ILikePie5

I voted for third party candidate.

Looking at things from the standpoint of "What do Whiteflame's DP1 actions suggest his partner is?" I think you're very unlikely to be scum. You were on his wagon, and that would have been a very risky bus. Banana is likely -- I've already mentioned WF throwing some sus on Banana but not voting for her. Vader is a possibility as well; WF said practically nothing about him.

Essentially, I view a Cop claim in a Luna game with a bit more suspicion than in an ordinary game.

My role is one way that a Cop result could be incorrect. Assuming that Pie is telling the truth, there's also a scum RB'er. He's also limited to odd nights. Putting it all together, I think the claim is at least plausible.

I'd like to hear more from Moozer and Owen. They haven't given much in the way of reads this DP.

His cop claim seems bogus too. Hope others will see the writing on the wall with this one. Why did he wait so long to claim if he was odd night anyway? Makes no sense. 

Yeah you are getting blocked. I don't have time for little boys with small egos and even smaller.... Well we all know ;-)

VTL pie.

I think the last mafia is between him and casey, but I find it really suspicious that mharman died, and he was the only one putting real pressure on pie to claim, and as soon as we get into day phase 2 everyone just stops caring about the fact that pie said multiple times he would on day phase 2 and just hasn't. 

If I get lynched that is okay, I am kind of over this game anyway after everyone was rude to me day phase one, but as long as pie gets lynched in the end I'll be somewhat happy with the result of this game.

I am pretty sure he is mafia, and my instincts have proven to be pretty good so far, so if anything, take that away from my contribution so far. Pie is probably scum, if not him my second guess is casey. Pie is leading the town and everyone is intimidated by him so no one will pressure him for a claim. He's not that scary guys. Lynch him.

Actually, that's a fair point. I don't like how Pie has refrained from fullclaiming. Everyone else has done it by this point.

Once a game, during and DP, I can assume the role of a dead player. That becomes my role for the rest of the game. 

Pie - The argument you can make for Pie being scum is that he hasn't fully claimed a role and soft claimed "investigative." From what I've seen (could be wrong), he hasn't claimed a song either.

Most likely waiting til all claims comes out to do such. I don't hold activity into high account so that's a non argument, but I think he was a bit hard on banana in Dp1 and definetly was pushing him hard until the WF claim where he very quickly changed his vote to ensure he wasn't the L-1.

Not to mention the biggest opposer of Pie who was catching on is dead.

I didn't use the role because I wasn't notified of the NP and even if I was on during it, wouldn't it be best to wait to see the dead roles I could take instead of guessing? How much of an idiot am I being? 

In a game with a Mafia Super Saint and a Town Compulsive Bus Driver? Plus, I think Moozer is very likely to be town, so add on a Hated Townie. Seems super scumsided to me. 

Banana, I would like to know why you targeted me specifically

Hi guys, sorry about the inactivity. How many people want my claim?

Wait, I’m confused, was WyIted mod-killed? Or did he die because he hammered or something?

Anyways, I’m a hated townie and a 1x double voter. You can VTL me now to test. I can change my double vote whenever I want, it just has to be within the course of one DP, ie. I just tell Luna that I’m using it, and I’m a double voter for that day. I can do that whenever you guys want.

Can there not be 3 or something?

Why does mharman being gramps implicate me? I don't understand.

Since when were any of you giving me a choice on who hammers me? I’m being actively scumread, so I doubt you’d take my choice regardless. Banana would be my choice if not for her claim, and I don’t have any other behavioral scumreads, so I guess the default to Casey makes more sense than lynching someone who hasn’t claimed.

As for my role being borderline SOP, that’s going to come down to a difference of opinion. I’m not convinced this would be a smart SOP claim and I think it would just have put me on the chopping block earlier.

I will consider it. Banana has no incentive to kill themselves unless they are town. You are taking what gamblers call a negative freeroll here where only town members will hammer if the person is scum. 

We just confirmed Casey is town. How about we vote pie who we were supposed to force a claim on like we promised banana?

You know what wf makes a good point. Who has the most faith he is scum here

unvote

I don’t love how so many people are dancing around hammering me. If you don’t believe my claim, hammer me and prove it to yourselves. All this effort to get someone else to do it makes me think several of you buy my claim but are voting no me anyway.

Yeah I’ll full claim DP2

Ok.

Banana, please hammer Whiteflame or you face the wall.

Perhaps I should be the one CCing Banana, not Pie

Fixed

Now we’re just getting into modpsych. Bombs and Super Saints have both come up in previous games, so it’s just a matter of which you think is more likely in this game, and with this song almost a given to be in this game, I could see why he’d choose to go this way.

Ah, there it is. Recalibrating…

How do you go about looking for people to pressure?

It isn’t. Seems like the idea was to fit with the theming of the song.

I’m “Kill Yourself” and I’m the Suicide Bomb. Note that it’s not the Suicide Bomber. This is just like the normal Bomb where the last person on my lynch dies. Justification is that Bo is one of the few people who could do this song without getting cancelled.

Wait, you talking tomorrow as in Nov 4 or DP2?