FourTrouble

If Earth flips town, scum MC explains why MC is pushing my lynch here.

If Earth flips scum, it's more likely that MC's very bad town. Post 362 supports this view.

I'm inclined to believe MC is scum as well.

MC, do you think Earth is town or scum?

MC, calling my reads "baseless" or "accusations" doesn't make then so. 

Expressing reads (however strong), being transparent about how you view the game, and changing reads as more info comes in -- none of this is scummy. 

Playing different from what you're used to -- also not scummy.

Millers aren't a policy lynch. It's actually a strongly town indicative claim if done early in first post of the game.

What's your behavioral read on Earth, Pie? 

Interactionless isn't a tell at all, period. 

RM, I believe your analysis is strongly tainted by confirmation bias. Assuming for sake of deeper analysis that Coal is town, who are the scum? 

Pie calls it "convenient" that I scumread Earth. This shows a lack of understanding. Nothing about my reads are "convenient." They're based on the evidence provided, which began with strong behavioral evidence and was followed up with an investigative result. 

I'd also like to note that Earth has literally confirmed that he's guilty, so I don't know what you're waiting for.

Actually, each ability is associated with an item. I don't think it'd be wise to list what these items are, or the other abilities. And therefore, I won't. 

You're asking the wrong questions, whiteflame. 

The character says that I'm a fierce swordswomen, an S class wizard, and that I have "different abilities" due to "different armors and swords" that I can "equip," and fact that my character has multiple sides, at times "tough" and at others "soft."

I guess I should clarify that I have multiple abilities, each 1-shot. I'm not solely a "day cop." 

What's the likelihood that town Earth claims miller after a guilty instead of his first post?

Earth's scum. Why aren't you voting him?

Lol @ Earth's fake claim

Response to Pie: what if scum have a role that allows them to negate MC's role? What if there's a hammerer who hasn't spoken (or isn't allowed to)? There's many possible reasons not to test MC's claim, from a purely theoretical pov. Being overly cautious (your approach) would recommend against putting likely townies at L-1 just so that we can test something that doesn't help us solve the game in at all, but certainly presents numerous risks.

My character is Erza or something like that.

Post 185. Believes I'm lying. Evidence of uninformed perspective (if Earth is scum) informed perspective (if Earth is town).

Post 183. Pie believes I'm fake claiming. Potential evidence of informed perspective about Earth's alignment.

Pie's paranoia seems townish enough. Let's lynch Earth.

Pie, his role is already locked. No need to test. This isn't something that scum lie about.

Post 185 is not a cc.

I'm a day cop with a guilty on Earth. Supa just reported this info to me.

The people who disagree with me are people who aren't very good or experienced at mafia.

Playing on many different sites is helpful for realizing that you can win 100% of games by focusing on behavioral evidence, and that all the rest is a distraction that scum routinely manipulate to mislynch.

Pie, work with me. Let me help open your eyes.

I don't mind a mass claim just to get it over with. It's super annoying having to deal with this distraction throughout the game.

Post 166. That's correct.

I'm going to policy lynch the next person who suggests testing MC's claim.

Pie, join me on Earth. Prove you're town!

Pie, you gotta break open from your cage. Learn to see.

Post 144. Earth is scum.

Okay, so I guess Coal is town. That's a helpful starting place to decide next steps.

So whiteflame is scum? Everyone agrees?

Posts are pieces of evidence. They speak for themselves.

Explanations are for those with cloudy eyes, unable to see the obvious.

Pie = scum because: awkward pointless questions, attempt to discredit me despite my reputation, awkwardly asking others to read my behavior instead of analyzing it himself.

Pie, what's your read on RM & Oro?

RM hunting third party is scummy as hell, though. That's how scum thinks.

Oro could be scum. Could also just be bad town. Unclear.