Hall Of Fame III - Nominations

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

08.06.2021 04:32AM

5

8

11

08.06.2021 04:32AM

Users

7 - whiteflame

6 - Fauxlaw

6- MisterChris

4 -Theweakeredge

2 - Undefeatable

1 - Intelligence_06

1 - Fruit_Inspector

1 - iLikePie5

1 - Badger

1 - BrotherDThomas

1 - Speedrace

1 - Ramshutu

1 - thett3

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park

1 - Why are we banning wylted?

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1

1 - Send trumpet to jail now

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts

1 - Anyone still here?

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary

1- Fox/Trump Immoral handling of covid19

Debates

4 - Wikipedia is a more reliable source than Fox News

3 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games In Their Curriculum

2 - Environmental Protection vs. Resource Extraction

2 - Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict

1 - TOURNAMENT R(2): Speedrace vs MisterChris

1 - Violent revolution is a response to political oppression

1 - Resolved: There is not systemic racism in United States government, as a whole.

1 - Constantine the Great should not be considered a mainstream Christian, because he was actually a heretic

1 - Systemic Racism is Definetly a problem in the USA

#33

Tejretics

Debates: 7

Posts: 497

2

4

8

Tejretics

08.06.2021 05:45AM

2

4

8

08.06.2021 05:45AM

I’ll vote for Whiteflame.

#34

Debates: 50

Posts: 2,934

5

9

10

08.06.2021 05:46AM

5

9

10

08.06.2021 05:46AM

USERS

Ramshutu
In addition to co-authoring the ever valuable Kritik Guide, for quite awhile he represented 27.5% of the total active votes. After all this time away he's still the #2 voter. By virtue of that alone, he's earned it; heck, his absence only enhances how profound his positive contributions were.
semperfortis
P1: It is prima facie that critical thinking is useful.
P2: Syllogisms and the logical form help express and encourage critical thinking.
P3: semperfortis raised the frequency of those techniques even outside his own debates.
C: semperfortis should be inducted into the HoF.
MisterChris
Mister Chris is the kindest, bravest, warmest, most wonderful human being I’ve ever known in my life.
Jokes aside, he is something of an enigma, having just appeared one day and ingrained himself as if we can all known him for years going back a few sites, and yet he's actually comparably new. Which makes his rise all the more noteworthy.

DEBATES

Should Abortion be Made Illegal?
Caleb vs. Ragnar
I'm still damn impressed by how well Caleb did against me. We each won and lost points and lost others, making voting mixed. Not only was it the closest I ever came to losing an abortion debate, but it made me grow as a debater with lessons applicable to any subject.

Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict
blamonkey vs. whiteflame
In addition to being a good debate, this one showcases alternative debate formats that can be supported here.
Admittedly, if this one was not nominated, I would instead be nominating a previous runner up.
TBD

THREADS

I am not particularly feeling this category right now.

Topic's author

#35

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

-U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games in Their Curriculum

08.06.2021 06:19AM

5

8

11

08.06.2021 06:19AM

Users

9 - whiteflame

7 - MisterChris

6 - Fauxlaw

4 -Theweakeredge

2 - Undefeatable

2 - Ramshutu

1 - Intelligence_06

1 - Fruit_Inspector

1 - iLikePie5

1 - Badger

1 - BrotherDThomas

1 - Speedrace

1 - thett3

1 - semperfortis

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park

1 - Why are we banning wylted?

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1

1 - Send trumpet to jail now

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts

1 - Anyone still here?

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary

1- Fox/Trump Immoral handling of covid19

Debates

4 - Wikipedia is a more reliable source than Fox News

3 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games In Their Curriculum

3 - Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict

2 - Environmental Protection vs. Resource Extraction

1 - TOURNAMENT R(2): Speedrace vs MisterChris

1 - Violent revolution is a response to political oppression

1 - Resolved: There is not systemic racism in United States government, as a whole.

1 - Constantine the Great should not be considered a mainstream Christian, because he was actually a heretic

1 - Systemic Racism is Definetly a problem in the USA

1 - Should abortion be made illegal?

#36

Intelligence_06

Debates: 167

Posts: 3,837

5

8

11

Intelligence_06

08.06.2021 08:07AM

5

8

11

08.06.2021 08:07AM

Users

-Theweakeredge

-MisterChris

-Whiteflame

Debates

-THBT: WiKiPEDIA is a MORE RELIABLE SOURCE for INFORMATION than FOX NEWS

-Resolved: God created “the heaven and the earth” with existing matter and energy and not ex nihilo.

#37

whiteflame

Debates: 27

Posts: 3,297

4

6

10

whiteflame

08.06.2021 01:34PM

4

6

10

08.06.2021 01:34PM

Alright, last round of this.

Users

Lunatic

This is a very distinct choice from my first two. I remember TUF well from his days on DDO, and while he's always been a solid debater and contributor in the forums, this is recognition for his efforts with Mafia on the site. I count at least 11 games he's designed and modded, kept up his efforts during a major slump in activity, has led efforts to get new people engaged with both forum and live mafia (for which he's designed and modded other games), and is a man of true culture for his love of the Stormlight Archive. We recognize a lot of debate and forum activity on this site, but especially going forward from this HoF, I think it will behoove us to recognize other contributions like his.

Debates

Resolved: Violent revolution is a just response to political oppression

https://www.debateart.com/debates/2637-resolved-violent-revolution-is-a-just-response-to-political-oppression

Yup, I'm nominating another MisterChris debate, though I'm doing this one for a few distinct reasons. First, I think his opponent, Undefeatable, deserves some recognition. I'm sure he'll make my User list in future HoFs, but for now, he absolutely deserves recognition for the sheer amount of effort he put into this one. He's incredibly quick to post his rounds and still manages to be thorough and incisive. Second, this is just a really interesting topic that I think both debaters explore deeply and thoroughly. Third, it features what is most definitely my longest RFD ever. Seriously, that thing took me a long time to write, and I don't do that for just any debate. An incredibly close debate, one of Undefeatable's earliest (and best, in my opinion), it's worthy of attention and praise for both debaters.

#38

FLRW

Debates: 0

Posts: 5,122

3

4

8

FLRW

08.06.2021 03:40PM

3

4

8

08.06.2021 03:40PM

I vote for whiteflame, Theweakeredge and 3RU7AL

Topic's author

#39

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

08.06.2021 04:08PM

5

8

11

08.06.2021 04:08PM

Users

11 - whiteflame

8 - MisterChris

6 - Fauxlaw

6 -Theweakeredge

2 - Undefeatable

2 - Ramshutu

1 - Intelligence_06

1 - Fruit_Inspector

1 - iLikePie5

1 - Badger

1 - BrotherDThomas

1 - Speedrace

1 - thett3

1 - semperfortis

1 - Lunatic

1 - 3RU7AL

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park

1 - Why are we banning wylted?

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1

1 - Send trumpet to jail now

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts

1 - Anyone still here?

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary

1- Fox/Trump Immoral handling of covid19

Debates

5 - Wikipedia is a more reliable source than Fox News

4 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games In Their Curriculum

3 - Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict

2 - Environmental Protection vs. Resource Extraction

2 - Violent revolution is a response to political oppression

1 - TOURNAMENT R(2): Speedrace vs MisterChris

1 - Resolved: There is not systemic racism in United States government, as a whole.

1 - Constantine the Great should not be considered a mainstream Christian, because he was actually a heretic

1 - Systemic Racism is Definetly a problem in the USA

1 - Should abortion be made illegal?

1 - God created “the heaven and the earth” with existing matter and energy and not ex nihilo.

#40

Debates: 564

Posts: 19,930

10

11

08.06.2021 07:43PM

10

11

08.06.2021 07:43PM

-->

@Vader

how are ties dealt with and/or what is the policy in unvoting and voting?

Will there be runoff votes, for instance, if the tie for third is too close?

#41

Debates: 564

Posts: 19,930

10

11

08.06.2021 07:43PM

10

11

08.06.2021 07:43PM

This is just nominations and not voting, correct? So what's the cutoff for what makes it to voting?

#42

Debates: 50

Posts: 2,934

5

9

10

08.06.2021 08:19PM

5

9

10

08.06.2021 08:19PM

-->

@RationalMadman

This is just the nominations. While not set in stone, I would estimate that anything seconded will move forward.

Topic's author

#43

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

08.06.2021 08:29PM

5

8

11

08.06.2021 08:29PM

-->

@RationalMadman

This is for nominations. The voting stage is the 8th where the top 4-6 move on

#44

Debates: 564

Posts: 19,930

10

11

08.06.2021 08:41PM

10

11

08.06.2021 08:41PM

-->

@Vader

Please answer me precisely:

What goes through and doesn't go through on each stage?

Topic's author

#45

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

08.06.2021 08:47PM

5

8

11

08.06.2021 08:47PM

-->

@RationalMadman

Right now the following would move on to the voting stage if voting ended today

Users

11 - whiteflame

8 - MisterChris

6 - Fauxlaw

6 -Theweakeredge

2 - Undefeatable

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park

1 - Why are we banning wylted?

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1

1 - Send trumpet to jail now

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts

1 - Anyone still here?

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary

1- Fox/Trump Immoral handling of covid19

Debates

5 - Wikipedia is a more reliable source than Fox News

4 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games In Their Curriculum

3 - Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict

2 - Environmental Protection vs. Resource Extraction

2 - Violent revolution is a response to political oppression

#46

Debates: 564

Posts: 19,930

10

11

08.06.2021 08:53PM

10

11

08.06.2021 08:53PM

-->

@Vader

Why would undefeatable move but not Ramshutu?

#47

Debates: 564

Posts: 19,930

10

11

08.06.2021 08:55PM

10

11

08.06.2021 08:55PM

-->

@Vader

I vote this debate:

Violent revolution is a just response to political oppression

Please add the word 'just'.

Topic's author

#48

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

08.06.2021 11:41PM

5

8

11

08.06.2021 11:41PM

Users

11 - whiteflame

8 - MisterChris

6 - Fauxlaw

6 -Theweakeredge

2 - Undefeatable

2 - Ramshutu

1 - Intelligence_06

1 - Fruit_Inspector

1 - iLikePie5

1 - Badger

1 - BrotherDThomas

1 - Speedrace

1 - thett3

1 - semperfortis

1 - Lunatic

1 - 3RU7AL

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park

1 - Why are we banning wylted?

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1

1 - Send trumpet to jail now

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts

1 - Anyone still here?

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary

1- Fox/Trump Immoral handling of covid19

Debates

5 - Wikipedia is a more reliable source than Fox News

4 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games In Their Curriculum

3 - Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict

3 - Violent revolution is a response to political oppression

2 - Environmental Protection vs. Resource Extraction

1 - TOURNAMENT R(2): Speedrace vs MisterChris

1 - Resolved: There is not systemic racism in United States government, as a whole.

1 - Constantine the Great should not be considered a mainstream Christian, because he was actually a heretic

1 - Systemic Racism is Definetly a problem in the USA

1 - Should abortion be made illegal?

1 - God created “the heaven and the earth” with existing matter and energy and not ex nihilo.

#49

Debates: 34

Posts: 5,754

3

4

11

08.07.2021 04:02PM

3

4

11

08.07.2021 04:02PM

Unvote brother

Unvote badger

Unvote ilikepie

Vote thett

Vote lunatic

Vote speedrace

Theead vote is for wylted

#50

Debates: 34

Posts: 5,754

3

4

11

08.07.2021 04:04PM

3

4

11

08.07.2021 04:04PM

do not sticky this neutrons please. Oddly stickies are often scrolled right past because nobody thinks of them as time sensitive

Topic's author

#51

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

08.07.2021 04:15PM

5

8

11

08.07.2021 04:15PM

Users

11 - whiteflame

8 - MisterChris

6 - Fauxlaw

6 -Theweakeredge

2 - Undefeatable

2 - Ramshutu

2 - Speedrace

2 - thett3

2 - Lunatic

1 - Intelligence_06

1 - Fruit_Inspector

1 - iLikePie5

1 - Badger

1 - BrotherDThomas

1 - semperfortis

1 - 3RU7AL

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park

1 - Why are we banning wylted?

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1

1 - Send trumpet to jail now

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts

1 - Anyone still here?

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary

1- Fox/Trump Immoral handling of covid19

Debates

5 - Wikipedia is a more reliable source than Fox News

4 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games In Their Curriculum

3 - Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict

3 - Violent revolution is a response to political oppression

2 - Environmental Protection vs. Resource Extraction

1 - TOURNAMENT R(2): Speedrace vs MisterChris

1 - Resolved: There is not systemic racism in United States government, as a whole.

1 - Constantine the Great should not be considered a mainstream Christian, because he was actually a heretic

1 - Systemic Racism is Definetly a problem in the USA

1 - Should abortion be made illegal?

1 - God created “the heaven and the earth” with existing matter and energy and not ex nihilo.

#52

Debates: 50

Posts: 2,934

5

9

10

08.07.2021 04:47PM

5

9

10

08.07.2021 04:47PM

-->

@Dr.Franklin

Would you by chance have any links to those threads you're nominating? #22

#53

Debates: 50

Posts: 2,934

5

9

10

08.07.2021 05:30PM

5

9

10

08.07.2021 05:30PM

-->

@Vader

Trying to double check the tally, hopefully I did not miss anyone...

Users

9 - whiteflame (MisterChris, gugigor, Dr.Franklin, ILikePie5, oromagi, bmdrocks21, coal, Intelligence_06, FLRW)

8 - MisterChris (Supa, whiteflame, gugigor, Dr.Franklin, ILikePie5, oromagi, Ragnar, Intelligence_06)

7 - Fauxlaw (RM, Supa, Sum1hugme, MisterChris, Dr.Franklin, ILikePie5, oromagi)

6 -Theweakeredge (RM, MisterChris, gugigor, coal, Intelligence_06, FLRW)

2 - Undefeatable (Sum1hugme, coal)

2 - Ramshutu (whiteflame, Ragnar)

2 - Speedrace (Supa, Wylted)

2 - thett3 (bmdrocks21, Wylted)

2 - Lunatic (whiteflame, Wylted)

1 - Intelligence_06 (RM)

1 - Fruit_Inspector (Sum1hugme)

1 - semperfortis (Ragnar)

1 - 3RU7AL (FLRW)

Debates

5 - THBT: WiKiPEDIA is a MORE RELIABLE SOURCE for INFORMATION than FOX NEWS (MisterChris, gugigor, oromagi, Intelligence_06,

oromagi v. Fruit_Inspector

4 - Resolved: Violent revolution is a just response to political oppression (MisterChris, whiteflame, Ragnar, RM)

Undefeatable v. MisterChris

3 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games in Their Curriculum (gugigor, coal, Intelligence_06)

Undefeatable v. Intelligence_06

3 - Resolved: Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict. (MisterChris, coal, Ragnar)

blamonkey v. whiteflame

1 - TOURNAMENT R(2): Speedrace vs MisterChris (whiteflame)

Speedrace v. MisterChris

1 - Resolved: There is not systemic racism in United States government, as a whole. (oromagi)

fauxlaw v. Undefeatable

1 - Constantine the Great should not be considered a mainstream Christian, because he was actually a heretic (oromagi)

Nevets v. fauxlaw

1 - THBT Systemic Racism Is Definitely a Problem in the US (coal)

Undefeatable v. coal

1 - Should Abortion be Made Illegal? (Ragnar)

Caleb v. Ragnar

1 - Resolved: God created “the heaven and the earth” with existing matter and energy and not ex nihilo. (Intelligence_06)

fauxlaw v. Fruit_Inspector

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park (Supa, ILikePie5)

By: PressF4Respect

2 - Why are we banning wylted? (oromagi, Wylted)

By: Lunatic

2 - Just checking in (Dr.Franklin, Sum1hugme)

By: Mharman

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1 (Supa)

By: Speedrace

1 - Send trumpet to jail now (Supa)

By: ebuc

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts (Discipulus_Didicit)

By: Discipulus_Didicit

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary (oromagi)

By: Greyparrot

1 - Fox/Trump Immoral Handling of covid19 (oromagi)

By: ebuc

#54

Debates: 34

Posts: 5,754

3

4

11

https://www.debateart.com/forum/topics/5488-just-checking-in?page=1&post_number=2

08.07.2021 05:37PM

3

4

11

08.07.2021 05:37PM

-->

@Vader

I voted why are we banning wylted you fucking dick

#55

Sum1hugme

Debates: 37

Posts: 1,014

4

9

Sum1hugme

08.07.2021 05:50PM

4

9

08.07.2021 05:50PM

-->

@Barney

@Vader

@Dr.Franklin

This is the link he was talking about. I also nominate this thread

Topic's author

#56

Debates: 30

Posts: 14,694

5

8

11

08.07.2021 07:21PM

5

8

11

08.07.2021 07:21PM

Users

10 - whiteflame (MisterChris, gugigor, Dr.Franklin, ILikePie5, oromagi, bmdrocks21, coal, Intelligence_06, FLRW, Tejretics)

8 - MisterChris (Supa, whiteflame, gugigor, Dr.Franklin, ILikePie5, oromagi, Ragnar, Intelligence_06)

7 - Fauxlaw (RM, Supa, Sum1hugme, MisterChris, Dr.Franklin, ILikePie5, oromagi)

6 -Theweakeredge (RM, MisterChris, gugigor, coal, Intelligence_06, FLRW)

2 - Undefeatable (Sum1hugme, coal)

2 - Ramshutu (whiteflame, Ragnar)

2 - Speedrace (Supa, Wylted)

2 - thett3 (bmdrocks21, Wylted)

2 - Lunatic (whiteflame, Wylted)

1 - Intelligence_06 (RM)

1 - Fruit_Inspector (Sum1hugme)

1 - semperfortis (Ragnar)

1 - 3RU7AL (FLRW)

Debates

5 - THBT: WiKiPEDIA is a MORE RELIABLE SOURCE for INFORMATION than FOX NEWS (MisterChris, gugigor, oromagi, Intelligence_06,

oromagi v. Fruit_Inspector

4 - Resolved: Violent revolution is a just response to political oppression (MisterChris, whiteflame, Ragnar, RM)

Undefeatable v. MisterChris

3 - U.S. K-12 Public Schools Should Incorporate More Video Games in Their Curriculum (gugigor, coal, Intelligence_06)

Undefeatable v. Intelligence_06

3 - Resolved: Developing countries should prioritize environmental protection over resource extraction when the two are in conflict. (MisterChris, coal, Ragnar)

blamonkey v. whiteflame

1 - TOURNAMENT R(2): Speedrace vs MisterChris (whiteflame)

Speedrace v. MisterChris

1 - Resolved: There is not systemic racism in United States government, as a whole. (oromagi)

fauxlaw v. Undefeatable

1 - Constantine the Great should not be considered a mainstream Christian, because he was actually a heretic (oromagi)

Nevets v. fauxlaw

1 - THBT Systemic Racism Is Definitely a Problem in the US (coal)

Undefeatable v. coal

1 - Should Abortion be Made Illegal? (Ragnar)

Caleb v. Ragnar

1 - Resolved: God created “the heaven and the earth” with existing matter and energy and not ex nihilo. (Intelligence_06)

fauxlaw v. Fruit_Inspector

Threads

2 - Tyranny at Lafeyette Park (Supa, ILikePie5)

By: PressF4Respect

2 - Why are we banning wylted? (oromagi, Wylted)

By: Lunatic

2 - Just checking in (Dr.Franklin, Sum1hugme)

By: Mharman

1 - Captain America: Civil War Mafia DP1 (Supa)

By: Speedrace

1 - Send trumpet to jail now (Supa)

By: ebuc

1 - Record attempt at the fewest posts (Discipulus_Didicit)

By: Discipulus_Didicit

1 - Hunter cover up getting scary (oromagi)

By: Greyparrot

1 - Fox/Trump Immoral Handling of covid19 (oromagi)

By: ebuc

#57

Debates: 50

Posts: 2,934

5

9

10

08.07.2021 09:26PM

5

9

10

08.07.2021 09:26PM

Updating my nominations a little:

Debates:

THBT Systemic Racism Is Definitely a Problem in the US
Seen plenty of debates on that subject, but this one stands out for good presentation. I don't think there's only one right way to present things, but good presentation is vital in debates. Additionally, the quality of the voting was superb!

Forums:

Just checking in
Blew the secret of the place wide open! ... And coincidently similar to the latest season finale of Doctor Who, but oh so much better!
Running Primary Poll Thread
Incredible insight, which must have taken a ton of hard work by Imabench.

#58

Debates: 50

Posts: 2,934

5

9

10