Total posts: 1,888
I was thinking of claiming a variant of a bodyguard and calling it like "secret service" so that the cop couldn't die until I did and saying that's why I knew there was a cop but Pie didn't get back to me fast enough about if there was any possibility custom roles were included
Created:
-->
@Speedrace
Yeah, that's a good point. Lunatic you may not trust my claim but at least trust the results.
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
3 mafia with a godfather would be OP as fuck. 8v3 makes D2 MYLO as it is. I'm really hoping this is 3P or else this is terribly balanced
Created:
Also FWIW GP immediately tried to push me yesterday because I had been in the list of Mikal's cumreads, which feels like it should be obvious that I'm town as a result, since it's making it obvious mafia killed him specifically to frame someone (me)
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
@Speedrace
Ah I just looked at the two unclaimed people on Lunatic's list, Lunatic you should reorganize that so Bullish is with the unclaimed or in his own category
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
After my post last night I read up to around where GP claimed. I don't know if I buy that he's changed his meta, and honestly it feels like something he needs to prove before we can believe him. He doesn't claim as scum, he claims as town. That's my main suspect for today.Drafter's Mikal pressure is dumb cause Mikal hasn't done anything stupid (at least as far as I'd gotten)The speed pressure also felt dumb, I dislike the "this person is good as scum, might as well lynch them" argument which nobody overtly said but that's what the argument boiled down to
Created:
Speed if you’re cop out. I assume it’s water at this point though.
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
That isn’t what I said. I discussed how his claim was suspicious D1 cause he didn’t immediately claim. I proceeded with this D2 and then people immediately piled on. I didn’t want to hammer so quickly. So now, even though Grey was my strongest scumread and has been since D1, I look bad because his scum partner probably hopped on the wagon.
Scumreading me may have been a bit too far but you said this and have made it very clear that you just didn’t read anything I posted D1
Created:
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
I called greyparrot out D1. You clearly didn’t read my posts D1 and just said “no activity” cause that was easier
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
See this is why I was frustrated that you were suspecting me D1 and D2 for inactivity. I came in and character claims immediately when I was like oh hey I haven’t been on yet! Sorry about that but I guess I should probably immediately character claim. Grey pointed out oh that seems like a doc soft claim and I got pissed at him I was like why the fuck would you point that out if it was, it isn’t but why would you put it out if it was
Created:
Also Supa was a terrible kill lmao
Created:
Cop has two innocents, assuming one isn't me it's 4v2 game over. If one is me then 3v3 confirmed vs not
Created:
I also hard claim deputy, as I am (or was, maybe not anymore, regardless) the deputy chief whip. If this claim is believed then the cop can out their results and the game is solved
Created:
-->
@drafterman
I more or less started the wagon and didn't want to hammer 24 hours into a 72 hour phase. I pray to god that that's not the reason you're voting me
Created:
-->
@Speedrace
Checking in vs discussion, I feel like just lynching at this point isn’t the optimal play, I feel like D1/2 is always 86 pages then we speed through the rest and that’s not the best case scenario
Created:
*don't want to hammer yet, that is
Created:
Can we get a time check? I want to lynch grey and don't want to be accused of waffling here I just don't want to hammer
Created:
Regarding GP yeah that's also concerning to me
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
Based on what you said it was leading up to the hammer not after
Created:
-->
@Greyparrot
Or scum killed someone who was pretty much guaranteed to be lock clear D2?
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
I actually provided some input at the end of the day phase. I still don't particularly like GP given it breaks his meta. If he's town then I'm happy I'm wrong but this feels like something I want to pursue until I am actually proved wrong. How many times have you not seen him claim instantly as town?
You're basically lock town, drafter pressuring Mikal also feels kinda town, I wanted to know more about the speed pressure.
You're basically lock town, drafter pressuring Mikal also feels kinda town, I wanted to know more about the speed pressure.
Created:
Water was still defending him even as whiteflame was pretty close to being lynched though, so I think that makes him look town. Because if he had inside knowledge and knew whiteflame was scum, he wouldn't have been telling town to scum read me if it was a mislynch. It seems to show he didn't have inside info and was genuinely concerned we were mislynchign whiteflame I think.
I'm not gonna read into it because I have trouble reading into anything water does, but I think that if anything that'd be scummier. Most players would have been getting on the whiteflame lynch or distancing themselves from whiteflame, but I don't assume water behaves like most other players, I think that he'd be defending a partner there
Created:
Alright, that's vague but helpful. Thanks
Created:
-->
@Elminster
Can you give a 1-3 sentence explanation of the WF wagon?
Created:
Is that a hammer on WF? Regardless of if it is or isn't can someone please explain the wagon? I read the first 5 ish pages and then skipped ahead to real time last night
Created:
-->
@Vader
I'm also not feeling great (physically). I usually get a lil bit sick around this time, lol, so I don't have COVID, but probs gonna get tested if the cold persists. I don't have a fever, headache, or general drowzyness, just a runny nose and a lil cough
I'd be concerned about COVID if I were you, your sense of taste is also gone seeing as you're a Bears fan
Created:
-->
@Greyparrot
I'm not pissed off for the sake of being pissed off, but if I had actually been softing doc why would you call attention to it, ensuring mafia sees it?
Created:
-->
@Elminster
Are mafia together
- Warren/elm
Created:
-->
@Greyparrot
That is not a doc soft claim, and if it was why the hell would you say that openly in the DP
Created:
After my post last night I read up to around where GP claimed. I don't know if I buy that he's changed his meta, and honestly it feels like something he needs to prove before we can believe him. He doesn't claim as scum, he claims as town. That's my main suspect for today.
Drafter's Mikal pressure is dumb cause Mikal hasn't done anything stupid (at least as far as I'd gotten)
The speed pressure also felt dumb, I dislike the "this person is good as scum, might as well lynch them" argument which nobody overtly said but that's what the argument boiled down to
Created:
Anyway, at this point I should probably claim given my negative utility (via inactivity, not a negative utility role)
I'm Drew Ferguson from Georgia, I was the deputy house minority whip at some point and I used to be a dentist.
I'm Drew Ferguson from Georgia, I was the deputy house minority whip at some point and I used to be a dentist.
Created:
I told pie "I don't know how active I'll be, I'll try my best, only use me if you absolutely need me"
He never followed up
I got an activity prompt yesterday
It's honestly kinda frustrating, cause it puts me at a significant disadvantage, and as a result puts my faction (in this case town) at a significant disadvantage as well.
Created:
-->
@Lunatic
I literally can't do much right now. I wasn't even told that I was going to be in the game. I will probably be more useful later in the game, but I'll do what I can in the meantime.
Created:
Pie didn't even tell me I was in the game let alone that it started
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@drafterman
I was going to say something to the effect of my condolences, but I’d rather echo whiteflame’s statement. Well put.
Created:
Posted in:
Shit, that insider trading role is very interesting but also OP as fuck
Created:
Posted in:
Dani please full claim. We’re at MYLO and you’re the only person who hasn’t.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Danielle
Cool, I can lock you in that same boat of town or only scum with speed
Created:
Posted in:
Hi just checking in to prove that I can hammer speed and win if I’m scum
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Speedrace
No, and this seemed to be a misconception last phase. It could still have been drafter or Dani or Lunatic, we just had confirmation that they didn’t carry the kill
Created:
Posted in:
Also some minor psych but I imagine Supa doesn’t replace out as scum there. I think the utility of the role and the fact that multiple people have confirmed its existence means I’m gonna lock whiteflame in as town
Created:
Posted in:
Figured whiteflame for a likely target since he has been widely townread
Created:
Posted in:
Drafter blocked speed, I got LSD like I said. It was a watcher. Nobody visited whiteflame
Created:
Posted in:
This does all assume drafter is roleblocker, and obviously if he knows I’m indefinitely tracking him he wouldn’t carry N2, but the statements still hold true.
Created:
Posted in:
Looks like whiteflame gave me the LSD. Hopefully it’s something fun. Thanks whiteflame.
Also for the claims list remember I have to track the same person each night unless I’m disrupted somehow. So if drafter dies or I’m blocked.
Neither drafter nor Danielle carried the kill last night. That means there is at least one scum in {whiteflame, pie, speed, lunatic}
Neither drafter nor lunatic carried N1. Therefore there’s at least one scum in {whiteflame, pie, speed, Danielle}
{whiteflame, pie, speed} are on both lists. Whiteflame is probably town. I want to lynch one of speed/pie.
Created: