Wylted

I am excited guys. We caught scum . Look at speeds passive posts this game which match his dp2 play last game where he was scum. I. Contrast to his assertive and less agreeable town play on dp1 of last game. To me this is pretty transparent and obvious speed is town. Please help me lynch him

I think at least 2 of you. are definitely town maybe your schedule is too busy to participate but you can still help your team in this game by VTLing Speed.

Speeds meta matches his dp2 play from celebrity mafia better than it matches his DP1 play where he was town. 

I like some other targets but Warren was right to have me dig deeper into speed. I think we need to go that route. Hopefully I have more energy to present. More convincing case speed is scum tomorrow,  but right now it seems pretty obvious given the information I have. 

Last game speed was town dp1 and scum dp2. You can see he is aggressively scum hunting last day dp1 and on dp2 when he is scum he became more agreeable. And even when he was targeting somebody specific he tried to ease tension 

Why does speed standout to you?

Just reread through speed's posts. They are bothering me more now. He is clearly buddying me and he seems to fear tension. Members of town usually don't mind tension as much but he seems to fear it by easing  tension with tiny jokes or smiley faces. Also buddying the most aggressive player is the most obvious move for somebody fearing conflict. 

I am still confused about his post 36, which bothers me. He made an effort to explain it, but his explanation seemed to avoid telling me what he was thinking. Perhaps it was a gambit to make bmd nervous as if he was pretending to read his soul. A sort of attempt to elicit a scum slip by inducing fear.

I have to reread his stuff. He has had barely any of my attention unfortunately.  I sensed from the first two pages of interactions he was town. 

Okay, sounds good

Yeah I would be opposed to a hammer without giving him a chance to speak. Especially since I think CC and Water are also good targets. 

The only way I accept Warren is town is if he is the other mason. Then his frustration with pie might be legitimate and make him use contrived lines of reasoning to vent. 

Interactional

Scum has probably already deduced who the other Mason is from intersectional analysis. 

CC was clearly just trying to copy his meta from his first game, but got desperate. Claiming for town cred randomly and then voting himself in some odd attempt to get town cred instead of scum hunt. I honestly think this shit is a formality now. We lynch warren CC and then water. 

We will get to you tomorrow.  

I actually prefer a CC lynch to Warren, but I guess it doesn't matter too much. They seem to be on the same team

Warren is in your scum pool right. I think a lot of us agree with a CC warren team and I think water is a third scum to be honest. Want to lynch Warren 

Did you see their posts al.ost in unison criticizing Poe's logic. Almost like they were mocking his logic together in a scum PM

I didn't ask for analysis but I am willing to wait because I'm sure your analysis is interesting 

If you are busy just jump in and skip some pages. Read the last page and you can still get a lot of information fro. That. No need to let how busy you are get in the way of enjoying yourself on here.

Are you still online and are you ignoring my question about your reads? 

Jump in and start playing. Nobody cares if you make mistakes. This is a team game. Your team whoever that is, is here to help you navigate the game. Your goal as town is to find scum but we don't know who scum is. We lynch by voting a player to lynch, which takes a majority vote. So this is very team based

If you guys want to post less than make up for it with more depth. You can do that by just batching your time on here instead of checking throughout the day to make sure you don't waste any extra time adopting the style and in fact likely save time

I know life gets in the way sometimes and is more important than a stupid game, but just put in the appropriate effort. 

Also the 1 2 3 categories are not rankings of ability. XLAV was in category one but was great. BSH1 is in category 3 but he is mediocre. The categories are just styles not rankings

Posting guideline for noobs.

1. If you are not providing much depth than you should be hyper posting.

2. If you are posting some okay analysis and actively hunting 10 to 15 posts is probably enough.

3. If you are providing very deep analysis that spans 1000 words and it is giving us honest clues about how your mind works, you can get away with one or 2 posts a dp.  _______

An example of some people in each category

1. Water pie supa

2. Speed disc

3. Nobody currently playing the game but BSH1 sometimes gets there for a recent example

I am willing to lynch anybody I don't town read right now. It is your own faults for not communicating in more depth

What are you doing? The game is 24 hours in and we still don't have a big town wagon. Start sharing your thoughts so you don't end up lynched by POE

Why did you claim. Don't let us speculate when you can provide the answer definitively. I need to know your reasons

Reads now please, even if you are committed not to act on them. We need your reads incase you are the NK so you can influence the game post mortem

Give me all of your reads please

Are masons town aligned if you have theoretically used them?

I think club could be scum as well. Claiming Mason out the gate like that was a stupid town move. Possibly too stupid for club to ever make if he was legitimately town but as scum it may give the appearance of being confirmed town from the perspective of naive players. Masons are often sometimes an odd combo of scum and town done for purposes of trickery by the mod. 

This is odd but ai am willing to lynch two claimed players now even though early claims are usually indicative of town. Both CC and water seem scummy to me. My read on water comes from the RVS stage though and he needs to be more forthcoming with his thoughts on the game

His character claim makes no sense unless he did it to try and force some town cred

He has chosen to talk game theory over game playing because it is easier to hide that way as scum and this may be a forced attempt to look consistent by VTNL ing so blatantly especially when game one he actually seemed to retreat a bit on that philosophy 

I think CC is scum. He is not scum hunting and he has went against his conservative style by character claiming with no prompting. Not to mention his only contributions are fluff. 

What are your reads so far. 

What are your reads so far?

This guy fancies him self as somebody into learning how the human mind works, while simultaneously saying behavioral analysis is pointless. 

I think I am done explaining this because you lack the cognitive capacity to understand. Results are bullshit and behavior is what we should be leaning hard on

I think one more full claim and then we can work on moving the game forward to a lynch or VTNL decision. Water is inactive so we need info from him.

I disagree. If inactivity is a problem. Possibly policy lynch so he can decide whether he wants to put in the effort or leave. I kinda ultimatum to put in at least a little bit of effort.

So when should I post my sign ups?

How is it diverse to fuck each others races out of existence until we become one race?

You can use those same bullshit reasons on DP2, because the possibility of killing town is always there. It is retarded logic. If we keep using your logic town would never lynch and scum would direct all the kills. 

Ut is stupid to limit the number of town directed kills. 

If you say so, I rarely see a game where information recieved by roles is really reliable though

Because in this game roles are useless. A cop can be flavored, the mafia can have roles that mess with results. The o ly information we have is behavioral. 

He will get better each game. It takes longer to get good on this site than DDO because it has a less active mafia community 

I swear every game. Stop this. We need to make the game fun for other players if we want an active mafia community.  We can't treat somebody like that. Club puts in good effort, is fun to play with and doesn't deserve to be ostracized every game. Why should he have to role claim every game dp1?