Total posts: 3,159
Posted in:
-->
@Bullish
@warren42
Ok. Either way, should be interesting.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Crocodile
Did you use multiple abilities last night, or just one?
Created:
Posted in:
Are you saying you can do multiple actions on the same night?Yes
Dafuq? This is not how JOAT works.
VTL Croc
Created:
Posted in:
Ok just got back, and I'm reading through the DP.
What I get from this is that Croc claimed tracker (but then refused to justify), and then claimed JOAT (while possibly CCing two people).
As he has a result on Warren, it is very likely that if Croc flips town, then Warren is scum (unless there is a strongman in the game, which is still a possibility).
If Croc flips scum, then everyone else on the RM lynch is town, and Warren will seem a little bit more town, and we can just go off of the rest of the list.
I don't like Warren's claim, but Croc's claim switch raises a few eyebrows.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@skittlez09
I asked for you to justify the link between your role and your character, not that.
Created:
Posted in:
If you go into the forums, and look under "Topic", you will find "THIS IS NOT A FORUM TOPIC".
Hence, "THIS IS NOT A FORUM TOPIC" is a forum topic.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@oromagi
Corvius or Corvus?
Corvus. I accidentally typed an I in there without realizing it.
Is this a 1X ability or can you do it again?
Sensor is a 1x ability.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
Ex: Yellow Brick RoadPurple Rain
These two songs should be disqualified
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
Ok that is possible. Strongman somehow slipped my mind lol.
Created:
Posted in:
I've read the description of Seraph Knight that was provided in Drafter's list (in the resource Speed provided at the beginning of DP1), and it doesn't hint at a delayed action at all. This seems like Warren trying to make something up because he got tracked last NP. This, along with his weird "strong" town read of RM from very early on in DP1 from what seems like a single post RM made (scum knows who town is), makes him very much scum in my eyes. I'll VTL Warren as soon as Croc's identity is confirmed.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Crocodile
You've already outed yourself as a tracker, so what's holding you back from revealing your character?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
@WaterPhoenix
@Crocodile
Wait, isn't tracker a role in and of itself?
Created:
Posted in:
I have some important info.
I am Corvius Glaive. My character found Vision at Edinburgh in his quest to obtain the mind stone, and also found a way into Wakanda's medical lab. Because of this, I am sensor.
I used my ability DP1, and found that 4 of the people on the RM Lynch are town.
Since Supa turned out to be third party, this means that there is probably one other mafia on the lynch, and one not on it, if there are 2 mafia in this game (which given the third party makes the most sense).
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@warren42
I’m actually really surprised I won lol. Some of the songs (like Darude Sandstorm) I literally came up with off the top of my head and didn’t expect to get a really good score. Anyways, thanks for this, it was really fun, and I discovered some good songs that were submitted here!
Created:
Posted in:
Recently, there was a statement made that, had it been made outside of a mafia game, could have possibly warranted moderator action. In light of this, there is one issue that I feel deserves attention.
Should the COC apply to mafia games? If so, then to what degree? Should the whole COC apply, or just certain portions?
What do you guys think?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
Don't worry about these guys. Natural selection will weed em out ;)
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@MisterChris
Jesus the person? Maybe.
Jesus the character in the bible (the one that resurrected)? Probably not.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
Self-sufficient villains vs granted-power villains.
And how do you know this split?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
No, you see, because RM knows Speed better than Speed knows Speed. When Speed said there is no theme split, what he really meant was that there is a theme split, namely the one suggested by RM ("good" villains vs. villains vs. "third-party" villains), according to RM.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
Oh no, I didn't "suddenly go back to scumreading" you. I was just busy dealing with your cheerleader Warren.
Created:
Posted in:
Oh boy, RM is now taking this personally because we caught his shenanigans.
He is essentially playing the same way that he did last game when town outed him in DP3 (trying to deflect the attention onto others), except this time with extra spice.
VTL RM
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@warren42
No I read 136, which is the fucking problem. You say "You went in on Oro and User." Let's see what you consider "going in on"
- User
- "Why is crocodile probably town?"
- "What makes you think RM is too hard to read? After all we are only like an hour into the day."
Why ask him a specific question about a specific thing he said if you don't plan on ripping into him further? This just seems like you trying to get an inexperienced player to slip up and then wagon them.
Man. I sure did "go in on" him. Asking him two questions about his reads. Sure was harsh. Maybe the mods should ban me for how hard I went in on him. I can't believe I was so terribly rude to him.
Strawman.
After that I can't imagine the harsh things I said to oro...
- Oro
- "Oro said he "probably" wasn't vanilla in a game where speed explicitly stated in signups there were no vanillas. That's legitimately suspicious."
Oh wow, casting suspicion on someone for a post they made. How nefarious!
You tried to put a role into Oro's mouth based off of the softclaim he made and scumread him based off of that. Yeah...
Weird way to admit that you aren't reading the thread... #95
When I said "where", I was looking for a post number. In #95 you just said "SEE YOU DID IT AGAIN". I explained it in #136, which you ignored half of and twisted the other.
In #113 I then talk about how his mod psych stuff about theme is more likely to come from town in my opinion.
Post #113:
Everyone else, do we think RM is more likely to insist speed has made a subconscious theme split and work on analyzing it as scum or town?I'm slightly inclined to go with the latter.
All you said here was that he did X, therefore he could be town or scum. You then went on to say that he was a townread for this, again without explanation.
I reiterate a combination of the two, as well as just some other general liking of his thought process and that I think it's townie, in #209.
Post #209:
I think he's wrong but I like his thought process, I think he's town.
Again, no explanation.
Then, you apparently ignored when I tagged you and gave you some more reasoning in #228 (because why bother actually reading my arguments when you already know my alignment, right?) about how he's come to conclusions (mod psych, existence of third party, etc) I disagree with, but that the way he went about reaching them felt as if he's town.
How does the way that he went about reaching them lead you to believe he's town?
Post #228:
I have a single townread that I have qualified earlier by saying that the strength of it was unwarranted and essentially gut, and since I've essentially said I think he's wrong on just about everything but his thought process reads town to me.
Again, no explanation on how his thought process reads town.
It would probably be too much to ask for a claim, since I guess you are going to blatantly refuse and lash out at others, just like RM.And then this is just blatantly being a dick for no reason. Super cool, love playing with people who are rude just because they can be.
Saying that it would be too much to ask for a claim is "being a dick for no reason"? What?
If I asked you for a claim, would you claim? My guess is no but you can prove me wrong.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@warren42
Read 136 again.
Also, when I asked you where I was "switching" my reads, you never responded.
Also, the only explanation I saw from your townread of RM was that he was "pure" and "transparent".
It's clear that you are going to keep trying to deflecting my questions and claiming that I'm "switching" my reads on you.
It would probably be too much to ask for a claim, since I guess you are going to blatantly refuse and lash out at others, just like RM.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
I lromise I will not claim. I have both done nothing to deserve being picked on and also am happy to make a shitty town lose if they're going to treat me this way, end of discussion.
What does you claiming have to do with others "picking on" you?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@warren42
Can you shut the fuck up with this "fanboy" bullshit?
Mmmmmm I taste salt
You townread RM right off the bat at post #24. Scummy. Now you're cracking at the seams, which your OMGUS clearly shows.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
@warren42
Mafia and third party have different win conditions. Often, if one wins, the other loses. So if I'm scum and Oro is third party, then why would we be together?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
Thirdparty is scum, is that confusing for you?
What? Third party has a different wincon from both town and scum. Hence, third party.
You still haven't answered #151
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@User_2006
Like, what do you think about the gameplay from the players in this game so far? Who do you think is more town? Who do you think is more scum?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
ScumPressF4RespectOromagi
So first you claim that Oro is third party, and now you claim that he is scum. Please explain.
Created:
Posted in:
RM - yes I Townread myself
Guys I am sorry, when I said this:Kingpin can't be godfather unless.this.is daredevil's storyline. The OP says daredevil isn't a hero in this. Kingpin's nemesis is daredevil.I just realised after reading Little Cookie's post on the page before this (last post on the page) that it was Deadpool's storyline that's ruled out, not Daredevil's. I apologise. That said, I also realise that this is irrelevant now as this is a pure villain-on-villain game (which I did not at first think).
More artificial attempts at trying to seem more town.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@skittlez09
Assuming RM is scum it'd make a lot of sense that the scum team was full of active players cuz the main reason he was on the defensive last game was due to the mafia being inactive.hence why hes on the offensive now as he has a squad for support this time around.granted this is assuming he is scum
Good read.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
Why do you want me to force interactions on Oro? Are you suggesting that we are both scum and that we're purposefully avoiding each other? If not, then why else would you want me to force interactions with him?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
Yes, I also have reads on your fanboy Warren.
Created:
Posted in:
Except this time he's on the offensive, rather than the defensive.
Created:
Posted in:
Just read through all the new stuff and RM's play this game looks very similar to his play last game
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@warren42
You went in on Oro and User
Why is crocodile probably town?What makes you think RM is too hard to read? After all we are only like an hour into the day.
Oro said he "probably" wasn't vanilla in a game where speed explicitly stated in signups there were no vanillas. That's legitimately suspicious.
But also made post #24 out of nowhere.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@warren42
You keep shifting the reasoning for why you scumread me.
Where did I shift my reasoning?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
@WaterPhoenix
What concerns me the most about Warren's post #24 is that it was vague (using general adjectives like "pure" and "transparent", as well as saying "I dunno"), out of the blue, and was phrased as a response to a question (though there were no posts addressing him prior to #24).
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@oromagi
I know. What I said was that if we all claimed early, then scum would know who's who and who to eliminate first. That's what I meant by "outed". Also, scum would have a pretty easy time fakeclaiming, given the plethora of choices in the MCU.
Created: