While transpeople deserve equal rights and dignity, transwomen are not women.

More rainbow More rainbow More rainbow

Sorry, I'm new here so maybe I haven't wrapped my head around the framework. We can drop the "dignity" part and leave it to "rights" if you like. I'm just looking for a civil discussion and I hope to better understand those who feel transwomen and women are the same as has been expressed often in certain media.

Alright. The dignity definition isn't quite what I was looking for, but, based on your definitions I might need to nitpick.

Okay, for the sake of argument, a woman is someone who is born biologically as a woman and by "dignity" I mean the dignity that all people deserve regardless of their sexuality. Is that enough?

Actually, you can make something out of this. I could argue this without needing to go into high detail especially since its only ten thousand characters.
I'll do this if you verify one thing, what is the definition of "dignity" and "woman"?

That's part of ,my confusion with this topic. At the least women are those who are born biologically as women, but I'm not sure if that's a controversial statement for some.

Kind of defeats the point when the definition itself is the debate. Probably best to phrase it as "which definition is better?" or something along those lines.

I advise adding a definition for women into this debate.