Moozer325

I never thought this would happen, but I agree with you 100%. Both sides have done wrong, and have had wrong done to them. That said, it is no excuse to be committing human rights violations and possible genocide. In the words of my mother “I don’t care who started it, just stop fighting!”

I think we should, at least wait for him to get online so he can defend himself.

I'd give him a pass. He says he's on vacation.

No one really stands out. I'll vote for anyone in my PoE pool. Joebob, Earth Lunatic, are all good to me. They're just not active enough for me to make an informed decision, so we kinda have no choice.

Wait, I forgot Pie was confirmable, so I would say he's more like 0.05% scummy, so we can both agree that there are much better options than someone who says they are confirmable next DP

Okay fine, I won't vote for you, but do you really have to try and Lynch Pie? We might be able to agree on someone in the PoE pool. I'm offering a compromise. Pie is a little scummy (like 3% scummy), but there are other people I want to go for more. It looks a bit like an OMGUS from you.

No, your points are valid, it's just PoE for me at this point. I might be open to a Earth Lynch or something. There's almost no activity there.

I'm also fine Lynching Savant BTW. Luna's just in the PoE because of inactivity. Same with Earth mostly. I can't town read you or scum read you if you give me nothing to go on.

*least as in least scummy

What's your reasoning for Casey and Earth? My PoE has it down to Luna, Earth, Casey, and Savant, but Casey is the least of them.

I don't think that would make it too powerful. Besides, you could have chosen who to steal from before the DP started, and then made it seem like you chose Earth on the spot.

I think it was me who did that actually.

Yeah, that’s a good point. I was under the assumption that he was a 1x Lynchproof for some reason.

Never mind, just saw his post

Wait, is he a 1x Lynchproof, or total Lynchproof? Because 1x seems a lot more scummy than total Lynchproof. Also keep in mind that there is that 1x vigilante floating around, and possibly more, so we might have to kill him some other way.

Are you a 1x lynchproof or a total lynchproof?

Wait, what did we just do?

In my opinion, this was a horrible idea. Since when is Lynchproof a mostly townie role? I get that it could go either way, but I still think that it’s too close for comfort.

Anyways, here’s some post shirt debacle reads. Honestly, I’m kinda leaning in a WyIted/Savant scum team direction.

WyIted: Slight Scum because they did the same thing Savant did and tried to gaslight us into thinking they had a town confirmable role. It worked on me anyways, and I don’t like it.

Savant: Also slight scum because of how much he and WyIted have been working together when the other one was going to get the shirt. Claiming confirmable roles without specifying how confirmable they are seems like a scum gaslighting play to me, especially when you get your scum buddy to back you up.

Null: Everyone else.

Pie: Lean Town because of how he stopped Savant getting the shirt originally.

Barney: Lean town because of his role confirmation. It seems like such a negative utility role if it were scum, so I check him off for now.

Mostly it's the lack of evidence. If God wanted us to believe in him, why wouldn't he just reveal himself to all of us at the same time? And for that matter, why has he not revealed himself to me? You can say it's all part of his "divine plan" or something, but that still doesn't mean I'm going to believe in him.

Yeah that's a good point about your role.

I suppose I would also like a claim.

Also, I’m not saying your not lean town because of this, but you still need to clarify.

Yeah, but your not the one picking who gets the shirt.

*or

The definition of atheist is literally “no religion” So how could I say it was a religion? 

Owen also said you could explain your lack of religion in the first post, so I went and did that.

Are you still confirmable? Because if so, we can give the shirt to you.

Alrighty, reads!

Savant: if he had just admitted his mistake in how confirmable he was, I would write it off, but he has been very defensive, so top scum read for now. But remember, it’s DP1, so none of this really means much in the grand scheme of things.

Everyone else: Null. I don’t give any scum cred to believing savant, and I don’t think it should stop anyone from getting the shirt, but oh well.

WyIted: slight town only because they claimed confirmable, but I’m not fully through the DP, so maybe something happened.

Pie: Lean town. I don’t think scum would push this hard on something that is pretty clearly pro town. Also, I’m scum reason Savant, so that helps Pies case a little.

Lastly, I’m gonna defend myself a little for almost letting savant get the shirt. He said he was confirmable, and when everyone started voting with him, I assumed he had confirmed. I think I missed the vote stealer claim and confirm. Sorry about that, but I just kinda thought he had confirmed. 

Also Savant, you need to say whether you’re ROLE confirmable or AFFILIATION confirmable, because that’s what caused this whole mess. For the record, I am Hard affiliation confirmable, but only by DP3 so keep me in the PoE pool.

Sorry I have to leave right in the middle of this, but I’ll be back tomorrow morning.

So do we want WyIted claiming the vigilante?

So sorry, I must have missed that.

I’ll start I guess. I’m atheist, which for me at least doesn’t mean I 100% confident that there isn’t a god, I just haven’t been convinced that there is one yet. 

I don’t think it’s probable that there is a god, but if there was sufficient evidence, I would believe it.

One more bad shirt joke and I’m blocking you :p

I’m gonna PM Austin about that. I think your right about it being able to be used any night, and I would do the same, but I’ll just double check.

Confirm first.

Okay, I’ll Unvote and wait for your claim, but why all the unvoting and revoting. Barney clarified that number to lynch is 7, so we’ll just get six people to vote and if anyone else quick hammers, then we lynch them.

That’s sounds good to me.

I agree. In my experience, DP1 is usually just a PoE lynch, and I’m fine with that.

Alright, *exerts pressure on Barney*

I’m not normally against religion in school. I’m an Atheist personally, but you can believe whatever you want in my book. My problem is the mandate part. You can believe whatever, but you can’t force your belief down other peoples throats.

Bart Simpson would be a pretty scummy too, don’t you think? We cannot lynch just baes on this. We have two day, so let’s use that to build on behavioral reads, and if it comes to it we can lynch based on PoE.

It is though.

Yeah, your probably right.