ILikePie5's avatar

ILikePie5

A member since

3
7
10

Total posts: 17,895

Posted in:
Pie Recycled Roles Mafia Signups
1. Moozer
2. Lunatic
3. Casey
4. Savant
5. JoeBob
6. Earth
7. Whiteflame
8. Barney (TBD)
9.

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
-->
@Savant
Sorry, man. I think you played pretty well, but the town just had too much working against it.
Wasn’t the first time and won’t be the last sadly
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
-->
@Lunatic
The only advise I think I would give to town, and it was stated by someone earlier in the game, we are giving way too much credit to "confirmation roles" these days on DART. I've been guilty of this too. But it’s how austin and savant won in mahabarata as well. I almost wanted to do this game and randomize roles affiliations so town roles could be maf and vice versa to help push the narrative that behavior should be taken into account with results. Because that was really caseys only major doubt this game, was his night actions. And barney kind of got thunderdomed by joebob because his role technically wasn't confirmable pre-death, so that was a basic free mislynch for mafia when town was already up after mafia had  a night kill blocked. 
I thought Savant was the bleeder or something. When he didn’t die DP3 I had alarm bells going off. But he wasn’t scum so I figured he was the Doctor 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Pie Recycled Roles Mafia Signups
1. Moozer
2. Lunatic
3. Casey
4. Savant
5. JoeBob
6. Earth
7. Whiteflame
8.
9.

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
-->
@JoeBob
You had one job
Created:
0
Posted in:
Pie Recycled Roles Mafia Signups
1. Moozer
2. Lunatic
3. Casey
4. Savant
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
Sign up for my game
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
Ya I was basically the only Townie doing something that game lmao. Hard to 1 v 4
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
-->
@Savant
I suspected Moozer of being a third party role, but I'm too used to TOS where executioners can only have town players as their target. I figured it worked the same way here, though I probably shouldn't have.

By the endgame Moozer had an easy path to victory by just offering an alliance with the scum, and idk why he didn't do that. He would have lost if I hadn't unvoted so quickly.
You should’ve lynched WF. Scummiest person alive
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
-->
@JoeBob
@Casey_Risk
Y’all are jerks for not lynching WF. I died and flipped town. That should mean my reads are genuine and should be heavily considered.
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles V2 Endgame!!!!!!
I thought Moozer was hard throwing as a townie in DP3. Sucks that Austin, Joe, and Barney basically went AWOL
Created:
0
Posted in:
Pie Recycled Roles Mafia Signups
-->
@Earth
@Vader
@AustinL0926
@Casey_Risk
Signup
Created:
0
Posted in:
Pie Recycled Roles Mafia Signups
-->
@Lunatic
@whiteflame
@Savant
@JoeBob
@Moozer325
Signup
Created:
0
Posted in:
Pie Recycled Roles Mafia Signups
This game will be kinda like Lunatic’s except all characters will come from my games that I have hosted. Should be fun for yall.

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 3
-->
@Lunatic
Ur missing WF in final VC
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Savant
If you're telling the truth about your role, might be best to protect Pie tonight since he's a likely target.
That’s the problem. He can’t pick. He can only protect Grey, who doesn’t exist in this game
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
What about WF. You were on them for a bit?
Wym?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
1. Savant - 13 Reasons Why Mafia (by Pie) - Ani Achola - Doctor

2. Barney - Fast Food Mafia (by Supa) - Dunkin Donuts - Restless Spirit

3. Whiteflame - Fairy Tail Mafia (by Supa) - Juvia Lockser - Protector

4. Casey - Naruto Mafia (by Supa) - Sasuke Uchicha - Tracker

5. Joebob - MCU Heroes Mafia (by Speedrace) - Thor - 1x Silent Gladiator

6. Moozer - Civil War Generals Mafia (by Pie) - Henry Hallock - Bookie

7. Austin - Ancient Roman Battles Mafia - (by Pie) - Battle of Pharsalus - 2x Motion Detector

8. Pie - WWII Nations (by MisterChris)

9. Earth - Anime/Game Waifus (by Mikal) - Lucy Heartfilia - Town JOAT 1x RB, 1x JK, 1x Hider, 1x BP

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@JoeBob
If I die and you live, lynch WF tomorrow and then one of Moozer/Earth the following day. Everyone else is town for sure
Created:
2
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
I’m probably dead tonight anyways 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@whiteflame
Second, let me get this straight. You’re saying that someone who is a fan of this anime, who knows these characters very well, would actively decide to fake a claim that you believe requires one of those two characters to be in the game? I’ll admit, I was surprised too. My game’s the only one that contains Gray Fullbuster, so I fully expected that people would sus me over this claim. It’s practically a given. That being said, this is Luna’s attempt to combine a lot of games together to make one using a variety of roles. I don’t see any protective roles here aside from Savant’s claim.
This is all WIFOM. That fact is that ur role is connected with Grey, and Grey doesn’t exist.
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
VTL Barney 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
I’ll buy that for now, but only because you have some town cred.
Right now tho, we should lynch WF tomorrow 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
Why is Savant suddenly town? Not that I’m totally disagreeing with you, but I would like to hear some reasoning for this one.
Because of what happened last night. I’ll let him reveal it, but I have a pretty good idea of what happened 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Earth
@Barney
@JoeBob
@Casey_Risk
@Moozer325
Okay, so I think Casey has to be town because there’s no other investigative role out there. That leaves WF (who I suspect the most right now), and then Moozer or Earth (one of them is scum because of the Jailkeeper mechanic failing on Earth’s side and then Moozer admitting to choosing Savant who was targeted last night.

Joe is confirmed town, Barney is getting lynched today anyways, and Savant is town for sure. I’m obviously town


Now, here’s why I think Whiteflame is scum. This is his PM from the game: 

Lunatic - You are Juvia Lockser. You can use Rain Magic, a magic where you can make it rain and also control the water by blending into it. You are a quiet and shy person, but soon become madly in love with Grey. You care a lot for Grey and do so many things for him when he seems to do nothing returns. You are so loyal, that instead of giving yourself blood when in a battle with your magic, you gave some of yours to Grey to heal. Because of your undying loyalty to Grey, you are the Protector. If Grey were to die in the night, you would kill the person who killed Grey and then you save Grey, but ultimately killing yourself at night. You win with the town.
The role is directly linked to Grey, who was another character in that game. We know at this point that each character is from a different game, so Grey doesn’t exist in this game. The entire justification doesn’t make sense in this scenario because “Grey” doesn’t exist in this game. Only Grey can be protected per the PM, but Grey doesn’t exist in this game, so this is clearly a fake claim coming from Whiteflame
Created:
1
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
1. Savant - 13 Reasons Why Mafia (by Pie) - Ani Achola - Doctor

2. Barney - Fast Food Mafia (by Supa) - Dunkin Donuts - Restless Spirit

3. Whiteflame - Fairy Tail Mafia (by Supa) - Juvia Lockser - Protector

4. Casey - Naruto Mafia (by Supa) - Sasuke Uchicha - Tracker

5. Joebob - MCU Heroes Mafia (by Speedrace) - Thor - 1x Silent Gladiator

6. Moozer - Civil War Generals Mafia (by Pie) - Henry Hallock - Bookie

7. Austin - Ancient Roman Battles Mafia - (by Pie) - Battle of Pharsalus - 2x Motion Detector

8. Pie - WWII Nations (by MisterChris)

9. Earth - Anime/Game Waifus (by Mikal) - Lucy Heartfilia - Town JOAT 1x RB, 1x JK, 1x Hider, 1x BP

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
I’m Henry, “old brains” Hallok (probably spelled wrong). I’m the bookie, so each night I choose one person and if they get lynched on the next DP, then I get to kill someone on the next night. I chose Savant last NP, which now seems kinda dumb. I didn’t really think about Joebob using his role, but oh well.
Very interesting 
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Casey_Risk
Basically, he and Barney were the ones I was most unsure of how to read. I debated with myself a lot about which of the two I should track, and finally settled on WF. Not sure if it was the right decision or not, but it's what I did. 

My break is about over, be back later. 
Fair enough
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Casey_Risk
Hold on a second Savant, there's something I'm not understanding here. You claim to be the doctor and that you protected yourself, but according to the 13RW Mafia endgame, you shouldn't be able to protect yourself; only other people. Unless I'm just reading that wrong? 
Savant is town. Period. I’m not hearing anything to the contrary. So you tracked WF and he visited no one, so that spells good things for WF. Why did you choose WF?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
1. Savant - 13 Reasons Why Mafia (by Pie) - Ani Achola - Doctor

2. Barney - Fast Food Mafia (by Supa) - Dunkin Donuts - Restless Spirit

3. Whiteflame - Fairy Tail Mafia (by Supa) - Juvia Lockser - Protector

4. Casey - Naruto Mafia (by Supa) - Sasuke Uchicha - Tracker

5. Joebob - MCU Heroes Mafia (by Speedrace) - Thor - 1x Silent Gladiator

6. Moozer - Civil War Generals Mafia (by Pie)

7. Austin - Ancient Roman Battles Mafia - (by Pie)

8. Pie - WWII Nations (by MisterChris)

9. Earth - Anime/Game Waifus (by Mikal) - Lucy Heartfilia - Town JOAT 1x RB, 1x JK, 1x Hider, 1x BP

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
That’s really weird that you didn’t receive a message
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
You probably want my claim now, right?
Oh ya definitely you should claim
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
Interesting indeed
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
Just to be absolutely clear, the message was just “confirmed”

So you didn’t get a message that your action failed?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Casey_Risk
Please full claim
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@whiteflame
So I’m Juvia Lockser. The role says Protector, and I kind of remember this from the game, though it’s pretty different from versions of the role I’ve seen elsewhere. I’m tied to another player by loyalty (I’d like to at least keep who that is under wraps) and if that player is targeted for an NK, then I kill the NKer and eat the NK in place of their target.
Interesting, I have a few thoughts on this, but I would like to hear Casey’s full claim and then Moozer’s full claim
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Earth
Did you intend to keep Austin on the character/player list?
Yes
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
Sorry, I was having lunch with someone, do you still want my claim?
Claim after Casey
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
1. Savant - 13 Reasons Why Mafia (by Pie) - Ani Achola - Doctor

2. Barney - Fast Food Mafia (by Supa) - Dunkin Donuts - Restless Spirit

3. Whiteflame - Fairy Tail Mafia (by Supa)

4. Casey - Naruto Mafia (by Supa)

5. Joebob - MCU Heroes Mafia (by Speedrace) - Thor - 1x Silent Gladiator

6. Moozer - Civil War Generals Mafia (by Pie)

7. Austin - Ancient Roman Battles Mafia - (by Pie)

8. Pie - WWII Nations (by MisterChris)

9. Earth - Anime/Game Waifus (by Mikal) - Lucy Heartfilia - Town JOAT 1x RB, 1x JK, 1x Hider, 1x BP

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Earth
I am more interested in Moozer's claim tbh.
Your JK didn’t prevent the NK, so I’m not. Right now I want to see what makes Casey think WF is town, so WF needs to claim first, then Casey
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@whiteflame
@Casey_Risk
@Moozer325
But right now we need everyone to full claim so we can figure out balance and stuff. Order of claims:

Whiteflame
Casey
Moozer
Pie
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Savant
Won't be very useful tonight, but I should be of more use later on. If it is between JoeBob, WF, and Casey, that means we basically have the game solved anyway.
Could also be Earth, now that we know what happened last night, I don’t like the answer he gave at all
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Savant
Oh wait we could actually VTNL. Has Barney been confirmed?
A VTNL would just randomly end in one of them dying. JoeBob is confirmed and Barney isn’t, so Barney does die today, but he’s likely town cause Mafia would’ve roleblocked JoeBob if he wasn’t. That means we have his vote tomorrow, which is good.

So that leaves Moozer, Casey, WF, me, and Earth. JoeBob probably dies tonight so POE leaves Moozer, Casey, WF, me, Earth. I want everyone to full claim before we lynch Barney
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Savant
VTL Barney

Barney's role is less valuable, and JoeBob is confirmed.
Unvote please. We need to figure out what actually happened last night, and what we are going to do tomorrow. Right now you’re cleared cause I know what happened last night now. Moozer is sorta cleared, which leaves JoeBob, WF, and Casey
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
Oh yeah, I almost forgot about that. It’s not really applicable in that respect, but I got a confirmed message from the mod, so probably.
Please full claim
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Savant
My protection succeeded, which means I can't use my role tonight. Lynch is between Barney and JoeBob, so I won't reveal more at this time.
Okay that makes sense
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
1. Savant - 13 Reasons Why Mafia (by Pie) - Ani Achola - Doctor

2. Barney - Fast Food Mafia (by Supa) - Dunkin Donuts - Restless Spirit

3. Whiteflame - Fairy Tail Mafia (by Supa)

4. Casey - Naruto Mafia (by Supa)

5. Joebob - MCU Heroes Mafia (by Speedrace) - Thor - 1x Silent Gladiator

6. Moozer - Civil War Generals Mafia (by Pie)

7. Austin - Ancient Roman Battles Mafia - (by Pie)

8. Pie - WWII Nations (by MisterChris)

9. Earth - Anime/Game Waifus (by Mikal) - Lucy Heartfilia - Town JOAT 1x RB, 1x JK, 1x Hider, 1x BP

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Savant
I protected myself. Can only protect myself once, but it should mean I'm confirmed.
What are you claiming? Doctor?
Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
Actually, you should full claim first. Cause you’re heavily implicated by the JK

Created:
0
Posted in:
Recycled Roles Mafia V2 Day Phase 2
-->
@Moozer325
Did your action fail?

Created:
0