust how he plays. I’m ok with having some non-tryhards as well.

I would love to grow the community to a size where we can separate the tryhards from the casuals, but that’s not gonna happen for some time.

Oh yeah another thing that could have fucked us was that we all sucked at fake claiming this game so basically we kind of all used each others roles. If we had been lynched in a different order would would have fucked each other lol 

Agreed and to be fair town was equally as guilty for lynching her. I know I was scum but she did seem genuine town from my pov. Her logic was bad but that’s to be expected from noobs, not sure why she is expected to act differently than others did when they were new. I remember a lot of you when you were new and big mistakes you all made lol. 

I am not being a simp but we're doing a lot of talking down to banana who took a lot of time off of playing because she felt that she was not being treated as an equal. 

I know we have to balance the current pool of players enjoying the game and being welcoming but given the state of the game here, perhaps we should lean heavier on welcoming.

Look. You had some good luck, you can’t get too mad when the luck reverses mid game.

At the end of the day, you still won because scum played better than town. GG.

Mafia theme was all around death, it was like life vs death but in Wylted language

town did NOT need more confirmation lol

Oh and thanks for playing everyone! It was nice to play a game where I could be active (been awhile of just filling in to have enough players).

We didn’t. If we did we wouldn’t have waived a night kill and could have won earlier