ILikePie5

Take for example the last game. One of my options were 1x PGO, and that it would only kill the first person to submit an action against me. So had I picked that and say a cop submitted "Cop Earth" first, and then mafia nightkill me later, I would kill the cop and be nightkilled. Im guessing it’s a full powered PGO.

Im rereading, but I haven't gotten to it yet. Just in case no one asked, does your PGO have any limitations?

I have been skimming the DP here and there since the start of the day. I don't object to lynching an inactive.

I also don't know if mafia are gives fake claims in Casey's games? Can anyone verify if they are or aren't. Isn't specific in the DP so I would rather see from other sources what the trend is

Figured I'd compile a list of probable ERBs in this game. I've excluded the 2 known ERBs and I'll give away that mine is in to this group. Still struggling to think of splits beyond a basic distinguishing element like "Villain vs. Villain" or instances of recurring characters, which do occasionally happen in ERBs (I think Abraham Lincoln showed up 3 times after his first appearance, always in a political match-up after he battled Chuck Norris).

Rasputin vs. Stalin

Jim Henson vs. Stan Lee

Darth Vader vs. Hitler

Steven Spielberg vs. Alfred Hitchcock 

Jack the Ripper vs. Hannibal Lecter

Joker vs. Pennywise

Barack Obama vs. Mitt Romney

Mozart vs. Skrillex

Luke Skywalker vs. Harry Potter 

Edgar Allan Poe Vs. Stephen King

Albert Einstein vs. Stephen Hawking

J.R.R. Tolkien vs. George R.R. Martin

James Bond vs. Austin Powers

I think everyone should say whether they’re on the list or not and if not, we can ask 

How many of the games you looked at was he scum?

Austin's first post comes off a bit scummy to me. Maybe it's just because of how many times I've played with him specifically. As town he tends to start with posts that move the game forward, whereas when he's scum he's more likely to make posts that try to avoid any suspicion. i.e. "just checking in" or "Pie SOP claiming makes sense" which contributes very little.

VTL Austin

Also no copy-pasting your PM

I kind of figured wylted swapped your role so I didn't say anything (you did ask him to do it)

All part of my master plan to confirm Austin without losing my roleblock. I knew scum more likely than not had a role designed for better kills and that if Vader was scum, the temptation to use it would be too great. Since he was my top scum read before it came down to me and Austin, I had a close to 50% chance of stopping the night kill.

That or I just got kind of lucky. Mostly the latter.

We thought GP was a bulletproof. Could not risk another no kill. The Wylted kill was to throw town off and direct some blame and sus to other directions

The way Earth interacted with Vader is NEVER scum-scum, trust me on this

Wow I can't believe the obvious scum was obvious scum

Vader just got back to me and said I can't vote first and shoot. He answered in error. I can still shoot though.

To me, it matters that it informs two lynches rather than just one, whereas shooting Vader will almost certainly have no chance of informing the lynch this DP. Maybe I’m wrong, but I doubt it.

Again, my point was and remains that if Casey flips something that is not Mason, that’s when it matters.

I’ll admit, I missed this scrolling through your posts on my phone. That’s my bad. I’ll take your point on this one, it is possible that Earth could have a daytime and night role, though I still think GF would stretch the wording you posted pretty far.

Not sure what this has to do with my point. If Casey is a scum or town mason, then their recruiting you is possible either way. My point was if we verified that Casey is not the mason, that could inform the lynch since you said you’re in a separate chat with him through the mason role, though I guess that doesn’t matter given Earth made his choice.

If y'all think I'm scum so badly and Casey flips town when you shoot, town is essentially fucked. I always am under the pretense that getting rid of scum first is better than taking a gambit. I obviously am going to disagree with me getting shot because I am town anyway but it is going to be too hard to go post for post on this issue on why Earth should be the lynch

Really not sure why WF is spinning a 5th gear over Vader getting shot...