Shila

OMG, you think Shila is really Gp don't you.

I hear some people do define miracles as even everyday events or unusual occurrences in the natural world, should those events bring them meaning, experience, closeness with God.

Or feel blessed, to be in improbable fortunate situations, such as the sun shining like that in Ireland.

You didn't read the study he posted, apparently you didn't get past the title, how about you read the post and the article it is about, and maybe you can get your head out of your ass and say something relevant Non-Sequitur Man.

Take the butterfly, you have a caterpillar that at a certain point in time, grows a cocoon, then the caterpillar liquefies, and this homogenous liquid, with no structure at all, it slowly assembles into a butterfly, a completely different creature emerges from the cocoon, full grown and able to fly....from a liquid.

We are just going to have to look deeper to understand it.

I think we missed this because no link. Hopefully it is recorded

You all know that ebuc is a Borg, don't you?

Take the butterfly, you have a caterpillar that at a certain point in time, grows a cocoon, then the caterpillar liquefies, and this homogenous liquid, with no structure at all, it slowly assembles into a butterfly, a completely different creature emerges from the cocoon, full grown and able to fly....from a liquid.

I assume that's why housing prices are rising. An increase of the population due to immigration since we are below replacement levels, means more demand for less supply so now it cost 500k to move into a shack

There is nothing about the trinity that is determined by nature or even considered natural.

He is using the word "natural" analogically. You would have known that if you understood what he was talking about.

Thomas Aquinas' Trinitarian theology has been criticized as proposing an abstract notion of God that is divorced from salvation history and that is supported by tedious and ultimately incomprehensible explication.

Says who? You? The Council of Trent did not seem to think so.

"God is the Father" means we are applying a nature to a person.

What is the nature of someone mean?

Someone's nature is their character, which they show by the way they behave. Just how do the managers harness their energy, rivalry and ambitious nature into winning teamwork? She trusted people. That was her nature. Synonyms: temperament, character, personality, disposition More Synonyms of nature.

That is not what it means in philosophy or theology.  Further showing you don't know what you are talking about.

"God" is a term that is universally applied to the Three persons. However, when you apply it to one you are saying that person has the nature of God. Saying: "God the Father" is a particular and then to say "is a title applied to God" You are using the term "God" here universally. To then go from there to say that "God the Father is God the Son" is to say two particulars are the same thing because of a universal nature. That is a fallacy.

The first says there is no real distinction in Persons.

This is what I said and the "the first" refers to your post #143

So I was referencing you as I said.

Note even Jesus calls God the Father

Yeah, when he was referring to the First Person of the Trinity. I am not saying The First Person is not God. I am saying the Second Person is not God the Father because that is what the church teaches.

The video you posted is people screaming in English. Which means it is not of Fatima, because Fatima is in Portugal...

So how does this, or other videos discredit the Miracle of the Sun???? Because some crazy people think they see a miracle when it is not, therefore all sun miracles are false? 

What in the fuck Does Trump have to do with anything?  TDS

USA = Greatest number of migrants

USA = Greatest in technology

Migrants bring in money, labor, some even start buisnesses of their own. Most importantly, they bring in knowledge which USA needs for technological advancement.

Maybe if USA had high IQ like Japan, maybe it wouldnt need migrants, but as it stands right now, USA needs migrants due to both knowledge and low birth rates.

Biden hasn't been on the site for 8 days.

Genki

I reckon if i set a ( bush on fire )  

I'd get that bitch to cum. 

Fucking easy as. 

With the technique of spaced repetition, it enables me to learn with less effort while achieving good results. Plus, all these brain and memory improving apps help too, as well as my understanding of which words I need to learn as priority.

You all know that ebuc is a Borg, don't you?

OMG, did Biden die? I think you all know what I mean.

UFO's in medieval art have always interested me. Such as The Baptism of  Christ  by Dutch artist Aert de Gelde in 1710.

https://render.fineartamerica.com/images/rendered/default/canvas-print/6/8/mirror/break/images/artworkimages/medium/3/ufos-in-ancient-art-baptism-of-christ-1710-painting-by-aert-de-gelder-tom-hill-canvas-print.jpg

One has to ask, what was the inspiration?

God the father is the son and is the Holy Spirit...

 does not say the same thing as:

God is Father, God is Son, and God is Holy Spirit...

Damn it. If you don't atop I will be sending you unsolicited dick pictures. 

Japanese people have highest IQ in the world, so learning Japanese might give me higher IQ, which will help me deal with my issues as trans.

https://www.jagranjosh.com/general-knowledge/the-list-of-the-top-10-countries-with-the-highest-iq-check-the-list-here-1663252594-1

A transgender (often shortened to trans) person is someone whose gender identity differs from that typically associated with the sex they were assigned at birth.[2]

Often, transgender people desire medical assistance to medically transition from one sex to another; those who do may identify as transsexual.[3][4] Transgender does not have a universally accepted definition, including among researchers;[5] it can function as an umbrella term. The definition given above includes binary trans men and trans women and may also include people who are non-binary or genderqueer.[6][7] Other related groups include third-gender people, cross-dressers, and drag queens and drag kings; some definitions include these groups as well.[6][8]

Being transgender is distinct from sexual orientation, and transgender people may identify as heterosexual (straight), homosexual (gay or lesbian), bisexual, asexual, or otherwise, or may decline to label their sexual orientation.[9] The opposite of transgender is cisgender, which describes persons whose gender identity matches their assigned sex.[10] Accurate statistics on the number of transgender people vary widely,[11] in part due to different definitions of what constitutes being transgender.[5] Some countries collect census data on transgender people, starting with Canada in 2021[12][13][14][15]. Generally, less than 1% of the worldwide population is transgender, with figures ranging from <0.1% to 0.6%.[16][17]

Many transgender people experience gender dysphoria, and some seek medical treatments such as hormone replacement therapy, gender-affirming surgery, or psychotherapy. Not all transgender people desire these treatments,[18] and some cannot undergo them for legal,[19] financial,[20] or medical[21] reasons.

The legal status of transgender people varies by jurisdiction. Many transgender people experience transphobia (violence or discrimination against transgender people) in the workplace,[22] in accessing public accommodations,[23] and in healthcare.[24] In many places, they are not legally protected from discrimination.[25][page needed] Several cultural events are held to celebrate the awareness of transgender people, including Transgender Day of Remembrance and International Transgender Day of Visibility,[26][27] and the transgender flag is a common transgender pride symbol.[28]

Suppositum Definition: Something supposed to be true; an assumption. Suppositum Latin From the past participle of supponere, to suppose.

No. That is not what it means.

Sub ponere. To be placed under.

It developed into the latin word supponere which has the primary meaning of "to place under"

Which transfered to the philosophical meaning of that which is placed under the appearances of something or substance. In other words: what the thing is. Which is determined by nature. So yes,

He was talking about nature. St. Thomas assumes you have already read his philosophical works and can tell when he is talking about certain concepts in A treatise about God. Which further points to the fact that you haven't studied this, because you don't understand what is being said.

You did not complete the sentence God the father is the son and is the Holy Spirit. God the father means god is the father.

"God the Father" is the combination of words referring to the First person of the Trinity.

"God is the Father" means we are applying a nature to a person.

THEY DO NOT MEAN THE SAME THING.

This tells me you haven't studied the basic philosophy and logic or theology behind this.

I never said I could. Nor did I say anything that says I have.

The first says there is no real distinction in Persons.”

This is referring to what YOU said.

The first says there is no real distinction in Persons.

The second says All 3 Persons have the same nature.

It may be a case that something unusual occurred and when the church got wind of the story decided to embellish it with their own take on what "really" happened.

The remake of Fable 1:

I know that better graphics are usually much good, but Fable the Anniversary could have added a bit more to the game than simply graphics.

"no knowledge of anything other than what you regurgitate from media "

Thats kinda rude.

Good day guys. 

And ummmm  hey. ,  

have a great weekend.  

I wonder why police don't carry condensed law books on them at all times,

Or have a legal call center they can call to check themselves before they take certain actions.

He hasn't prevented any American from applying for a job or even working for another company.

Americans made money working for Musk. Now they want to tell him who to hire.

Do you want me to tell you what scripture says debating is?

It's not what you said. Do you desire me to tell you?

Take the butterfly, you have a caterpillar that at a certain point in time, grows a cocoon, then the caterpillar liquefies, and this homogenous liquid, with no structure at all, it slowly assembles into a butterfly, a completely different creature emerges from the cocoon, full grown and able to fly....from a liquid.

We are just going to have to look deeper to understand it.

Good, that falls in line.

Difference between what is true as an assumption.

No. That is not what it means. That is most certainly not what St. Thomas means either.

He is speaking here of a suppositum which is a philosophical concept that means a real distinct being having a nature. You and I are suppositums of a human nature.

God the father is the son and is the Holy Spirit...

does not mean:

God is the father,

Do you speak English?!?!?!?!

If all 3 persons have the same nature. There is no distinction in persons, they have the same nature.

Wrong again showing you are either making stuff up and doing google searches to try and justify yourself. Nature is not the same thing as personhood. You and I have the same nature, but we are not the same person.

You cannot even grasp the concept of the Trinity.

I never said I could. Nor did I say anything that says I have. 

God the father is the son and is the Holy Spirit...

 does not say the same thing as:

God is Father, God is Son, and God is Holy Spirit...

The first says there is no real distinction in Persons.

The second says All 3 Persons have the same nature.

Doesn’t look like you read it yourself.

Doesn't look like you can read.

You're a pedophile; of course you would say that.

Then cut government spending to zero. That minimizes cost, and you don't care about anything else.

I'm fine with government spending going to individuals that benefit society (teachers, cops, etc), not to those that are bad for society (murderers, r@pists, really any criminal).

A teacher's presence benefits society relative to that teacher not existing; this is not true for a criminal.

means only a distinction of "suppositum";

What does this mean? Do you know? Do you actually understand what he is saying here?

All of Theology is studied under the light of philosophy. If it isn't it becomes sentimental.

Ruh roh, Musk overruled Trump on H-1B visas and now MAGA folks are threatening to murder him.

They don't like it when Musk puts Trump in his place.

I have heard of Professor Hughes and there are many Thomists who disagree with him on his understanding of Thomistic Doctrine.

Gardail

Grenier

Hugon

to name a few...

I answer that, Since as Jerome remarks [In substance, Ep. lvii.], a heresy arises from words wrongly used, when we speak of the Trinity we must proceed with care and with befitting modesty; because, as Augustine says (De Trin. i, 3), "nowhere is error more harmful, the quest more toilsome, the finding more fruitful." Now, in treating of the Trinity, we must beware of two opposite errors, and proceed cautiously between them—namely, the error of Arius, who placed a Trinity of substance with the Trinity of persons; and the error of Sabellius, who placed unity of person with the unity of essence.

Thus, to avoid the error of Arius we must shun the use of the terms diversity and difference in God, lest we take away the unity of essence: we may, however, use the term "distinction" on account of the relative opposition. Hence whenever we find terms of "diversity" or "difference" of Persons used in an authentic work, these terms of "diversity" or "difference" are taken to mean "distinction." But lest the simplicity and singleness of the divine essence be taken away, the terms "separation" and "division," which belong to the parts of a whole, are to be avoided: and lest quality be taken away, we avoid the use of the term "disparity": and lest we remove similitude, we avoid the terms "alien" and "discrepant." For Ambrose says (De Fide i) that "in the Father and the Son there is no discrepancy, but one Godhead": and according to Hilary, as quoted above, "in God there is nothing alien, nothing separable."

To avoid the heresy of Sabellius, we must shun the term "singularity," lest we take away the communicability of the divine essence. Hence Hilary says (De Trin. vii): "It is sacrilege to assert that the Father and the Son are separate in Godhead." We must avoid the adjective "only" [unici] lest we take away the number of persons. Hence Hilary says in the same book: "We exclude from God the idea of singularity or uniqueness." Nevertheless, we say "the only Son," for in God there is no plurality of Sons. Yet, we do not say "the only God," for the Deity is common to several. We avoid the word "confused," lest we take away from the Persons the order of their nature. Hence Ambrose says (De Fide i): "What is one is not confused; and there is no multiplicity where there is no difference." The word "solitary" is also to be avoided, lest we take away the society of the three persons; for, as Hilary says (De Trin. iv), "We confess neither a solitary nor a diverse God."

This word "other" [alius], however, in the masculine sense, means only a distinction of "suppositum"; and hence we can properly say that "the Son is other than the Father," because He is another "suppositum" of the divine nature, as He is another person and another hypostasis.

Your post#98

You here are using language that implies sameness between two persons. You have to be careful. It would be better to say it as "God is a Trinity of three Persons. God the Son became Man and The Holy Spirit is the Comforter or Paraclete."

Like I said, I do not think you intend heresy. But I think you are using language that is ambiguous and leads one to think that there is a sameness between two persons. That is why I brought in Modalism. That is the type of language they used when discussing this. You have to be careful how you say it.

St. Thomas is very clear here, if you understand the terms he is using from philosophy. The Persons are distinct and not each other.

Scaramouche who has been campaigning for Harris has openly threatened to murder Elon Musk if he doesn't play ball with the deep state

Is this supposed to be a joke? Cause there's no way you listened to your video and took that away from it.

Are you going to ignore Jesus and the Holy Spirit?

God will give you the grace if you do your part. 

God does not just drop knowledge into our brains. We have to do our part in studying and reading what other great saints have said and done before us.

God also expects us to follow the teaching of the Catholic Church because He gave Her the authority to do so. He expects us to study and love our faith.

You have a Sola Scriptura attitude which is a protestant attitude.

Just asking based off how this individual formats and uses language.

Sounds about right. By the way, thanks for your overwhelming support of the Biden admin. over the past 4 years.

Do you celebrate the new day?

What does scripture say debating is?