Mharman

Fine that grants us another lynch. If Supa were really doctor you'd think scum would've killed them instead of going for Intelligence again. It's almost as if Supa is waiving NKs to appear as doctor.

Well then you've bought yourself a ticket into DP5. If Croc flips town, Supa will keep you alive to have enough votes for me.

I know. I'm just tired of waiting on Croc.

If he even gives one. Relax. We got this. Just lynch Supa tomorrow is Croc flips town.

You're a watcher. Oromagi is a reincarnator. You two are confirmed IMO off of PR usage and Behavior, respectively. Both make sense with theme. That leaves Croc and Supa. While Supa and Croc's claims both make sense, their power role usage makes no sense. Supa refused to protect Croc NP1. Croc has just been useless all game.

I say we just lynch both.

Any objections to a Croc hammer?

I don't know where you're getting the idea that I've been buddying Speed. If you read my posts, I hard scumread him. There were moments when I thought he had a point, but overall he was solidly scum in my book.

Regardless, I think you're right about Supa. To me, the no NK means one of 3 things.

A. Inactive Croc didn't submit NK. (Croc is scum)

B. Supa really did protect Intelligence. (Supa is town)

C. Supa waived the NK. (Supa is scum)

Scenario B is most interesting. It would mean someone chose Intelligence over Croc (a claimed cop). Only Croc would do that, because he would be the only one not afraid of the cop. So in scenario B, Croc is scum.

In two scenarios, I see Croc as scum. But you are correct in that Supa is highly suspicious, at one point, he was my highest scumread and I think he's still up there.

I say we lynch Croc, then Supa if we are wrong. Any objections before I hammer Croc?

That means he would be a mafia strongman or ninja more than a tracker.

You're forgetting the role Mace Windu played in discovering Palpatine's plot to destroy the Jedi.

Wait a sec. I don't think Jules would be a tracker. Looking at the movie, it appears he'd be some kind of killing role. I am more inclined to lynch Speed now. Still, we need Crocodile's cop results.

Still, it might be some points in your favor if Crocodile says he got no result.

Whether or not Lunatic visited Croc is irrelevant. What matters is whether or not you are town who actually discovered this or mafia who is using an obvious move for town cred.

I agree for those reasons. I'm just saying Supa is equally or more likely to be scum. Think about this:

1. He claims doctor when jailkeeper is in the game.

2. He claimed to protect me, a vanilla, which makes no sense, given that there are claimed power roles in the game that are a higher priority.

I agree that Supa is more likely scum. I still scumread Speed, but I have a stronger scumread on Supa.

Still, still we need Crocodile's cop results.

I got none

*not weakling

Could you direct me to the post where you claimed weakling for context then please?

You should get in here ASAP too.

I will not vote until Crocodile reveals his results.

ok, but then why say you're not a weakling? Why not just pretend you're a vanilla from the start?

I'm down for Supa or Speed. Preferring Supa because there is no denying the Jailkeeper + Doctor is not believable. Speed at least made some arguments, however dubious of them I am.

If you were never at risk of getting lynched, then why did you need to claim a minor PR instead of vanilla in order to not get lynched?

You didn't want to get CC'd? Why not make the claim in DP1 when you are at the highest risk of getting lynched? Why claim DP2?

*there

Ok, but why then would you claim your character wasn't a weakling? That seems counterproductive to hiding a PR.

Also, aren't their any other minor PRs you could've used other than bleeder?

AGAIN, DO NOT LYNCH UNTIL WE GET CROC'S COP RESULT.

Ok, but why bleeder? Why not vanilla?

Because Lunatic visiting Crocodile is easy to predict.

Why did you lie about being bleeder?

So you protected me, and not the claimed power role that Croc was, or that Lunatic was? You townread Lunatic, too.

That makes sense.

DON'T LYNCH YET. We need Crocodile's cop result.

Both are crazy IMO.

Speedrace claims he is a tracker. Intelligence says Speed visited Lunatic. That would require Intelligence to be watcher. And I don't think both are in this game. One of them is lying.

Why me?

explain, please

Who did you protect night one?

How many shots at being a doc do you get?

Also, vanilla

Stan from Together For Days.

It makes sense with Nick Fury, I guess. Still worried about the poem though.

Accidental tag in Post #5.

Any cop results?

Well there goes my idea. I was planning to tell from who died in the night whether or not Lunatic was the jailkeeper.

If Lunatic = not dead AND Crocodile cop = no result AND someone else = dead, Lunatic is a roleblocker for mafia.

If Lunatic = not dead AND Crocodile cop = no result AND no one else = dead, Lunatic is a jailkeeper.

I did not count on mafia killing Lunatic. I thought they'd go after Crocodile. Or, If Lunatic was a scum roleblocker, they'd roleblock Crocodile and kill someone else.

Mharman def. Danielle, 137.84-87

iLikePie def. SupaDudz, 145.5-122.22

Crocodile def. SigmaPhil, 128.48-100.46

RM def. BearMan, 132.44-105.08

Warren def. Skittlez, 142.48-90.7

EAST

1. iLikePie (1-0)

2. RM (1-0)

3. SupaDudz (0-1)

4. BearMan (0-1)

5. Danielle (0-1)

WEST

1. Warren (1-0)

2. Mharman (1-0)

3. SigmaPhil (1-0)

4. Crocodile (0-1)

5. Skittlez (0-1)

I wish I had girlfriend.

Granted. I can't think of any corruptions.

Sooooo, what is your wish then?

shoot sorry for posting

We limited on time. I say we just lynch Danielle so scum can't use her inactivity to their advantage. Plus it's probably the only lynch was can get this DP.