Total posts: 79
Posted in:
Put me down for modding a game. I have an idea for a D&D themed game.
Created:
Posted in:
By the way, I was totally bluffing about wanting the mafia to visit me. Or was I? The wine that comes with this role is absolutely delicious. Thanks to MHarman for igniting a passion for mafia I haven't felt in a long time.
Created:
Posted in:
WHEW. I am 'caught up' as much as one can trying to power read 850 odd posts. Going to make an effort to at least keep updated on a day to day basis. Reading mafia posts for an hour and a half is not exactly the most productive thing I could be doing.
First thing I want to say, is FVCK this whole "mod confirmed" bullsh!t. I don't buy it at all and have used similar tactics as scum myself. I don't like anyone taking this for granted.
I made notes as I went, so here are my reads. A lot of this is gut.
Vader - Scummy. Initially posted stuff that seemed like fluff/fake scum hunting. The whole business with his claim strikes me as scummy.
Cerulean - Gut says town. Analysis seems reasonable. Activity a bit lacking.
Mikal/Castin - Scummy. I don't like his fixation on the category thing. Seems like he thought he'd found a thread and flipped when better opportunities arised. I found #302 and #602 in particular SUS AF. My notes on Castin were 5 iterations of "sus".
Whiteflame - Gut says town. I'd be fine with lynching later because of useless role, but given scum have been given fake claims, why claim this?
Savant - Gut says very pro-town. First to claim and NPC. Vulture is a dangerous claim, but that doesn't strike me as scummy in this case. Analysis falls in line with my own thinking a lot of the time.
JoeBob - Scummy. Seems to want to find a bandwagon to jump on. Post #725 I marked as super sus.
Ultracepid - No read.
Casey_Risk - Gut says town. Analysis seems good. His meta analysis struck me as pro-town.
ILikePie5 - Scummy. Attempts at scum-hunting seem shallow. Marked as sus multiple times.
Lunatic - Gut says town. Did not like your 'fvck town' menty-b. Done that myself as town though, so hard to judge it too harshly.
Resurgent - Gut says town, but it's a weak and mixed feeling. Marked both "pro town" and "sus" more than once in notes.
iamanabanana - Low activity, possible town-lean.
Wylted - Strongest town read. Could you please verify what you meant in post #725.
If I missed anyone, they're a non-read based on lack of activity.
So, with all that said, the lynch I'd be most happy with today is...
VOTE Vader
If he flips town, not much is lost in my opinion.
Doctor should be on Wylted tonight and every night.
Created:
Posted in:
UNVOTE
Sorry about the drop in activity. I have had a busy two days between work and other commitments (just about to go and run my weekly D&D campaign).
I don't particularly like any of the wagons and it all seems a lot like the DP1 business as usual.
I'm going to VOTE No Lynch for now, being unsure about how much time is left. If I get the chance, I'll read through the 500 odd posts I've missed.
I don't have anything on for the next few days so expect a major uptick in activity.
Created:
Posted in:
Oh dear, i have a lot to catch up on.
Can we get a vote count please?
Created:
Posted in:
I cant reveal the specifics of how my bomb works because it would only benefit scum at this time.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Yeah don’t remember that.
It was South Park mafia, 5 years ago. It was DP2 though. I remember because i was so salty i havent played from then until now.
Created:
Posted in:
I am specifically saying the doctor shouldnt visit me because it would be a disaster to lose the cop and the doctor, plus whoever the mafia kill, in one night. Any one can get it though. Mafia should all visit me, definitely.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
You led a bandwagon on me DP1 for being idle. I was town and you were scum.
Created:
Posted in:
Inb4 lynch toaster because he wont explain exactly how the bomb works.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
@ILikePie5
Why do you feel the need to defend Lunatic?
First of all, i dont trust him at all. But i dont think him claiming to be a crafting table is scummy and will say so.
I thought the bomb only killed the player who targets the bomb for the kill. Can yours kill multiple players?
i would rather not give away the specifics of how it works, except to say the doctor should not protect me.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
@ILikePie5
Maybe I shouldn't dismiss you so readily then, but I still think it's likely you aren't scum at least.
And the WIFOM goes around and around. >:)
1) Why claim this so early?2) What did Mharman “exactly” call your role3) What is the justification Mharman gave for Pressure Plate being a “JOAT-like” role?
Answered the first two already. I figure im only one of several JOATs but the justification for me at least is that pressure plates are multipurpose.
What meta?
Well theres the general meta youd find somewhere like mafiascum where you can basically follow a flow chart and never do any social deductions and then theres the DART meta where someones previous game behaviour can give hints (or something like discord activity giving away scum).
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Dont buddy up to me you bastard. You know what you did the only other time ive played here. : P
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
fake claiming a Cop up front would be ballsy
Anyone who remembers how i play will tell you i have gigantic balls.
Created:
Posted in:
the worst thing that could happen for town is the doctor tries to protect us both up or
I meant the doctor tries to protect me and i blow us both up.
Created:
Posted in:
I took a gamble claiming my character because I believe it sounds rather scummy, on account of pressure plates being a big pain in the arse within the game. I claimed my role because of the rather OP but volatile nature of my role combination, the worst thing that could happen for town is the doctor tries to protect us both up or for me to get lynched early on before I can get some reads on people.
The mafia could come for me and sacrifice one of their members but 1 for 1 exchange is an outcome I can live with. Maybe they have a roleblocker too but a gamble is a gamble.
The mafia could come for me and sacrifice one of their members but 1 for 1 exchange is an outcome I can live with. Maybe they have a roleblocker too but a gamble is a gamble.
Created:
Posted in:
Poison darts, i didnt think of that. Also, TIL that you can use pressure plates to detect traps, hence the cop powers.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
Why do you think poisoner and cop make sense for pressure plate? Bomb makes sense, for obvious reasons.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Castin
Welcome to the game. Sorry Mikal gave away that youre scum DP1 of your first game.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Mikal
Mass soft claims is sop
Not in my town scum. Your entire reasoning fails when we have people claiming to be NPCs, so clearly not everyone is a category of item.
Created:
Posted in:
Also also, trying to get mass soft claims for no reason.
Created:
Posted in:
First of all, crafting tables are called work benches if we go by in-game vernacular and they are the most important item in the game. It makes perfect sense to be an alchemy table or a crystal ball rather than ‘work benches’ as an entire category. Acting as though claiming to be a specific bench is akin to claiming to be a red bird and a blue bird is such a stretch. Add to the fact that you initially thought he claimed his full character as ‘crafting station’ which isnt a thing while knowing that there are multiple types of pressure plates makes me think that you are fake scum hunting.
Also, you keep trying to make me, who has hard claimed cop, out to be scum for nonsense reasons. I am THE pressure plate. Not pressure plate. Not pressure plates.
i say we lynch Mikal and let mod sort out the truth.
Created:
Posted in:
Mikal sus af. No mass claims please. Only helps mafia at this point to work out who is the Nurse/Doctor. Crafting tables are a much broader category than different coloured pressure plates with slightly different effects. Doesnt seem weird that lunatic is a specific table for his specific role, whatever it is, especially when we have no information. Claim or im leading a wagon on you.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
Why would I think that neither cop nor poisoner make sense for pressure plate? Love when scum pretend to scumhunt. Lol
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
Im not trolling. Given my weird character and extremely unorthodox role, i figure this is some wild west mafia where you cant meta your way to victory so im going with a bold strategy.
Created:
Posted in:
Hello. I am the item called the ‘pressure plate’ and i have a JOAT style role where only one of the abilities make sense thematically. I have a 3x cop ability, a 1x poisoner ability and a 1x bomb ability. I will lead you to victory town, so long as you don’t let scum lead you down the garden path.
Created:
Posted in:
I live in Australia, so /in with the understanding that i am not active in the same time frame as everyone else.
Created:
Posted in:
Oh i see. The first sbd last time i tried to play here TUF meta’d me into being lynched using bullshit logic and that felt bad.
Created:
Posted in:
Anyone know what year I wrote this? Feels like it must have been at least 15 years ago.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Greyparrot
Here's my argument from my perspective, which is that of a townie, as to why I don't, at this point, think Speed is scum:
-Speed has claimed Stan. That's a strong ass claim.
-Speed didn't hammer me when he had the chance. Considering this wagon REEKS of mafia, I consider that a strong towntell.
So your nonsense chain post is just more pointless fluff trying to make gold out of shit like the last page and a half. Your Cartman right? That is far from a confirmed town character as far as I'm concerned. FOS right up in your grill son.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Greyparrot
How would I possibly know that he had just returned at the same time as me?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@drafterman
Yeah, I think if you were town you'd have hammered me.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lunatic
So you think I'm scum, and that I'm lurking to avoid attention and that I waited until now to say anything and my partner Speedsomething, who was slightly less lurky, conspired with me to jump on now and divert this wagon against me?
I'm embarrassed for you. Activity has no bearing on affiliation, I know that and you should know that.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
And that's useless fluff. You can see my evolving thought process. OMGUS (Lunatic)... but you're Kyle. OMGUS (WaterPhoenix)... but Bullish hasn't claimed his character yet.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@drafterman
And statistics on how often lynching inactives benefits Town compared to Mafia?
If I had rocked in and there were no unanswered questions, no one was suspicious enough of anyone else to warrant making a wagon and it was possibly LYLO, I can see lynching someone simply because they're inactive but in spite of all the other threads left to be pulled at, you want to hammer me? This isn't mafia scum, you had time... I don't understand why?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Speedrace
Lol, I must admit, I completely forgot about this. Long time since I've played mafia, so it isn't on my mind.
Created:
Posted in:
UNVOTE, VOTE WaterPhoenix
Lunatic has claimed Kyle, which is pretty strong. I guess this is just you being stupid.
Major FOS at WaterPhoenix, who was the most into this empty wagon and has the weakest claim of the people I'm suspicious of.
Created:
Posted in:
VTL Lunatic, AKA Tuf
You're far too experienced to be pushing a bandwagon against me because I'm "inactive". I don't play this fucking game to skate by abusing inactivity, but we've just had Christmas and New Years and that's why I'm inactive. Spent the past 3 days running around like a blue arsed fly. Just built the Lego Hogwards Grand Hall with my daughter when I remembered this game. This is the shittiest wagon I've ever seen. Once again, I doubt my townread on drafter because I know what a devious bastard he can be.
I sped read to post something, let me go back again and read in more detail.
Created: