Chess Mafia DP1

So because I used dots, I’m suspicious? That makes no sense.

No. Your phrasing 

VTL Joebob for character claim.

I have no clue what you mean by that.

I am algebraic notation.

Read my post.

Sure, which makes my point even more valid. He’s never played as scum. He’s more likely to make the mistake if anything.

Point still stands. I put dots and your loosing it thinking I’m scum. You’re being ridiculous.

Alright, having just caught up on the DP… yeah, I don’t get the basis for this push on JoeBob. I think the basis for sussing him is weak at best, and this statement by Pie is just flat out false:

I can confirm that I’ve played with JoeBob as scum. I’ve seen how he behaves in the role. I think he’d be more careful about his posts if he was scum, since he regularly requested help with those posts in that game. None of what I’ve seen so far matches his scum behavior in that game.

That being said, the character claim doesn’t automatically give much away (though I’ll note that it’s also associated with moves, bringing it in line thematically with Castling), so the information garnered can still be useful without providing too much info to scum.

Eh I don’t consider that a game in the first place. There’s a reason why I didn’t play that game. Point taken though.

Yes exactly but that’s just my point. He’s extremely cautious with his posts. That post screams wanting to seem like he doesn’t know the fact that Savant is definitely town.

Castling

Pawn

Algebraic Notation

The odd one out is algebraic notation at this point in time. The first two are more niche. A specific piece in game where there are multiple pieces. A move in a game where there are multiple moves. Algebraic notation is universal.

It is still an opportunity to get some intel on his behavior as scum, and notably, the only one we have. 

It expresses a degree of uncertainty that I would not expect to see in a scum post from him. That caution would have to be his scum partner coming through, which is possible, but I don’t have good reason to believe that yet.

I guess that’s one way to look at it. I think there are several plausible theme splits, though I’ll note that Algebraic Notation isn’t consistently an outlier.

As of now I think he’s the best candidate to lynch. We have 3 claims already. I’m fine getting a role from Joe and making a decision. Idk where the inactives are which is annoying af too

The split works with my charscter, and I’m 90% sure it works with yours based on what you said earlier.

I’ll consider it, but I want at least a couple of the inactives to chime in before pursuing anything.

In a sense, yes. That’s why I’m considering your proposed split, though I think I need to see a couple of other soft claims before I can come to any conclusion.

Algebraic Notation doesn't seem to be outside the realm of possibility. You say it's universal, but I'm not really buying it. Besides, he putted his claim in like 10 minutes.

I can probably guess what some of the townies have assuming my split is correct. I also have a decent idea of what scum may have.

The outlier is Algebraic Notation.

You are. All I literally said was to not lynch Savant today, and your harping me on it.

I doubt that im the only one that’s an outlier.

And yet you’re saying I’m scum because of it.

Does Pie always demand claims from a lot of players? He did so last game and was mafia.

Can yall say something