Mharman

If I don't get an answer by the time I have to leave for work, I will leave my vote on Crocodile.

What is your case for a non-SLJ being town when the possiblities are likely all-SLJ or SLJ vs. non-SLJ?

nothing else strikes me. I just scumread Croc because non-SLJ just isn't likely as town. I believe it is a bold claim to spin the narrative surrounding theme analysis.

In post 76 Crocodile says the theme isn't SLJ vs. Non-SLJ. I think this a bold attempt to cast off suspicion after he already claimed non-SLJ. Again, non-SLJ doesn't make sense as town given how many town SLJs there are. At this point I townread Skittlez because Intelligence is right, he did claim early in my game, and he was town that game, so I was completely wrong in my initial scumread of him.

Post 75. Crocodile says he's not SLJ. I still think he's scum. There's too many SLJ's for this game not to be SLJ-themed. I myself am an SLJ.

so yeah, I scumread Croc

Post 64. Croc doesn't know Jackson's role, implying he doesn't have SLJ as a character. If the split is SLJ vs. Non-SLJ, then he is certainly scum. If it is all SLJ, then Croc is lying and is still scum.

Ok yeah you're right. that's my bad. I researched poorly.

I swear I remember he didn't... I'll check it out though

I disagree with post 66. I think an SLJ vs. no SLJ is a fine theme split, I just don't know if that's the case that it IS the split.

Ok so there's this brief moment of tension between Supa, Speed, and Oromagi. Where Speed and Oromagi got the theme right off the bat, Supa missed out on it, then appeared to get it. I'm going to need more information before I can form any reads. 

We don't know whether or not:

-All roles are SLJ or just town.

-Scum was given a fake claim they could use to decipher the theme

If all roles are SLJ or scum was given a fake claim, we can conclude that no one with an SLJ claim is immune from being scum, especially after the theme was figured out.

First thing I see is Skittlez claim early. This is the first time Skittlez claimed early and I just doubt he'd do it for no reason. I think this is much rather a quick claim to avoid suspicion. For this, I scumread Skittlez off the bat.

I have limited time (work in 1 hour- won't be back until 8:00 pm, and even then, I have a final draft of a college paper to write), so I'm going to post in the form of quick notes.

Is there a similar but more detailed thread for the religion forum?

I agree that hood/ghetto culture is bad for society. I just don't think it's a culture exclusive to black people, and I don't think there is any specific "black culture", or any specific culture to any race. I believe all humans are equal, and have the right of choosing whichever culture they prefer.

reading rn

Game 319, let's go!

dang, I should join these sometime

I'm going to agree with grey here. I believe that culture is NEVER bound to any specific race. 

Mharman tied w/ Danielle 0-0

SupaDudz leads iLikePie 10.6-0

SigmaPhil leads Crocodile 17-0

RationalMadman leads BearMan 35.1-0

Skittlez leads Warren42 16.2-0

Me after benching Sammy Watkins this week: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6tXN9b4W9c

The Kickoff has started!

I honestly miss this youtuber

nice

I think my game had a good core idea behind it but just flopped in execution. I'm over it now, but I was extremely angry with myself when I realized the mistake(s) I had made.

No. The purpose of the vigilante, PGO, JOAT's 1x Suicide, were to mask the fact that there was no scum by having people die in the night in other ways. I wanted town to eventually figure it out so that there some winners, but still a decent amount of losers. Maybe like a 50/50 split.

An explanation for why I didn't let you replace Pie.

indeed :/

I'm still mad about screwing up my game

Let's get hyped, I guess

two more games and I can add the next batch of games to my archives

This is game #319 in Debate website mafia history.

No. It was just temptation to see if you would actually use it.

By asking to be replaced out in a PM

He didn't. He just left town.

ewrfverwgfv

oewrjvn42eoigvr

So basically I made a game with no scum, and only those who lived at the end or quit the game would be in the winners circle. The idea was like the real Salem Witch Trials, there were no witches and anyone who saw that and stopped the witch hunt or left town altogether was a winner.

But then I screwed up the setup in what would very likely be my only chance to execute a game like this.

I was under the impression visitors notified someone, and it was one of the most useless town roles I could find at the time. But I did not know visitors did not notify the guy they visited. So when Supa claimed Skittlez visited him, it caused a crapstorm. And it's my fault. So as the organizer of the game, I hereby disband the town, forcing everyone to leave town and win the game.

Because the object of the game was to stop the witch hunt, and I made a screw up that only led to the witch hunt being driven along further, I decided to end the game and give everyone except Crocodile the win.

Crocodile doesn't get the win because my screw up didn't affect his death, as visitor hadn't been used until the night phase. Pie only gets the win because he left the game in a PM. Everyone else wins as well.

Here are the PMs:

Oromagi - You are role madness. Boo. Town vanilla.

Bullish - You are the voyeur. No, not the role. Your character is voyeur. Your role is vanilla. Town.

Intelligence - You are OMGUS. Let's give your stupidity more power, shall we? You are a double voter. Win with town.

ENDGAME UP SOON

ENDGAME UP SOON

*facepalms*

I'm an idiot.

ENDGAME WILL UP SOON.

Yeah it happens

lol

Y'all just ever unsubscribe from your own thread to reduce notifications?

Yay. I added a tag

thanks