ILikePie5

One of the dumbest things I've ever seen written in a mafia game. 

Did you full claim in your first post? Nope, therefore "anti-town."

Also, you are not the entire town. If in doubt, try VTLing me again as you keep threatening to do, your vote won't suddenly be worth more. And again, only scum would hammer me, which would out themselves.

...

And to be clear, I gave my partial claim at Lunatic's request, not yours. Your fake pressure means very little.

You've given not even a soft claim, and now you're pretending you have an extra vote.

Undue pressure may work on brand new players, but I am not one.

If anyone wishes to hammer a fellow townie while there's nearly 2 days remaining in the day phase, by all means, out yourself as scum. That does town more good than what I can.

I've given you my character claim, as requested, and you have not removed your vote. So I'm now pretty sure you're scum seeking mislynches.

If moozer gives us nothing this day phase im fine with lynching him. This is ridiculous 

My role is also confirmable tomorrow as well I will add

I had a choice as to whether to use it and I chose my target, yes.

Of  course you may.

First, as I signaled at the end of the last DP, he was my trickiest read. I wanted to either have a target to sus this DP or be able to eliminate him as a plausible target of suspicion.

Second, after I received the PM, I agonized over who would be most likely to give me this and believed that most anyone else would have been more likely, since I figured Earth didn't solidly townread me following on DP1. I believed he was about as likely as you were to send this to me, so I flipped a coin. This is how the coin landed.

It's a means by which players can have AI direct their tactics, hence I put it in the tactics bucket. I don't really care to argue how we should perceive it because, either way, it's distinctly different from the other claims made so far and from mine as well. They are all markedly different.

He's at L-1. Ball's in his court.

I’m going to need something more than that, some bucket that this falls into or is associated with. I can push for full claims after everyone has given a softclaim. This is too vague.

Alright:

I received a PM from Austin saying that I had an opportunity to use a chess engine at the cost of my night action. If I used it, it would allow me to find out the alignment of my target during that NP.

I accepted. I targeted Earth. I was told he was innocent.

After the fact, I was told that this ability could not have been redirected or roleblocked.

I don't like how Pie is rug pulling town on his character claim and there is no way Pie would know or come close to knowing what the theme is. Town should get a hardclaim from Pie.

I've already stated that I'm also a strategy, so I'd put myself in the "tactic" bucket as well. I think Luna has been pushing a soft claim since the start of the DP, but I'd nonetheless like to get some clarity as to which camp he falls into. So far, we've seen tactics (using Stockfish), individual moves (Castling), and pieces (Pawn). Algebraic Notation is more just a descriptor that covers all these things to some degree.

So if you fall into one of these camps, state which one, and if not, state what camp you do fall into. Since I haven't seen evidence of a softclaim from either of you, I'm tagging you two first, and I'm taking my vote off for now.

I was told I would receive the alignment of the player I chose. I used it. I was told I could accept or decline, and I chose to accept, targeting Earth.

If that's your idea of a joke, you need to try harder. There are four people who have less outed information, yourself included. By any standard, you're being a dullard.

the problem with me is that it's too 180 imo. Don't get me wrong if you played different but kept some of the same parts of last game I would think you are town asf, but this is a complete 180 imo, almost as if it's a calculated maneuver to flip people into thinking you are town

For the sake of progressing things... I'm a tactic.

Pie: Probably the closest to a town lean based on his behavior last DP, though in my reassessing things this DP, he ends up more null to me, particularly after those reads. Just like Luna, he's not very specific about what makes Luna look townie to him beyond being more incisive with Supa. I get that that makes it less likely that they're a scum team together, but he seems to be hedging a bit on this read with the "but you never know" at the end. I guess he's ending up with Barney in scum through PoE and frustration that he hasn't answered questions yet, which makes more sense to me given what I know of Barney's behavior as scum. The fact that he's claimed to have a confirmable role means he'll either be cleared or at the top of my scum list next DP, so he's not the focus of my attention right now.

Pie - I think Pie would likely be my top scum read. His spearheading of a JoeBob lynch is quite literally the exact opposite of how he played last game with some minor similiarities.

As I stated in Option 3 of my theories, I don't put it past Pie to go and push a Savant NK to give himself town cred using the WIFOM strategy. Seems like that behavior analyzing and all that is something he tends to do. 

I can only use my ability, protecting one person and making one other person's ability untamperable for one night.

I did nothing, seeing as I only have one shot, so I better use it well

Also, I was told this after the fact: the action I took was not considered an "active action." I asked for clarification, and what that means is it doesn't behave like a normal night action. It wouldn't have been affected by a roleblocker or redirector (yes, he did say that specifically). So, while a Godfather might fool it, I think we can confidently say that the result is the one I got on Earth, not the result of some change of target.

I'm going to decline, at least for a little while.

Barney hasn't contributed enough for me to form a read on yet. 

Moozer is suspicious by POE.

My top scum read is supa at the moment. I will go further into detail on this soon, but I wanna hear his "theories" first. 

And I'd like a pastrami sandwich. We don't always get what we want.

Didn't you just ask me not to claim further?

Yeah the NK doesn't make sense because even if scum knew he was the role, they could've just used him as a mislynch target because of the Miller aspect and his role. I have a few theories though

poor savant hasnt made it past dp1 once...

Yeah, it's kind of baffling. Savant would have consistently been a target of some suspicion and, given that he said he couldn't confirm the second aspect of his role, I wouldn't have seen him as much of a risk to leave alive.

Wtf is Stockfish