Total posts: 10,910
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
Whiteflame stop saying I am refusing to give any information lol. I gave it as soon as he asked. There was no need to full claim prior because I essentially function the same as a doctor and if mafia knew the negative utility of my role it would they might not view my role as enough of a threat to change course, so it’s obvious why I don’t wanna reveal that part.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
I’m the apportioner, I extend a persons life one day phase though they still die eventually.
Created:
Posted in:
I am not going to even read or respond to whiteflames block of text there. On my mobile so short posts only. I am town confirmed. Whiteflame is a weak ass self protection role, I am an actual protection role.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
Are you confirmed by anyone? If so, who and how so?
I am twice confirmed. How you don’t know this blows my mind.
1. Counterclaimed the fake doctor (savant) dp1
2. Lynched Austin the claimed super saint dp2 which as mafia would have lost me the game.
If you lynch me it’s literally you being an idiot. There is 0 manipulation about it. This should have been me choosing between you and Whiteflame not you choosing between me and Whiteflame. If you fuck this up you are a retard and I’ll never stop reminding you
Created:
Posted in:
I am going to a family reunion. Gonna have to be that asshole on my phone the whole time I guess. Joe on make the right decision here. If whiteflame isn’t lying there is basically no town protective role. There’s been one I every game you’ve played in so why wouldn’t there be here? And why the hell would I bus savant day phase 1 for no reason? And suicide by trying to lynch Austin claiming he was a super saint? Think about it. Makes 0 sense for me to be anything other than town.
Created:
Posted in:
vtl whiteflame.
Joebob if you fuck this up i am so fucking done playing with you ever again. I am double fucking confirmed. Do your part and vote the last scum .
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
And that lack of success with that role seems awfullyconvenient. I’m not surprised that he wanted to protect JoeBob, as he’s thesole investigative role, but over the last few DPs, his target was announced bysomeone else and he just went with it. That’s not what I’d expect town Luna todo, since he would know that scum would just pick a different target, wastinghis efforts.
You have known who I would target every single night because austin publicly told me what to do each night (though I was planning on doing the joebob protection either way). You never had to worry about my kill protecting your kill/
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
We can’t confirm a single thing Luna did. He claims hetargeted JoeBob the last two NPs, but since JoeBob was apparently never thetarget of the NK, so we only have his word on that. We cannot confirm his roleany more than we can confirm mine. Additionally, he hasn’t full-claimed hisrole up to this point, so he hasn’t been straight with town the entire game,using the uncertainty of his role and the earlier CC on Savant as a basis forbecoming one of the most townread players in this game. It’s the reason Itownread him initially.
I CC'ed the doc. And I lynched a lynchproof claiming he was a super saint. You literally cannot argue I am scum. Well you can, but no one smart would believe this. Which is why you are trying to appeal to joebob so hard right now and take advantage of his noobiness/laziness.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
If he is a protective role and he can’t heal himself, how hasn’t he died?
Because austin has been publicly announcing who we should be protecting each night which honestly wasn't smart. Whiteflame knew who I would be on the last two night phases so he didn't have to worry about my protection blocking him ever.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
Luna does seem like the more reasonable lynch right now. If he is a protective role and he can’t heal himself, how hasn’t he died? Also I haven’t seen anything that actually confirms him. He could have just said he was role blocked at the beginning, so that in the later days he gets townread for getting role blocked at the beginning.
Bro if you actually throw this game when it was handed to us, I am permanently exiling myself from playing mafia with you again. Period. I am town confirmed. This is between you and whiteflame, and its now obviously whiteflame. I am double town confirmed. Stop buying into whiteflame's manipulation. I am not even kidding you I will perma ban myself from playing with you ever again if you vote me in this situation and I will call you a retard so hard in the end game. Whiteflame is appealing to you because he's hoping your a noob and will just blindly vote with him. I am literally fucking town confirmed.
Created:
Posted in:
can’t trust anyone, what if it’s you? I doubt it is, but you never know.
I confirmed myself in Austin dp2 if you remember. Not too mention I counterclaimed the doctor day phase 1. You can’t honestly still have doubt on me. Whiteflames only protective measure in his role is for himself, so if I’m not the doctor there really is no protective roles in this game is what you are suggesting
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
Damn, Austin was the last person I expected to be NK'd. I'll organize my thoughts. Give me a few minutes.
The fake surprise is amusing lol. Like I just pointed out, Austin was the obvious target if you didn’t expect me to deviate from joebob.
Created:
Posted in:
Also, no one's mentioned it yet, but it's surprising JoeBob's still alive. Scum have an RB and could have used it on Luna again to take him out. Not that it tells me anything about alignment, it's just an odd choice.
No offense but this post is just so scummy. lol joebob was the announced target so it makes more sense for them to just roleblock joebob if your the one who is mafia you don’t have anything to worry about unless you suspect me to not listen to the day call.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
Please make the best case you can for your innocence and why you think the other person is the better lynch.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@whiteflame
Please make the best case you can for your innocence and why you think the other person is the better lynch.
Created:
Posted in:
Well I’ll do everyone their due diligence and let the one v one arguments play out. Gotta say Whiteflame, doesn’t look to good for you, but I will hear ya out.
Created:
Posted in:
Current Mafia:
iLikePie5 - Mahabharata Mafia DP3
Signups:
N.A
In the Hopper:
N.A
On Hold:
Mharman - Gunplay Mafia
RationalMadman - 8 player game, unknown theme
Lunatic-Clash of Clans mafia (on hold til after the mafia universe game)
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
Alright. Who do u wanna lynch?
I guess Moozer. He is just the better target because of his flip flop and opportunistic behavior contradicting his words last day phase. Like I said, he initially questioned you for your logic in lynching me, then when it seemed like a lynch between you or me was inevitable, the second you appealed to him and joebob, he is immediately okay with lynching me. Smelt very oppertunistic to me. And his role feels ultimately useless.
Only reservation on moozer I have is that I've had an inkling that a veteran has been with savant, based on the claim. Also I kind of don't see pie throwing two noobs together as scum but I could be wrong, and maybe it truly is just random. But whiteflame has a really strong character claim, it's really only his role I am suspicious of, and I actually town read him for his behavior last day phase. So if whiteflame is scum here, props.
But yeah I am also leaning moozer atm.
Gonna give the day phase some time to breathe before voting, we have plenty of time to discuss this.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
didn’t someone use their ability on me to prevent me from dying, or was that someone else
I protected you, and no, it shouldn't have prevented you from doing anything. I am guessing you were just regularly roleblocked by mafia.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
well cuz if my action failed wouldn’t that mean he’s ascetic? Or would that mean he just didn’t do anything’s.
Pretty sure its a roleblocker mate, I received the same message np1.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
If you believe that fullclaiming your role at this point will help town, please do so.
There will be no point in the game where full claiming my role more than I have already will be more helpful to town.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@JoeBob
wouldn’t this mean that moozer is ascetic?
explain?
Created:
Posted in:
So vader was intentionally targeted. That makes more sense. For some reason I thought he had the kill redirected to him.
Created:
Posted in:
Wait a second. Vaders kill only would have been redirected if the player performed a NEGATIVE action. Joebob wouldnt count as a negative would he?
Created:
Posted in:
I think joebob is town. I wasn't roleblocked last night, but np1 I was told my action failed.
Created:
Posted in:
I protected joebob last night. Supa was supposed to protect joebob last night. I don't know if he actually did or not. I have to ask pie some questions about how my role works with the victim role, because if joebob was the target he should have been protected, unless the victim role took priority. Unless supa targeted someone else.
Joebob results?
Created:
Posted in:
None of the remaining POE players are really looking good for me besides vader/joebob based on the claim and result.
Barney for suggesting we lynch both me and austing out of order, which would lead to a mafia victory (no defense for that yet). He also has this crazy character that sounds like it should be a revenge killing type role, yet he is just a decoy? In what way does that role help or benefit town? The only reason I can see pie making this role useless is because its a tranny, and as a right wing trump supporter who probably hates trannies, he could have nerfed the shit out of this major role I guess? Also Barney feels very low effort this game. Not what I would expect from a town player trying to solve the game. He has on multiple occasions accepted that he is willing to be mislynched, or shows very little care about being lynched. I don't see him offering up a whole lot of helpful analysis to further town along at all. Could be after savant was lynched he just wants to give up instead of ride this out for a few more phases on a weak claim.
Moozer is a dickriding flip flopper, whose role is negative util. I already usually suspect commuters, most of the time I see them claimed I am suspect of them so that doesn't help his case. He extremely easily went from telling austin that I shouldn't be a lynch priority for being on the savant lynch last day phase to boarding austins wagon IMMEDIATELY when austin appealed to him and joebob's ego to get me lynched. His role doesn't help town get anywhere and it also technically makes a THIRD protection against night kills when combined with my role and whiteflames (technically whiteflames person still dies, but still).
Whiteflame the main problem I have is his justification. While true that he was a surviving member of the war, I don't see the link to being a VIP really at all. Nor do I see it really as a "pro-town" role. Though from the wiki's it seems Arjuna is a major character, one of the five pandava brothers, and is considered a "hero". He was exiled, but the reasons for exile was because he turned down a woman who wanted to jump his bones and referred to her as 'mother' meaning it as a compliment, but she took it as an insult and tried to get his dick chopped off and exile him. But the wiki describes this character as a good character overall. So I guess whiteflame for me is lowest on the list, but I have to keep in mind whiteflame could have asked if this character was in the game and could have been told no. Overall its a solid character claim with a weak role claim. Behaviorally I don't suspect much though I will say.
VTL barney for now. open to further discussion about whiteflame and moozer, but barney's behavior, character, and role are all scummiest to me for now,
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
Only got like 2 hours of sleep because I was arguing with Austin. SmhSorry about that :( didn't quite mean to take it so far but I needed you to genuinely want to hammer me.
I mean it's hindsight now, but it feels like out of all the people you could have "town confirmed" using your role it still feels like a waste that it was used on me. I still feel like you genuinely had no reason to scum read me and were scum reading me over literal perceived omgus. I am not sure how much of that you played up because of your role factor, but I am still genuinely confused on how you thought doing what you did with me was the best course of action for town.
We can move on from it I guess because what is done is done, but I feel like we are exactly in the same spot we were at the beginning of the day phase. Again I wasn't even scum reading you, and was gonna treat you as if you were town anyway. We could have tested your role on literally anyone else to get a town confirmation, then you would have still had me as the doc who CC'ed scum and we didn't need to go through all these shenanigans.
Created:
Posted in:
Fuck me im gonna be exhausted at work today. Only got like 2 hours of sleep because I was arguing with Austin. Smh
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
Does the day phase end with your lunch or does the vote just stall out?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
Okay well hopefully your egos been satisfied. Time to go play some overwatch
Created:
Posted in:
Hopefully lessons were taught with this and we can go back to normal scum hunting in the next game. If not welll I guess we can just do this again and again
Created:
Posted in:
VTL Austin
For the record I think we’re both town here.
Pressure Barney. I’m pretty sure he is the last scum. Good luck town :)
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Moozer325
Vote Austin, then Austin will vote himself, and I’ll hammer and we’ll take out two birds with one stone. Let’s do this.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Barney
I’ll happily hammer him just need a few more votes
Created:
Posted in:
Here’s why we should just get rid of both of us right now.
Austin is new but he is in this “my shit doesn’t stink mood” because he was correct in one lynch. I actually suspect a bus here. It if he isn’t bussing and is just town, he really desperately needs this ego check. I’ve been around the block enough times to see how this plays out. Royalpaladin, drafterman, Mikal, you always get one. This player plays in a way that makes them think because they are right once or twice they can get extremely tunnel vision every single time and basically bully and manipulate people into following them, and the second that doesn’t work out they act like Austin is acting now.
I’m putting an end to that shit right now. I’ve done it before and I’ll do it again, teach these young whippersnappers a fucking lesson. Austin can get us both killed and sit here and argue with me about how right he was in the endgame while learning 1 v 1s never benefit town. If there’s any time to teach him that lesson it’s now. Chances are he’s actually scum doing this so it’s probably not a big deal anyway, because I see scum behave this way ten times more than town.
If he isn’t scum though it still is a good time to teach him this lesson because he isn’t acknowledging that I even could be town.
That’s the difference here. I on the other hand know that he could be town and just being a Mikal here. Austin remember that guy Elminster you were talking about when you were reading games? That’s exactly who I am talking about. We had to lynch that guy over and over again to teach him a lesson and I’ll do the same thing to you right now.
We can do it as many times and as many games as you want until we shut that fucking ego of yours down.
Town can afford it this game so I am especially down with it. And it will free up some time for me to do other things so it’s a win win. You can call it a dick measuring contest, and it kind of is, but only because Austin is making it that way. So if we’re gonna do this let’s do this when town can afford it.
Barney suggesting we do it one at a time is scummy af btw because that guarantees mafia get two kills out of it if we’re both town instead of one and it gives them the win. Barney is probably scum for even suggesting it. But I’ll let town figure that out at this point. The game is now daddy lunatic teaching young Austin a valuable lesson in pride.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@AustinL0926
I didn’t say it was out of frustration, the fact that it is calculated is actually my point. Again you have nothing to lose in this situation. As scum if you are hammered here you just save yourself time from a failed bus, or you get a mislynch that you feel you can easily justify. I’m hoping town is smarter than that though if your plan does go through and you manage to mislynch me instead of getting a trade with your role.
Either way I’ve proven that this one for or. With your role trade is absolutely the best way to go for town so I’ll follow through no matter what. If we’re gonna do this let’s do it.
Created:
Posted in:
Two extra phases*
Ignore all the spelling and grammar mistakes please I am supposed to be sleeping lol
Created:
Posted in:
Also notice the difference here: I am willing to admit that we could both be town in this situation. Austin is not.
And I am willing to do a 1v1 trade, since that will win the game for town on the spot. Let's do it.
Who says this as town? The fact that I am willing to call his bluff shows that I have less to risk here than he does. This is all or nothing for him. He hedged all his bets on people buying into his town cred from the savant bus. If that doesn't work, at least he saves himself a lot of time and effort of having to manipulate everyone after I put it out there that he isn't town confirmed. He was really banking on being town confirmed, and wants to shut the narrative that he isn't down, and hopes by intimidating me and getting me to back down he will accomplish that further, and if I do back down, still get lynched, he can play it off as "Look lunatic was just being anti town by not giving information blah blah" and manipulate the rest of you blindly for the rest of the game. Yeah the fact that I am not doing that should tell you what this is pretty blatantly.
I have less to risk than he does by doing this and he knows it. This is a win win for him, because if he is scum he doesn't have to waste him time after this point if don't back down. And If I do he gets a mislynch he feels he can justify out of it.
That's why I say let's just cut out all this nonsense and fucking do it. Town is literally in a spot where they can afford to do it, it gets two major players off the field for you to worry about in the backs of your minds, and I trust the rest of town to be able to figure out who the last scum is if it isn't austin, as you essentially will still have to extra phases to do it if you VTNL after results are passed next phase.
Created: