Mharman

Your role doesn’t have any further utility to it. That’s my point.

Since we’re on the topic of reads. Part of the reason why I want to lynch someone (likely Banana) tomorrow… I should probably post those notes of mine too

I’ll type out a full set of reads when I get home

Joebob gave fuck all last DP in terms of reads. Not a fan of it.

DP ends Friday night. I’d prefer to lynch someone tomorrow instead of today.

Anyway, if we’re going for Banana, I suggest we coordinate who hammers. It should be someone who isn’t useful to town anymore. Sorry Pie, but I think you might be the best candidate.

Banana’s role does sound scummier for sure.

Thank you.

Last thing: Yes, you should tell everything. You will get lynched without doing so, like it or not. You are obviously town to yourself, but to the rest of town. Including me. I will say that I am torn between you and Vader and will have a better idea in the morning. I suppose I should think whether or not it’s a false dichotomy, but it’s gonna be hard to do so if one of you has given me a reason for a scumread. Something like refusing to full claim would be an example.

Took 2 hours btw. Goodnight, don’t expect me to be active in the morning. If awake, I will be groggy.

Anyway, I just got done with reading DP1. Wrote some notes on some of the things that seemed notable to me, for both possible townreads and scumreads.

Will be mulling them over in the morning, with a read and note taking of this DP as well.

Correct me if I’m wrong… But is it not possible for Earth to hand out cookies to living players from purgatory?

Does Earth hand out cookies to others in purgatory? 

I wonder what the incentives of the cookies are, if any exist

Oh yup. That confirms it… which means we can’t really be certain Vader shot correctly based on Savant being in hell. But then why would Savant accept such a cookie? Perhaps there is some reward for doing so.

Wait a minute. If going to heaven is tied to a cookie, why would going to hell be tied to being mafia? Wouldn’t it be tied to Earth’s cookies instead?

Could it be that the cookie givers can give out cookies after death? It should be noted that Earth said he could win by surviving, or by giving out enough cookies. Surviving seeming to be optional if he gave out his cookies.

Earth did seem to be ok with dying, which in theory would have cost him the ability the win the game. But not if he can give out cookies after death.

Oh and Vader is added to the town list, forgot about him

I'm gonna go reread the game thus far while waiting on a Banana claim. I'll add my vote to the wagon after Wylted posts a vote count. Things certainly aren't looking good for Banana, so I might be eating crow soon.

I guess he just wasn't feeling it

Honestly I'm shocked Earth didn't gaf about his wincon

Town:

Greyparrot

Pie

Casey (dead)

Other Innocent:

Owen

Mafia:

Savant (dead)

+ 2 more?

Other guilty:

Earth (dead)

Owen is innocent.

OH lol. 

Why the hell would Banana reject that?

I think Greyparrot is town. I've decided.

Not sure. There are inactives who haven't had time to answer Pie's question about who has your role now.

Sometimes GP just... says stuff like that. For better or for worse.

Eh. He called all of us actual fucking trolls last time he was mislynched as town. I wouldn't take it personally.

I don't think Savant's non-flip has anything to do with Greyparrot's new role. Bio-engineer doesn't seem to match Savant's entry. Most likely scenario is scum's flip being hidden on death.

vote count?

I'm pretty sure Trump knows he's not gonna get a third term lol. I didn't know Canada had term limits, though. That's kinda fucked lol.

I'm going to guess so. May have been a dick move on my part to use that. Sorry Wylted

Really thinking Vader shot correctly now lol.

Even with 14 players, I think 2 town killing roles might be a bit much, especially if one is vigilante

I'm not convinced that there are two killing roles. Also, I just said why you're probably town.

Did you forget to add someone to the purgatory thread?

Actually that changes things though. I was gonna take Banana's side thinking she explained things poorly (and some sketchy things about Vader)... but now I may have to conclude he shot correctly, which would imply he's town. Hold on lemme think.

Oh here's something btw...

Savant isn't in the purgatory thread, despite being dead.

I'm gonna have to second Pie here. Give all details or get lynched.

I know you say you've given all, but I don't think that's the case.

Please give a synopsis of everything, even if you've already stated some of it.

I have some thoughts on that... although it is certainly going to depend on Banana's full claim. Give me bit to type it up.

So, are we all forgetting about Vader vs. Banana here?

Does your rejection kill people, or is that a separate part of your role?

You tagged the wrong person

Alright fuck this shit. My brain cannot process this right now and the solution is to sleep.

I think I’ll be better off tackling this tomorrow.

 Do not rush into a lynch… we have time.

Assurance of your affiliation is more important than the usefulness of your role. Anything that makes us more likely to lynch Vader over you should be considered helpful. 

Alternatively, he could just not be a vig and it’s a gutsy fake claim.

Not necessarily but I see the theory.