ILikePie5

If you're town I prefer you go for Pie, see above under "the plan." I think town is being too quick to clear him and I'd like coverage from him being scum. If you're scum, sparing Joebob will look sus for him btw.

Pie – Lean town. I thinkwe’re too quick to clear Pie here. Yes, being told of Casey’s role could beconsidered a little OP if scum has it, but what’s the point if town has it?Casey gets confirmed regardless by virtue of her ability. If it’s so Pie canget himself lynched so Casey can reverse it, why didn’t he do so? It would’veconfirmed them both. I think there’s a real possibility of Pie being a day rolecop and scum. 

So you guys still want me giving reads? 

Yeah, see I don't feel any incentive do do anything if your just going to assume I am mafia no matter what. At this point just mislynch me, i'll kill vader, and I'll say I told you so later. Doesn't seem like anyone else is willing to lynch the obvious mafia here so luckily I will do it for you guys.

No, not really. The topic of this thread is the professed right wing value of each state to be able to solve its own problems without the big bad federal government stepping in, so telling me what the governor of a whole other state thinks is totally irrelevant.

You’re not the only person who can develop a correct read here.

As for Joebob, tell him to hold off until tomorrow. There is no need to rush a foregone conclusion. There is reason to wait, since myself and probably others have some things to say.

I’m posting my reads and notes when I get home. I’m also not hammering. My life is valuable.

Why?

 I will say that something about Barney being roleblocked is off… why not Vader?

The latter will take care of itself if Banana is town (seems unlikely at this point)… but both are worth noting.

I’ll do it when I get home

Your role doesn’t have any further utility to it. That’s my point.

Honestly I just want to live in the easy world where it's Joebob and banana lol. Idk, I feel it's probably harder than that tho. But yeah, the thread feels pretty towny in general, so it makes sense that the last few scum are probs just getting boxed in and lowposting.

DP ends Friday night. I’d prefer to lynch someone tomorrow instead of today.

Anyway, if we’re going for Banana, I suggest we coordinate who hammers. It should be someone who isn’t useful to town anymore. Sorry Pie, but I think you might be the best candidate.

Why would I care what the governor of New Jersey thinks about NYC's traffic programs?

Much as I do understand the pushback against two killing roles being in the game, at least to some degree, I don't really understand what would make this a tough decision if that's where you're coming from. I'm not sold on the Banana lynch myself, but I don't see a world in which Vader is scum here. So much of what he's done would have to be carefully planted ahead of time and executed in a very particular way. Couple that with the notion that scum would get an extra NK that activates on voting and I just don't buy it. At least Banana's Town Insurgent claim is a one-off that activates on death, and we've seen plenty of scum bombs that function in a similar capacity. Hell, been one myself.

If my powers get activated, who do you want me to shoot?

Basically top scum reads

I am sorry I've been super busy today. I don't know why I am being voted over vader. The functionality behind my role is that if I am killed or lynched I can select any player I want to die. I was hoping to be the night kill, which is why I didn't want to reveal this, but I guess the cat is out of the bag now.

We did, it's been implemented already. 

Do better.

I hate buying the lie that Pie said because in general lying as town unless it's for a good reason is scummy, but honestly the way he set it up hinted that he was going to be some type of role. I'm still interested how he got the transgender fake claim though.

I have a pretty decent town read on him 

That's one mystery solved. She was saying something about believing Earth was still around. Unless he's doing something squirrely in Purgatory, it's at least clear that you have the Cookie Giver role, though that still leaves questions about why his role says "Removed" in the OP.

If you eat a good cookie, you go to heaven, and vice versa. If you reject a good cookie, the angels who ate the cookies have vendetta of sorts on the ones who rejected. 

So, uh, can we be friends?

Sorry about the inactivity guys. Life's been hectic. 

I've decided to come clean - My vanilla thing was totally a fake claim. I'm the counter part to the Evil Cookie Giver. I'm the Good Cookie Giver. My essay is about the necessity of attempting to do good in an evil world. 

I win if I can distribute five cookies. I go to hell if I distribute less than three. I can also win by surviving. 

If you eat a good cookie, you go to heaven, and vice versa. If you reject a good cookie, the angels who ate the cookies have vendetta of sorts on the ones who rejected. 

So, uh, can we be friends?

Did you forget to add someone to the purgatory thread?

Oh here's something btw...

Savant isn't in the purgatory thread, despite being dead.

That's taken a bit of a backseat to both Banana and Greyparrot suggesting that their role kills if they're hammered, then changing their minds.

Boy, I can't wait till all those small government states rights conservatives find out and demand Trump stay out of it.

How so?

Ok.

So my role is the Vital Coward, and my character is frozen jesus. 

If someone uses the NK on me, it will be automatically deflected to a random town member. It is a passive 1x use, and when I asked, WyIted told me I would not be notified if my passive was used.

I’m on the bus right now. When I’m get home I’ll give my thoughts and full claim if that’s what everyone wishes.

Should I reveal what happened last night, or wait a little longer for someone to come forward with the knowledge they must know I know?

Explain how both implicate her? I might've missed something

Even assuming the CC works - why take a one-for-one trade? Everything you're pointing out is more just anti-town/inexperienced rather than actually scummy.