ILikePie5

game of thrones- why wouldn't you know that?

Hey fellas I forgot this existed AMA

A bit of a polarizing user sometimes, but prone to boughts of some impressive insight from time to time.

I always have a weird vibe with yyw

So I think Chris's flip helps give us a poe with him as well. I'm surprised he really hasn't pressured drafter for backseating but goes after chris who is a much easier target. 

To me drafter sticks out more than Chris 

He's usually more vocal about what he thinks and he's just been very agreeable with what people are assuming about the theme and not engaging as much as he normally does. 

If this is the case, why should we base the entire theme split on it? I feel like with the characters we've got, it doesn't make a lot of sense to be so rigid. if we WANT to be rigid, we should target Speed if anyone, although I don't think he's scum rn. 

This was inaccurate and Oromagi showed you that it was inaccurate. In his first post in #47, he said that his show was Karate Kid/Cobra Kai

Well the Wiki labels him as antagonist, but he returns the gifts thus making him the protag. But not til the last 2 minutes

My concern is how tf do you justify the Grinch's behavior. My pm says the bad shit, the justifiction of the bad shit, and then the turn. How do you jusitfy the Grinch just stealing presents and fucking with people? I don't get it

And with Chris being inactive and barely skimming DP, I know we discussed the PM's and how the bad was justified. It seems like to claim he didn't read that part and thought of a basic claim that everyone would know about good turning bad

I actually start to scum read Pie a bit more for this. To change the conversation of a theme that town itself decided as true is sketchy.

I also am sketchy of MisterChris's claim. While the Grinch does turn good, I also think it could be an easy fake claim for someone who wasn't paying attention. Also my PM states that my character did bad things, but then justifies the actions, then states I turned positive. How would justify the Grinch's action before turning good? He was just a fucking dick 

This would throw a dent into the entirety of Pie's theory since there would be Movies v TV Shows, but you are a combination of the two, so how would that be possible for theme split. If everyone is either movie or tv then you would have a character matches both, but in a different series. That would make no sense. I am going to ignore Pie's theme split theorizing

Right now I have a slight lean scum on Pie. He's being more active, which means he's either a PR or Scum

Again, read the first sentence I wrote in this game. 

Also, POST#540- "TUF specifically mentions both the tv show and the movie."

So you edited my movie and tv show claim to just tv show? That doesn't make any sense. If you really thought I was trying to play both sides you would highlight the fact that I was the only one claiming both (at that time). But you did the opposite, you edited the film claim out to make 3 neat TV claims- as in 3 scum.

So that's another falsehood- that's obviously not what you were thinking.  Want to try again?

POST #138

"I think that's interesting because my character is definitely a more 'shades of grey' character and TUF invested a lot of text in spelling out that complexity."

Another false accusation.  The first thing I typed in this game was that I am both Karate Kid/Cobra Kai- which you have just agreed makes me both, which you have failed to note I've been saying all along.

Another false accusation.  The first thing I typed in this game was that I am both Karate Kid/Cobra Kai- which you have just agreed makes me both, which you have failed to note I've been saying all along.

Why do you keep making shit up about me?  Why won't you answer the question that started this?

Why did you edit out my claim to be both FIlm and TV?  What were you thinking?  What advantage did you hope to gain?

Chris, yes.

Oro, no.  Johnny Lawrence is the antagonist in Karate Kid, not the protagonist.  I have seen every one of those movies and Cobra Kai.  

Readers will note that Pie still hasn't answered the direct question that made him freak out and start accusing me.

Why did Pie change me from Film+TV to TV only when making a case for Film vs TV?

Why did Pie freak out instead of simply acknowledging the error?

What does Pie think of his Film vs. TV theory now that The Grinch is on the table.

I'm the Grinch from How the Grinch Stole Christmas. My character sneaks into the Who's homes to steal from them, yet my hatred for the Whos is warranted because they treated me with contempt for being different. I also have a point when I say their Christmas is just being about material things. 

but that's not inverted.  Inverse reality would be scum=protagonists, no?

OK if this is the case, I'm a town antihero too. I'm a villain that had a point, but is a protagonist under this definition. Frankly I just thought that anybody who was "Evil" was automatically an antagonist. 

That's changing the subject again and that's not what you believed one hour ago when you edited out my Karate Kid claim in post#518.

 IF you thought that Film+TV was scummy then you would have said so and preserved my Film+TV claim.  

Instead, you claimed that TV only was scummy and modified my claim to TV only only to change your mind now (apparently as some kind of defense)

So, you still need to explain what you were thinking when you modified my claim.

Apparently you haven't read any of my posts because I have already discussed the dual shades of grade nature of my character and noted that TUF invested some energy in writing my character's defense.

So, we have you

VTL'ing me without reading any of my posts,

modifying my claims to make me appear less town

Dodging my simple, direct question like Pee Wee Reese

(long pause while Pie consults the scum PM)

(long pause while Pie consults the scum PM)

I asked you first and I have the moral high ground- removing evidence that corresponds to town is a scum move for sho.

My first post of the game was POST#47

The character claim was locked in here. Coal has figured out and has already said so.

TUF specifically mentions both the tv show and the movie. What advantage did you hope the gain by editing that corroboration out?

I was just looking for the post where draft claimed movie. (see #533) can give me post#?

fix'd

TOWN

oromagi         (karate kid)

Don't change the subject.  You came up with a theory of tv show vs film,  then edited out my made-early-and-oft-repeated film claim....apparently to increase suspicion on me.

I would like to know your thought process when you modified my claim in order to fit your theory.

I note you removed my Karate Kid claim in spite of consistently claiming Karate Kid from early on.  Why did you do that?

Let's just say that it's a holiday movie and leave it at that. 

I don't have a problem disclosing whether my character appears in a movie or a TV show, though I fail to see any utility in doing so.  No facts so far suggest that the TV/movie distinction matters. 

Whats the justification for killing Chris?

Whats the justification for killing Chris?

Low key the theme may just be Characters in Movies vs Characters in TV Shows with each character basically being an asshole and their actions justified to fit the inverse reality stuff.

Supa - Negan - Miller - TV Show (The Walking Dead)***
Oro - ____ - ____ - TV Show (Cobra Kai)
Warren - ____ - ____ - TV Show (Game of Thrones)

Pie - Magneto - ____ - Movie (X-Men)
WF - Lt. Harris - Cop - Movie (Police Academy)
Drafter - ____ - ____ - Movie (???)
GP - Omegol - Hider - Movie (Lord of the Rings)
Speed - Hyenas - Vanilla - Movie (Lion King)
Elm - Wicked Witch - ____ - Movie (Wizard of Oz)

***There’s plans to make a Walking Dead movie

MisterChris
Coal

Let's not try to walk and chew gum at the same time for the moment.  Read over the posts I have written that mention Chris.  That should clear things up. 

Warren's time may come.  But for the moment, it's Chris's time in the sun.  

Right now, MisterChris is who I want to hear more from.

He has been hiding in the shadows.  It's time to step into the light. 

Wth does your PM say dude. Put everything paraphrased

The part about starving and being exiled ?

1. We know that Lunatic has put in multiple entity characters in his games before according to drafter's recollection, which I verified to be to be true. Which means this wasn't a 1/2 minded attempt to fake claim

2. We know the risk of claiming a character that is an outlier that could be scum read. Speed admitted to this in the first post he made, suggesting he knew his character was an outlier and wanted to claim it in the same way an SOP claims due to the oddity

3. I do not think that Lunatic bastard modded the game to where there would be 2 characters from the same form of entertainment that are on opposite teams. The theme and characters are so vague and unknown, to have the same show for opposite teams would be considered bastard in my opinion for this type of game, where the characters are too vague to resort 2+ characters from the same show

3a. The more ideal thing for Speed to do is claim Scar, as it will draw less suspicion to his character, hence making it easier for him

3b. I personally think Speed did not look back 1 and 1/2 years into mafia within 6 minutes of the DP starting just to see if group entities are in the game so he could claim did this.