Casey_Risk

Surely you can't be serious.

As for this, either you are the Jester and you gave yourself away for some absurd reason or you aren't and this is a weird gambit.

Anyway someone hammer this Mharman noob he just got CCd and now he’s OMGUSing.

I need someone to tell me what’s going on…

okay lynch me then I dont have a role pm anyway so I dont think I am playing lol

RFD: he said he was Mafia.

I was rereading what Earth told me, and the message doesn't actually specifically say I am a townsfolk. It only says "you win with the town." I would've been told explicitly that I am on the town, right? I think this means I am really a third-party player.

Right now I am trying to figure out if Skippy or joebob/barney is more certain. I think we have to wait and see where Casey wants to go 

Dude, if I was scum with a roleblocking ability, I would not have said out loud what my ability was. Maybe there are strategies to that, but not a good one in this game right now. 

The reason being that two of them are passive--Commuter and Ascetic--and only one is active--Jailkeeper

I dont think it was but unvote just in case, just wanted a vote down before I went to sleep so things arent stalled out on me

I’m down to lynch Barney, but we have to be 100% sure, otherwise it’s game over. 

He (wylted) claimed ascetic.

So we have an ascetic, a Jailkeeper, and a Commuter. Three roles that deal with preventing actions happening/ blocking.

I suggest it because our major investigative roles are already outed, or dead. The only other thing I can think of us maybe risking is a potential protective role, and there might not even be one because mharman had a 1x doctor ability. Earth's prior two games only had bodyguard's also. If there is another protective role, I am guessing it's a weak one given the existence of the 1x doc. 

Wait, you weren't given anything?

Usually it's pulling teeth to get that man to claim, so I usually dread it but I think we should be mass claiming this phase to puzzle this out. 

Casey, does your ability deactivate at LYLO

Could we be at mylo right now?

I do have lingering doubts on Barney, since my character makes it ambiguous if the theme split is "Bosses aligned with Bowser / Bosses who aren't" or "Characters aligned against Mario / Characters aligned with Mario."

The justification for being a Commuter is that I am optional, but very difficult to fight. (Frankly, I think PGO would have been a better role.)

@Casey

What did magic do for you?

I guess my closest guess for a teammate would be Wylted first, Pie second

"Years", it was actually Earths only game, which makes the leap of logic of town having big time power roles like that even weirder for his second game.

This statement is so suspicious. Why would lunatic thinking a claim is scummy, make him scum?

Granted, the hours might not have matched up exactly since these sorts of things typically round.

I was picking up on the stuff you were laying down with skipper, because I also think he was laying the noob stuff on a lil too thick. Some of the questions almost seem like he is selling it too hard (asking what "SOP" means for example, that is a fairly common piece of terminology used all over the world, almost anyone who has ever had a real job knows what a "Standard Operating Procedure" is. That and I when he was asking about the pm stuff, a lot of that felt fairly common sense to me and where he over sold it is trying to say "Earth doesn't have my discord information, so I guess I have to be town right? haha right guys? look at silly little innocent noob me hahah!"

63 and 64 were reads posts of mediocre quality. Not obviously bad, but hedgy (note: "hedging" as in "playing both sides of a read to avoid committing to either") enough with Casey and Skipper that I didn't feel inspired to unvote. I suppose I could have said that exactly in 68, but I didn't.

I don't think it's unreasonable to read into activity, especially since you were online before then.

I think for the most part, I can't comprehend it. I lack understanding of certain terminology like "parroting" and "OMGUSing." I'm not very smart; I have to work hard to think smart. I feel like what Mharman says about Cerulean I can agree with, but I don't really know how to articulate that. My opinion is just intuition or emotionally-based 

So, noticing how he's accusing me (in the same post you called out) and how Cerulean seemed to be doing a similar subtle accusation in his reply to me earlier, I established a link in their behavior, meaning potential collusion.  The logic pipeline is essentially Cerulean -> Skipper for me.

As for now? His recent response to you about he understands your points is kinda pointing me in the direction of the former now; nonetheless I will acknowledge that your original case on him does have some points. I guess I'll say he's up in the air for me after that.

I guess you a have a bit of a point here that it is merely a possibility, but I wouldn't count out the idea. What about his behavior looks legit to you?

He kept his vote one me? Why not say why? Wouldn't that still be good for a reaction test? To me, the subtlety just looks like he's hesitant to commit to saying anything. Like something self-preserving scum would do, whether they thought super hard about it, or its more subconscious/instinct.

I won't lie, though. I'm more inclined to believe it because it looks like a post one would make while working connection with... Cerulean!

I'm actually saying it's not a reaction test. I'm saying he's faking one. I gave a reason for that: I just don't see the need for him to be subtle about it. He can say outright he doesn't like something about me and it'd have the same effect. The subtlety is part of the plan. He can call it a test if he gets called out, and he can wait for someone else to make a case on me... which I think he was trying to condition someone to do.

Admittedly, I am aware he can spin one of my points back on me. I've also been hesitant to accuse until now, so what gives? Well, I was hesitant because I know if I counter-accuse, he's got what he wants. In a way, I'm giving him just that- except for the fact that someone else from town is starting to take a look at some of these things- you're kinda my hero for being the ice breaker. I'm gonna trust you.