MisterChris

lmao do me justice

Yeah, my bad

Mwahahahha, I am death

you can edit, I mean we forfeited lol

Yeah. That1 kind of boned us accidentally, plus my stupid mistake this day phase didn't help. 

Thanks Speedy ;)

Well that was dumb. 

Let's get this over with VTL MisterChris

LMAO yeah you caught me. 

I tried to fake claim, you'd think that I would double check the character list *facepalm*

Alright, I'm finally caught up for the most part!

I've been busy with debates and hanging out with the family today, sorry for being absent.

My character is brigadier general George Thomas. I am one of the few southern-born Generals who stayed on the Union side during the war. I played a key role in the Western Theatre, and my valiant defense of Chickamauga earned me the nickname "the Rock of Chickamauga." While I had a successful career, I failed to achieve the notoriety that some of my contemporaries received. I also neglected to write memoirs to further my legacy. Thus, I am VANILLA.

That's subjective but I'd have to agree as well

lmao 100% agree

Falls under both. "This is being posted in multiple threads, Ill try to combine lists so we have an accurate count"

Mods have given permission, as is stated in Bench's initial message.

Found a few, but it was tough. 

/in

I still think That1 is mafia. Supa has given no reason for us to distrust him, plus if he is wrong we can simply lynch him. Plus That1's third party claim doesn't make any sense.

I honestly can't believe scum team gave out Bear's role. I would think the whole advantage of having a Janitor would be for fake claims, so it doesn't make any sense. It has to noobs like Lunatic said. I think that narrows down our targets pretty substantially. Like, for example, I can't see a scum team with Oro allowing that

Oromagi's aggressive attack on Supa leads me to believe he is working with That1. I feel that he is the most promising DP3 lynch. 

Fr. I don't even get why Croc plays

"imo" stands for"in my opinion."

The PM Theory Oro had was that if Pie sent out uniform PM sentence structure to all the town members, we'd be able to identify non-town because their PM's wouldn't line up. Pretty far-fetched

Yeah for sure

It was the PM theory... which IMO doesn't hold much weight. I don't get why he focused on it so much

He is suspicious, for sure. I think the priority is a That1 lynch but he is next on the list for me

Yeah sorry not really buying the excuse here. Even if you are third party, that is still a policy lynch in my book because third parties normally win by killing town. 

alright... So 2 more

hm. Well, with her being a jack of all, do you think it is more likely for a 10 v 2?

Yeah it's pretty much a given. How many scum are there in a game of this size?

That's my fear. The moment of truth will be the next day phase but if Bear was doctor or something you're dead man

vamonos

Not out of woods yet, we don't know what Bear was. For all we know he was something really important. But yeah. This was a good catch

Smart. I mean I guess it's a fair read. She definitely didn't act that way last game

oh ok, that makes sense but seems pretty op

Yeah, I have to second Mharman. I'm very confused. Don't mafia kills give off info of who the target was? That's how it was last game.

Yeah, we were wrong that he was scum.  But I was going into it with full expectation that he might be town, and it still seemed like the best thing to do. I don't think it was a big loss.

We need your input. I suggest a Croc hammer (even if we think he is town), but it is up to you.

Understandable lol

He's not in any debates atm

Yeah, it's not voteworthy or anything, I just wanted his thoughts on the Croc lynch but he seems to be out of it. 

Anyway, yeah I agree with you and Lunatic that this game is pretty weird. By the end of DP1 in the Naruto mafia I'm pretty sure me and Lunatic had duked it out for a solid 10 million posts

lol, dunno about if he is mafia, I just wanted his thoughts on a Croc lynch

Am I the only one noticing a complete absence of Oromagi? I wanted to hear his thoughts

There's arguments for both sides... But I think it's clear he is our best option as is. If within the next few hours something amazing happens that indicates we should lynch someone else, then great. But for now I think the best scenario is a Croc lynch and cross our fingers

lmao yeah, not a true win but it would sully his record

Yes he is. I have no shame losing to him although I like to think we would be at least a bit closer in skill level nowadays lol

Yup. Truth is, the leaderboard is very inadequate for showing the skill of debaters. All it really shows is the ability to farm and the willingness to not forfeit.

I've lost to Virtuoso, someone who is #103 on the leaderboard right now. Admittedly, I was a lot weaker as a debater then, but I was a lot higher on the board than he was at the time. 

Well, that's all under the assumption he is town. If I can assume he is town and he still looks like a good lynch there is a problem. 

Frankly, I'd say there is a solid chance that he is mafia. 

No, you've been farming. Most debaters here only take debates that they think are worthwhile or interesting. You seem to take literally anything you think you can win.

It's not wrong, you can totally do that if you want to (Oromagi does it sometimes). But that's still farming by definition.

He won't even defend himself... Much less contribute and help find scum if he is town. We do not want a ELO (Eliminate or Lose) situation with Croc. 

Mostly from farming debates with Seldiora

This sort of solidifies my position to me.