Vader

Alright actually that Shield claim I kind of like to be honest and it's not for the way he claimed, gonna kind soft-ish claim but my role really isn't a traditional mafia role from my knowledge (or in any games I've played). Shield seems like some form of doctor and based on my role, this theme of having unique variations of roles based on certain aspects of the character make sense.

Also too I feel like if he was scum, any teammate (even if knew), would've just told him to claim a protective and not a new shield role

There is a way that Lunatic can still be alive yet draw the same suspicion but I am not gonna say (assuming he's telling the truth about visit negates action) so that we don't give scum any way of trying to win

I hate to bring out the mod psyche here but I sort of think that note puts Luna as likely town. It is likely to ask about hypotheticals but I don't know if he would do that as scum from what I have or copy and paste the exact message. So I kind of think it pushes him a bit town from mod psyche alone IMO 

Noted was just  a bit confused

Is that specified? I don't think I've ever been in a game where that's the case  

Who did Mharman replace for?

I also think this is a game where it's not hard to fake claim if you discover the theme. It's a countries history and you can point out a shit of people to choose from if they've been around for a while. 

Honestly there is some good feedback with the results though.

I will say I feel like ADOL has been harping on this theme split a bit that's only a slight indicator (though the pattern is holding strong). However I feel like the theme would've been easily discovered by scum and they would've fake claimed something else. I think his adamence to push seems a bit sus but I am not sure if that fits the meta (if anyone knows)

 No real scum read just kind of pointing out this shouldn't be fully believed and kind of wanted to gauge the response you gave

Yeah exactly I'm just airing my thoughts.

I am inclined to believe you for the most part. Feel like your responses have been towny and the character aligns really well to the role. I also just feel like having it every night is way too OP as well that it might just HAVE to be town cuz if I was scum I would've just claimed the 1x to play it safe.

Yeah I read that whoops I thought I big brained that

I guess that's a fair strategy that worked out really well for you, but even then wifom you could apply the same logic but take down 3 town. 

Nevermind I read Wylted's post wrong

Hold on? I need to check something but didn't Wylted claim what Savant's character is?

Ok so this is interesting.

I am genuinely skeptical of these types of claims, but the every night definetly makes it somewhat less fake claimy. But still I think I have thought of your Justice fakeclaim in Casey's last game on my mind

Alright good to know.

Did this fruit do anything? 

Was it a specific fruit?

Did anything interesting happen last night?

I'm preparing to graduate college and then going on a 3 week trip to Europe.

How abou you?

Inclined to agree for the most part. Gonna give my reasons in a moment

Wylted's lack of real substantive post kinda leans town-ish to me. It's pretty anti meta of him. Even when scum he tends to be a prolific poster and not really backseat and I feel in a game where activity is a bit lacking, he would for sure be trying to dominate and control the game. For that reason I town read him

I feel like Cerculean is kinda going on a tangent about really nothing at this point with MYLO and LYLO. Almost seems like it's a way to generate a response out of someone or something and doesn't have any substantive value. But it seems like he's tending to pick up on little inconsistencies and terminology and negating them. Not sure if that's scum or town play on him so someone let me know but it feels town-ish? I think it will be good to keep in my player notes though

Ok I just saw that his role was after death and best used after MYLO so that answers the question

safe*

Pie being adament about his MYLO lynch is pretty interesting which makes me feel he has a certain role. But then again I don't know if there's some utility to him being lynched then, or if it's solely because his role deactivates MYLO/LYLO (which I am tempted to ask). Either way somewhat peculiar and I don't really see him saying that and going for that strategy as scum. He would likely be playing it safe and looking to soft something space

Sorry have been swarmed with projects and activity has been lower but going to catch up

Twist the role to be scum*

Role confirmed, but honestly don't see a world that this could be a scum role unless you think I'm meta gaming or bastard

I'll give my full reads and such. I just don't think there is enough substance to make hard and long winded reads

I am very sus of That2. I frankily hate Beloved Princess claims because I inherently think they are a good scum claim. Gives a form of an out for not being lynched because they can easily play the card. I also hate how they went about softing their role. They were extremely vague for quite literally I believe no reason. I kind of want to think that they are an executioner but they have not been acting as such. But their behavior seems very and the justifications contradict themselves quite a bit. 

I have not played in a game with Cerculean so I have a pretty null read but I feel like they have good logic and thinking about things critically. Though I would like to see some more behavior substance

I've stated my reasons for banana. I feel like I have an idea what their roles is and coming from a game where they were heavily criticized and drew attention to themselves, I don't feel like banana would've willingly done that. Plus I also think if a player with experience is their partner (which not rulling out a noob can't be), I would think they'd rather them not draw attention with a statement as that unless there's a big meta play and I just don't think banana can think that way yet with their 3rd game. Slight town

I'm honestly pretty neutral on Pie. I don't agree with him that my posts have been fluff (there has been a bit than I would like), but there was only 37 posts and I gave my opinions thru what was given. As for the piggybacking, nothing is going to happen if I just clog up the forum with the same post WF said and I would get read in the same way. Despite that I think his pushes have been pretty town meta for him and I feel like he probably would've been on That2 harder if he came on earlier

I dislike Earth. I think he came on way too quickly to put pressure and on only the 3rd post wants to try and put claim pressure on someone just blindly following Pie. A bit FoS imo

I would honestly put whiteflame in a lean town but this is more gut. His pressure on That2 that was based on thematic analysis and breaking it down into multiple aspects and confronting head on claims seems more of his town meta than I have seen as scum, but lately my reads have not been great on him but gut is telling me most of his interactions are town.

Luna is null but I am likely leaning town on him. I think his approach of game comes off as townie so far and I think his analysis back to past games and other things makes me feel town. I honestly couldn't get a good grasp of his scum play last game and I feel like I don't really get solid reads on him til DP2. His pressure on That2 comes off pretty townie and since he was the first actor of it I doubt he's bussing a teammate that hard 

Everyone else is null

I personally think*

My role has a confirmation mechanic. I personally my role would likely put me in the town pile but others may disagree with it.

I don't rule out Casey getting something wrong, but I am going to mod psyche a bit, after how my game went with mod mistakes and such I feel like they would've taken some what more time to look at the info

Still I want to give That2 time to explain themselves to see if they can fully clear it up

Almost sounds like they are being vague on purpose. The response to assassination or execution of "just died" throws me off

I don't love the way That2 claimed their character. They said they were killed in the October Revolution but then backtracked it a bit. Even if it is a nitpick that's pretty weird to say "I was killed" then backtrack a bit

Yes I would agree. But I am also kind of going off the average scum play so can't really measure, but I guess that would be the logical play

Don't have any true scum reads at the moment. Finishing up a paper and going to check back in

My character is before the Soviet Union formation

I think this is a way to get things going with claims, I think a big way we can limit the claims is this

Are you a part of the Soviet Union history or from Russia history (anything before Soviet Formation and after the fall of the Soviet Union (so 1917-1991))???

There really isn't anything substantitive in the DP besides I think that Banana is leaning town. Don't think after the last game they had they would want to draw any attention to them until they had to. I have some idea of what they could be claiming just from how I perceive roles that could help town that tend to be mafia and I don't see why they wouldn't lie, unless there making a meta play that's big brain, but I feel like if they had a partner they would've told them to do claim something else and don't soft it

Hello. Catching up now after some project work and watching the Masters

Checking in. Won't be able to catch up until tonight

Happy birthday

in 

Ok not never asked, but it was for DP1 asking

This was never asked. The mechanic of the role itself is for the same day, not the next day

Ninja - does not appear on watcher or tacker reports.

The theme split is that you are in the New York Crime Family. I will not give you specific fake claims but I will give you hints about the game

1. I would stay away from claiming anyone in the DiMeo Crime Family. Try to look for characters outside that specific group of characters

2. The setup has no cop. There are multiple protective roles as well. This game has a role known as a Backup, where the player inherits the first town player to die. Do with this info as you must.

Vent your anger