I targetted whiteflame NP1 and Pie NP2. I asked Whiteflame about the fruit because I just wanted to see if he would lie about it at all. Doesn't rule him out of POE but he was telling the truthI got nothing from you. So either you were manipulated or you’re lying
Information that can't be confirmed is useless for establishing trust, perhaps it can be used by scum in determining who to target. I won't give away information without a good argument advantaging town. I shouldn't have said what I did first night either.
Did anyone get fruit last night?
You had two chances to protect the night kill if the role you claimed is legit.and how would I possibly know who was going to be night killed (outside the list and Luna)?
We can piece together who is lying out of you three better by organizing who visited who last night.No you can't because you don't know who is telling the truth about visiting whom.If you have a form of corroboration, start there. Otherwise this is irrelevant and if you are scum it's merely a tool which you might use to distract from the cold hard numbers.
Actually retarded. Idk what the end goal was. Like if she had just claimed White Mage, everyone would’ve been fine with it
I never said anything which could be interpreted as "blind trust", or in fact trust of any kind.Like it’s interesting why you’re willing to blindly trust me regarding my reading of Banana
Maybe I'm getting too emotional about this: but if town lynches the two people who got the math right (User and I) and then said "they threw it" I think I'm about done playing mafia. You all got your secret hand shakes and your palm reading, but in the end you're still lynching town and you're still losing.
Information that can't be confirmed is useless for establishing trust, perhaps it can be used by scum in determining who to target. I won't give away information without a good argument advantaging town. I shouldn't have said what I did first night either.
Do you think there are 3 scum?
Yea, they're just lynching themselves. Why didn't they act like town?I can't compensate for poor skill of my fellow townies.
She was actually a protective role, and Rasputin.
She was town and literally lied about her role. Town have no reason to lie.
Information that can't be confirmed is useless for establishing trust, perhaps it can be used by scum in determining who to target. I won't give away information without a good argument advantaging town. I shouldn't have said what I did first night either.
You know what it is? I bet I turned into scum.You didn't have any problem giving out that information after you claimed in DP1, but now you do
...give information that could potentially be validated by someone else
I never said anything which could be interpreted as "blind trust", or in fact trust of any kind.
In fact the only thing I said about banana vs user was that there was more support for going after user and user's logic for lynching Lunatic immediately was right and that was townie of That2User.
... and guess what she was town. My sole behavioral analysis was correct.
I can't compensate for poor skill of my fellow townies. Did you not realize what happened? Look at that2users flip. She claimed to be anastasia, and a beloved princess. She was actually a protective role, and Rasputin. She was town and literally lied about her role. Town have no reason to lie. 90% of the reason she was scum read initially was because of the inconsistencies with her claim, her being in the dreamer results was only a bit of icing on the cake. Earth literally self hammered and was CC'ed as the first tsar as russia.
I don't know, I can tell you if I was modding this I would have 100% put in three scum. You've seen me put 3 scum in two of my recent 10 player games, and town has won both of them. 11 players balances perfectly with 3 scum if your going for your average four mislynches. That or there is a third party role or something to compensate, 4 mislynches seems like an uphill battle for a scum team.
You know what it is? I bet I turned into scum.
Let the validator make his claim, otherwise this is speculation.
I can't compensate for poor skill of my fellow townies.Yea, they're just lynching themselves. Why didn't they act like town?It couldn't possibly be that your idea of town behavior and role layouts is a little over-constrained.
So you were saying there were too many protective roles when there were two claims of protective roles, but if there were three you wouldn't have lynched That2User?
No, you would have found it even more suspicious; or else all this crowing about "too many protective roles" is deception.There are two protective roles in town (I know for certain) and I wouldn't be surprised if Ceru is also a protective town.
Town has plenty of reasons to lie.
Your own role might have been more useful if you had withheld your claim until you had two or even three lists.
Ya tbh I agree with you. I would’ve designed it with at least 1 TP with 2 scum or 3 scum. If there are 3 scum, then lynching me is game over sadly. I think we need to get Cerulean’s full claim. Then Whiteflame. Then I’ll claim cause might as well. Then we can decide how we want to proceed. With 2 townies already throwing and a possible third, we’re probably not winning this anyway.
So why do you automatically go to Luna over Banana?
If she had told the truth since the beginning, she wouldn’t have gotten lynched
If ADOL is town, that’s literally 3 throwers on my team.
Information that can't be confirmed is useless for establishing trust, perhaps it can be used by scum in determining who to target. I won't give away information without a good argument advantaging town. I shouldn't have said what I did first night either.What? Then how do you expect to play this game lol
I don't believe that for a second.
Maybe you should expand your definition of "town behavior" to include these "throwers". You might lynch less townies.
What? Then how do you expect to play this game lolWith excessive sarcasm at the moment.
