Total posts: 542
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
@BananaAre you also saying that you’re responsible for killing Savant?
What? Of course not. I did not act last night. Except to reject someone.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Mharman
you should probably unblock Pie so he can tag you in games
I honestly forgot I blocked him
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Can you elaborate on justification?
Wylted's justification literally says "because the subject is hamas, your role is ___" unfortunately thats all I have. Minus the other 13 pages of journal entry that is.
Explain.
I was told by the mod I can't :/ all I can say is someone visited me, and I rejected them.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
If you’re CCing, you need to full claim. Hell now, you definitely need to full claim regardless.
I basically have. I am only not elaborating on the specific functionality of my killing utility, because doing so will defeat its purpose. You would do the same in my shoes if you knew what role I had.
You just have to ask yourself why would I lie about this as scum, and do you believe town would have two killing powers?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
I already claimed as soon as the kill happened in the DP
But that doesn't explain why your kill has question marks on it, why would town hide the body of the player they kill?
Why weren't you CC'd for Israel and Hamas debate by Savant?
He is not israel vs hamas, he is just Israel.
Why did you choose to not activate your kill tonight?
Maybe my role doesn't work that way. Or maybe I wanted to avoid hitting another town player like you may have done.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Character, role, and justification please
I am wylted thoughts on the hamas vs israel debate, I am a killing role, because the subject is hamas.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
What is your killing role then?If you are going to CC you need a full claim
I don't think I should be the one claiming in this instance. For one if I do, it completely makes my role useless. I am claiming a town killing role is all I am going to say. I obviously didn't kill someone, you did, and your reasons seem very shoddy. And you hid his flip which makes it even more suspicious. Hoping people will see the writing on the wall here and vote for you.
Created:
Posted in:
VTL Vader.
I am counterclaiming him, kind of. He obviously is some sort of killing role, but I don't think he is town. I am a killing role too, and I am town, and two town killing roles seems very overpowered. I think he is likely mafia or third party.
Created:
Posted in:
Well, when I was third party I could joint win with whoever won, also I just had a low chance of guessing the game ending phase correctly anyway. With that said, Earth's third party role doesn't help town in any way, and we can't leave him alive or we lose, so it seems killing him dp1 is the smartest play. That said I fully believe he is third party. But I will vote to lynch him.
VTL earth.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
@ILikePie5
For pie and luna and anyone still asking about my stupid role PM: I am sorry I didn't clarify this earlier, but my role justification and my role are in the first message, completely SEPERATE from the other 13 messages. The other 13 messages are like a journal entry or something. I know what my justification and role is without reading all that. Are you happy now? I guess I should have been more specific, didn't think you all would read into it so much...
Anyways catching up now
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Why did you not read it all?
Because it does not relate to the functionality of my role, and quite frankly I don't care about israel and hamas.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
@Greyparrot
Why are you voting me? I understand what my role is and how it works, the rest of the 14 messages do not impact my role. It seems like it's a copy and pasted diary entry of his thoughts on the israel vs hamas conflict. I don't know why reading all of that would be relevant.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
Worth reading it in full in case there's pertinent information. I received multiple messages as well and while it looks like a lot of it is just WyIted digging into the theme, you should be making sure that you fully understand how your role works and asking him relevant questions.
I don't know that it is relevant. Its 14 pages of his thoughts on the hamas vs israel debate, and the role and how it functions is separate from the rest.
Created:
Posted in:
Hello all. My Role PM was 14 messages long. I didn't read the whole thing, but I got the idea of it.
Created:
Posted in:
Well Vader feels town to me, I am pretty sure the two last scum are austin and whiteflame. Both were on the lynch that got executed. But for now I think i will vote austin because wylted is voting austin, and he's pretty much the only person who is guaranteed town at this point, since there isn't any way mafia would silence themselves twice. If wylted instantly voted austin I think wylted knows something, or has some information that points to austin being mafia. Maybe he CC's his character or role, or maybe has results, or something. Either way, austin is in my POE, I am okay lynching him or whiteflame as I am 90% sure that is the scum team. I will vtl austin for now.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Why aren't you suspicious of austin at all? His vote was on savant first. HE could have been lurking after voting just as much. They are both equally as sus to me.
They are both suspicious but whiteflame's more suspicious because of how close the day ended after he voted. They could both be a scum team though. Greyparrot also voted but he was town.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
Anyone could have taken advantage of my vote, and I’m not the only player alive who had their vote on Savant. I understand the sus, but I’m pretty careful as scum. Why would I just give myself away when the tides were already against Savant without my help?
The times don't add up, it looks like you, maybe savant and greyparrot were the only ones on when the day phase ended and we know both of them are town. Austin hadn't posted in a full hour before end of the phase. You voted, and five minutes later the day phase ended. That looks shady as heck mister...
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Okay so shouldn't it be obvious then? Whiteflame is scum because he voted savant and then savant was conveniently at the number needed for the mafia to use that role...
Vtl whiteflame.
Created:
Posted in:
Okay I am VERY confused. Why did the day phase end with only a couple votes?!
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
I can make educated guesses based on how 3p's were treated in past games.Why would you tell your fake claim if you were mafia? Well you already claimed your "real claim" so I honestly don't know why you would. Maybe to draw cred and for town to keep you alive??? Honestly idk seems like a bad move...The main question is, why do you have a fake claim for a 3p. No mods and games I've experience have had fake claims for 3p. Why is this game so much different compared to the other sites?
So your answer as to why I revealed my fake claim is that I am just dumb and purposely chose a move that would hurt the scum team for no reason, as opposed to the fact that I am actually just third party? Why would I lie when being third party is just as bad as being mafia, you guys are talking about lynching me either way, so what purpose would it serve me?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
I can make educated guesses based on how 3p's were treated in past games.Why would you tell your fake claim if you were mafia? Well you already claimed your "real claim" so I honestly don't know why you would. Maybe to draw cred and for town to keep you alive??? Honestly idk seems like a bad move...The main question is, why do you have a fake claim for a 3p. No mods and games I've experience have had fake claims for 3p. Why is this game so much different compared to the other sites?
So your answer as to why I revealed my fake claim is that I am just dumb and purposely chose a move that would hurt the scum team for no reason, as opposed to the fact that I am actually just third party? Why would I lie when being third party is just as bad as being mafia, you guys are talking about lynching me either way, so what purpose would it serve me?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
You wouldn't be the target of a lynch if you claimed DP1. No one was going to lynch you. Plus the fact you had a fake claim for this role is so off. I have been 3p in a bunch of games and never had a fake claim.
You don't know that. Also i cant control the fact that i was given a fake claim. consider this; why would i tell everyone my fake claim if i was mafia huh?!?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
I am just not confident that Casey would put a third party role into this game considering the balance implications of this game. Also I don't understand how you wouldn't just SOP claim 3rd party in the beginning of the game
By voting me, your proving exactly why i wouldn't or shouldn't do that... i am only doing it because i got investigated and have no choice at this point. You can lynch me, it doesn't effect whether i win or lose anyway
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Why would you need a fake claim as third party?
Why wouldn't i need one? The mod wanted to help me blend in i guess.
Also why do you think savant would be confirmed town with you being guilty? Mafia and third party are not the same affiliation no?
idk i guess he could be mafia, i didn't really think about it like that.
Created:
Posted in:
Well I don't really know what to do here. This is an unfortunate situation for me, but I guess I will tell the truth. I am Gandalf vs Dumbeldore. My qoute is: "You shall not pass! I rap fast like Shadowfax. Tom Riddle me this you bitch, how’s your little wand going to beat my staff?"
I am the third party prophet. NP1 I had to choose a day or night phase I thought the game would end on. i chose np4. If I am right I win no matter what with the winning team, if I am wrong I lose no matter what. So I guess there is no point in lying about any of this, since being lynched won't effect whether I win. Casey told me I would show up as guilty on a report since im not town. So that means savant is probably town and there is no need for him to claim.
I was given Ghandi vs MLK as a fake claim with "Ascetic" as a fake role claim since Ghandi inhibits himself through hunger strikes. I understand if you guys lynch me here.
Created:
Posted in:
Okay earth doesn't really feel like hes putting up much of a defense. I am going to go with my feeling here, and VTL earth.
Created:
Posted in:
Okay, I was unsure about earth before, but that role seems very scummy. It seems like a good claim if you were scum and were wanting to not get lynched. I'll think about it some more, but earth was already null for me, and hasn't really done anything to strike me as town, and the role claim isn't helping his case.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Okay it seems there is something there with the earth read, I do not think my vote is needed yet, and I see no reason why he wouldn't come on and comply with a claim, but ill check back and see if a vote is needed before the day ends.
Created:
Posted in:
Can someone explain the earth scum read to me like i'm five? I am a bit confused.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Casey_Risk
The majority of players have voted in favor of the extension. This DP will end in approximately 9 hours at 6:00 PM EST.Votes:Lunatic (2/6): Banana, SavantEarth (2/6): Pie, WyItedBanana (1/6): Vader
I unvoted in post 260
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
What season are you from? Everyone not on the list is posting their season to lock scum into a fake claim.
Mine is on the season 2 playlist...
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Bananas opening post actually does give me some scum vibes because she seems to have caught up way too fast. Maybe she actually was reading along but it’s also likely she’s scum and her partner gave her reads or something. Idk just something that pings me but I’ll look over her post again later.
I actually have been reading the game since before I replaced in thank you very much...
Created:
Posted in:
My rap battle is not on the list.
Also unvote. I can buy lunatic's response for now, and admittedly it is a bit of a stretch. But he is contributing a lot more now, so I guess we will have to watch him and see from here.
Created:
Posted in:
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
Welcome Back! Have you had a chance to follow/read the DP?
I have been following it since it started, I just missed the sign ups for this one.
Created:
This is... Sad. I feel sad for you.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Greyparrot
are we just things that annoy the host?
Created:
Posted in:
okay lynch me then I dont have a role pm anyway so I dont think I am playing lol
Created:
Posted in:
I'd consider joining but if pie is a jerk again I will probably just quit. So if he can behave himself maybe I will join
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Mharman
I hope you were just trying to pull a psychological tactic back there.I’ve known Pie for eight years. He treated you no different than he would anyone else.
No, no tactic there. I was being me. What you are saying right now though proves my point I was making in day phase one though. You all seem to be okay when men are dicks to anyone, wylted, pie and even you got extremely defensive and angry whenever I would stick up for myself, but when pie or anyone else is an arse than it's okay. It really is a man's world. I was literally agreeing with you and you were so offended by my comment that you took personal offense to it. You just prove my point. You can say it was my behavior, really, whatever you want. If I got lynched for my role claim fine, but I don't really think that was entirely it. I think you guys saw and took any type of behavior from a a woman that doesn't equal 100% submissiveness and gentleness as toxicity, while ignoring it from your male counterpart. Happens in society all the time, especially in gaming. A male raging in a game people are way more likely to ignore than a forgive, a female reacts even half the same way she gets called the most deplorable names, made fun of, exiled, etc. I am used to that type of behavior, but I figured on a debate website maybe there would be slightly higher standards for that sort of behavior. Turns out I was wrong, so yeah, this will be last mafia game, I am not going to continue to engage in this type of sexism going forward. Thanks for proving my point mharman.
Created: