Total posts: 10,910
Posted in:
-->
@coal
I was going to wait until after maybe someone took the bait, but since TUF has already tripped the wire. . .
I "tripped the wire" before you even made the "bait post" when I mentioned that everyone would claim vanilla lol.
Potentially either 6 town and 3 mafia (unlikely, for balance reasons) or 7 town and 2 mafia (more likely).
3 Mafia isn't just unlikely, it's impossible. The OP lists all potential mafia set ups, every single one includes only 2 mafia.
Now let's see how long it takes for TUF to suggest a mass claim.
Lol what? Why would I do that?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@coal
Lol okay we will pretend you actually read the opening post for the sake of argument. I don't think anyone on this player list is dumb enough to fall for that bait.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Objectivity
Likewise! Lots of familiar names on this list, should be fun!
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Objectivity
Who was Lunatic on DDO? Does he have a new username or just a newer member I don't remember?
Sup Adam it's me, TUF, AKA Connor.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@coal
This would be a good time for SOP claims to speak up.
Unless this post is intended to trap an un-thoughtful mafia member attempting a fake claim, the open set up options Lucky posted do not show any set ups with Millers, or third party and the like.
Created:
Posted in:
Well, most everyone I would have suspected to be inactive has posted already.
VTL Danielle.
She made a post about playing mafia semi recently, but not sure if she remembers. Airmax should post, I told him it was starting monday yesterday and he said that sounded fine.
Created:
Posted in:
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@PressF4Respect
Wh... what?You know there's a signup, right?
We wanted a private game absent of lazy players and trolls so everything was set up privately. Shouldn't interfere with the main games.
Created:
Posted in:
So I imagine there's no point pressing role claims, everyone will just claim vanilla.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
Lunatic said he'd be interested if we get people
No I didnt lol
Created:
Posted in:
Sorry man that last game was bad... Maybe in a few months if activity picks back up.
Created:
Posted in:
Lucky backing out was a cop out but it was a scum tell and it was the only one I felt pretty sure about lol.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@RationalMadman
I think it goes without saying that if the creator of the website is asking for help, you aren't going to be banned for helping. But I am also pretty sure you know this and are just attempting to be provocative as usual.We can't test it without breaking CoC
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Barney
Ah, I see. I wasn't paying that close attention this day phase, I am sorry. Let's do that next day phase seeing as it's too late now.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Barney
Singularity says he's scum. Not sure what you are talking about cycle stuff. No one is playing. Singularity might be trolling who knows but sounds like the best chance of not no lynching again because of inactivity.
Created:
Posted in:
UnOfficial Vote count:
Single (4/4) - Ragnar, speed, Lunatic, supadudz
Not voting: Single, Water,
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
singularity is probably trolling
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Speedrace
Did you ask the mod about your results?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Speedrace
What is the paraphrased meaning for your role link and what were your np1 results?
Created:
Sounds funny, I would participate but I think I would be too inactive with all the mafia games im involved in. I will try to vote though if needed, this sounds entertaining.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
Not every day phase will be like that though, dp1 people tend to have the least to go on. I for one was inactive initially do to the timing of the game starting but forsee much more activity for dp2. I just feel like you are jumping the gun and over reacting a bit. So what if it's a bit inactive? Create activity! I dont see you quitting like this except for buckling under a wee bit of pressure which is extra sketch.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Greyparrot
Yeah id rather not get hung up on that because it encourages more people to not try because they think everyone else isnt trying. Lets change the attitude to "go getter"
Created:
Posted in:
Ima be more suspicious of lucky if ragnar ends up dead lol
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
So if hes dead and you got your way why are you still claiming your gonna quit becauae people are fuck it lynching you lol
Created:
Posted in:
There is no way this is really the lucky from DDO
Created:
Posted in:
No one buy into luckys little over dramatization here. I'm probably the only vote left on him and hes still acting like we are going on a "fuck-it-lynch". My vote on him was also a reaction test which he has failed, given his over the top reaction. He led a wagon on ragnar and there are more votes on ragnar than anyone else and he is still panicking. Replacing out or no, I read his behavior as scummy and think he is a good dp1 lynch.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@WaterPhoenix
You dont find lucky wanting to replace after 3 votes and minor FOS as scummy as I do?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
Honestly, then Bullish, I'm just going to replace out. We have 3 players trying to play the game (Me, Lunatic, and Oro), and everyone else is either inactive or they only show up to complain about inactivity. If we aren't going to try to find replacements, and make time accommodations for those replacements, the game is already dead and not worth continuing.
If you are town (the nature of this post to me suggests otherwise, but i'll play along for the chance of it) then be the difference you wanna see. The players in this sign up list will be a bit lazier, since were missing drafter, speed, siranonymous, etc, but we can get this going. Normally I'd have spammed the fvck out of this dp, but it came up during my work week. Over my weekend I will be viciously active, thurs-sat. We can be creative and figure something out to rope people in.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
The fact that you want a debate in DP1 is incredible. No, I'm not going to "argue" why I'm town against a case that exists only in your head. What am I debating, the air in front of me?
You could present a reason why we should take your innocence for granted. Guilty til proven innocent. Your not debating the air in front of you, you are debating the 3/6 wagon on you.
Sure, I can encrypt a fake claim. I can encrypt a fake claim before anyone else in the game has given a hint about what their role or meme is and hope that when it comes time to claim that nobody actually has that role or meme, because I can't change it later on. #SmartScumPlay
You gonna make me link you to every game where scum has fake claimed day phase one? Ballsy fake claiming is actually #SmartScumPlay, you should know this. Feels like your attempting reverse psychology here.
Don't you think that letting a gut ping lead you to push for a lynch without substantiating a case, based on meta from years ago, and then asking me in the final day of the DP if that meta has changed is putting the cart before the horse? Don't you think that letting a gut ping lead you to push for a lynch without substantiating a case, based on meta from years ago, and then asking me in the final day of the DP if that meta has changed is putting the cart before the horse? I have games from mafiascum that I am currently playing I can link you if you want to see how I play DP1. Both games are ongoing so I can't disclose my alignment, but expecting "big brain plays" with the content available to analyze in this game thus far is a fundamentally flawed approach to the game.
I have had better luck with gut reads yes. And I can actually explain them in great detail most of the time, but argumentatively it ends up not being worth my time, because I know the counter arguments already. It is pretty useless to explain a scum read to the person you scum read, they have an inherent goal to saying "nuh uh" to everything. I am okay with back and forth just trying to stay out of the 'pointless realm'. My meta read on you from years ago, I am willing to change, but I would at least like an explanation as to what your current thoughts are and how they are different. I remember a very lengthy argument with you that carried over into the discord about how useless day phase 1 is. In fact, mikal still makes that argument basing it largely off of yours from back then. Now you are talking about quitting the game because it's not active enough. I don't want to read your mafiascum games, I just want you to tell me in your own words why your philosophy has changed, and what in particular your strategy is to get the maximum of information with a day left by pressuring ragnar?
Created:
Posted in:
Lol honestly the strongest argument not to lynch lucky DP1 for me so far is that he hasnt played for so long it would be a shame to lynch him so quickly but I'm feeling this one is actually scum.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
If you think you've picked up on my claim then you are already looking at the wrong post. You can't decrypt my claim without the code, that's the point of encryption.
Regardless it is useless. You can encrypt a fake claim or you could straight up make a fake claim just as easy. Following drafters logic in this one and it applies to oros poem coding as well.
This is everything wrong with mafia on DDO/Dart
You act as if you are intimately informed about current metas and playstyles of DART. This is presumably your first game back after years right? Back off the elitist stuff a notch lol. There are plenty of things wrong with the metas but I'm not sure my FOS here can be categorically compared.
Let me think of a good reason not to lynch me, "Because I'm town." Stupid answer?
If you are actually town you can do better than that. I seem to remember you were a pretty good debater. You have the largest wagon at the moment though and times a ticking. And currently your only providing a useless encryption to argue your lack of a lynch.
Looking for reasons not to lynch people instead of looking for reasons to lynch people results in a gameplay pattern where every DP we temporarily rule out players until we're out of time and go with a fvck-it-lynch, instead of incrementally gathering info that can be used to solve the game at LYLO.
I seem to remember you having a differemce stance regarding the effectiveness of DP1 banter. Has your opinion since changed? Regardless my reason for voting you isnt random or a "fuck-it-lynch". I may go more in detail if necessary from inquiring minds but I have a legit gut read on you. With time ticking I would prefer to lynch my strongest read.
Also I dont buy that you have a genuine interest in "incrementally gathering info" by oushing ragnar for activity. So what, he pops in says "hi" you say okay and urge a vtnl with 1 day left? Doesnt seem like town lucky. Then again its been a while since I played with you but I seem to remember big brain plays. Plays into part of my gut read.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
I picked up on your soft claim I think. Not sure it matters though. Trying to nderstand theme differences hasn't been proving to be an effective lately. Regardless there isnt a whole lot of time left and a mix of mod psychology and gut thinks you may be a good target for a dp1 ly ch unless theres any good specific reason not to lynch you that you can provide?
Created:
Posted in:
Should we give a lucky a good welcome back dp1 lynch?
Created:
Posted in:
Btw no one should be confirmed from on structure. Bullishs last quickfire mafia had the same pm structure as town.
Created:
Posted in:
Kinda wanna keep my vote on lucky for now. He feels sketch to me though trying to explain it in words I couldn't present a solid argument. Its a gut feeling.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
I do not win with the town, but I am town. :)Lunatic, do you win with the town? Prune I may be, somehow I have a... feeling that the town will experience... victory.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Lucky
I either have bad memory or I just don't remember you being such a persnicketty prune back on DDO
Created:
Posted in:
Created:
Posted in:
Well my return to the site was mostly due in large to a revitalized interest in mafia. I came back in October and enjoyed a good 4 months of mafia games. Its been fun! It's been real! But I'm probably out until mafia makes a return to the website. Thanks to everyone for some fun times and good memories. Its been real.
If anyone manages to get a real mafia game going at some point in the future just send me a message and I'll be back. Til then, ta ta for now friends!
Created: