Total posts: 3,773
Posted in:
One hour remains. I updated my own vote #6.
Tally
Debates (17)
Threads (15)
- MisterChris, SupaDudz, AirAnonymous
- Oromagi Covid Poem ()
- Starship Troopers ()
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park ()
Miscellaneous (9)
- ebuc’s enigmas (1)
Created:
Posted in:
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@BrotherDThomas
@ebuc
As a reminder since you posted in the nominations thread, voting is open.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@blamonkey
@oromagi
@Speedrace
@seldiora
@TNBinc
As a reminder since you posted in the nominations thread, voting is open.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Mharman
@Dr.Franklin
@Trent0405
@VonKlempter
@Crocodile
As a reminder since you posted in the nominations thread, voting is open.
Created:
Posted in:
Unpinned.
Quickfire does seem to be a good idea for some games, but I would estimate that it can easily be handled within the main sign up thread.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Intelligence_06
I'm not positive that's necessary with it already pinned, but voter turnout does feel lower than it was for the harder nomination process.
Created:
-->
@seldiora
How small are your rating shifts from losses getting? Like type 1 has about a hundred losses, and is only roughly a 100 points below you.
Created:
Posted in:
Tally
Switching the numbers to vote counts.
Debates (17)
Created:
Posted in:
My votes...
Debates
- Is Jesus the Messiah?While drilling down to one core issue, this was possibly the most in depth religious debate we’ve had. The educational value of this debate cannot be overstated.
- Resolved: The US should institute congressional term limitsBsh1's final debate. Incredibly close debate, and to this day I don't know how I would end up voting. Plus a truly relevant topic for affecting us all.
- Legalized Abortion (added 9/2)This is an odd one, since it offers no middle ground (all abortions legal, or all illegal... common sense says the issue at least a thousand times more complicated). Still, it was well argued, even making a feminist like me favor the con position.
I will note that the Atheists BoP debate only trailed behind this one by the slightest of margins.
Threads
- I will stereotype debaters properly.It's just too much fun, and could be picked back up at any time.
- DART Bard, 1st Edition, 1/3/2020To me it reads like a sateric love letter to this community. I just wish there was a 2nd edition.
- Pure Lies (added 9/2)
I have resisted voting for this for fear of doing such being misrepresented as bullying, but the thread is entertaining and perhaps insightful.
Misc.
If I understood them, I would probably be voting the enigmas.
- BrotherDThomas’ performance artSeriously, love him or hate him, BrotherDThomas is probably the highlight of the religious forum... Which probably confirms me as a pseudo-christian needing to be bible-slapped silly™ for talking about him instead of Jesus!
- Alpha MaleI'm confident enough that I don't need to explain this.
- Rap BattlesI've gone through periods where they annoy me, yet it's something so many users enjoy so it's worth celebrating.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
Well I am guess I am a DART Hall of Famer now! Wow! Crazy
Congrats!
Created:
Posted in:
Hall of Fame II
Voting Stage Rules
Welcome to DART’s second official Hall of Fame induction process! This thread is for the second stage of that process, namely, the voting stage. During this stage, users (you) may vote for the various nominees in each category (threads, debates, miscellaneous) for inclusion in the Hall of Fame. The three nominees with the most votes in each category will be inducted into the Hall of Fame.
Any user will be able to vote for up to three nominees per category for a maximum of 9 votes per voting user. Voters may choose to vote for less than the maximum number if they choose. You may vote for any of the nominees who have advanced out of the nomination stage. The voting process will close at approximately 2:00pm, PST, on 09/02/20. Votes cast after the close of the process will not be considered.
When you vote, you are encouraged to offer a brief justification for, explanation of, or reason for your vote. Please also bold your votes to make them more visible. You are permitted to change your votes within reason.
Those nominees with the most votes (3 per category) will be inducted into the DART Hall of Fame. In the event of a tie preventing exactly 3 inductions per category, the voting window will be extended for just those tied nominees. Those inducted will be formally honored with entries in the Hall of Fame thread.
There are no prerequisites or eligibility requirements for users to participate in the Hall of Fame voting process, except that they have an account on DART and are not voting/nominating from more than one account. Importantly, please don’t engage in coordinated vote trading and such, as that would be incongruous.
Notice
Due to an overwhelming majority within the nomination stage, the user category shall not be voted on this year. If there arises disagreement with this ruling, then voting on users may occur.
The Nominees
Choose up to three from each category.
Users ()
N/A
Debates (5)
- Atheists have BOP
CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06 - Congressional Term Limits
bsh1 vs. blamonkey - Is Jesus the Messiah?
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso - Legalized Abortion
Vector vs. MisterChris - Seldiora vs SupaDudz R1 Charter School
Seldiora vs. Supadudz
Thread (12)
- By: Speedrace.
- By: SirAnonymous
- By: Intelligence_06.
- By: BearMan.
- By: thett3.
- By: RationalMadman.
- By: RationalMadman.
- By: Speedrace.
- By: oromagi.
- By: ILikePie5.
- By: PressF4Respect.
- By: SupaDudz
Miscellaneous (4)
- BrotherDThomas’ performance art
- crossed’s information labyrinths
- ebuc’s enigmas
- Ragnar is the natural alpha male of this website.
- Rap Battles: Supa v RM
Let’s Begin!
“With all that said, let the nominating process begin! If you have questions, feel free to ask. Good luck to everyone and best wishes on a fantastic Hall of Fame process. This is a wonderful site and community, and there is so much greatness out there to recognize! I look forward to honoring those contributions and users who have made this site what it is!”-Bsh1, first chief moderator (he may be gone, but his spirit and contributions are still recognized)
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Imabench
Thank you for your hard work in this thread. I think this was the one I was trying to remember to nominate for the HoF.
Created:
Posted in:
Ok, anyone care to suggest any other changes before it moves forward? I could ask the nominators for each thread to list a sentence for why it's a good candidate? I could also put them into alphabetical order?
Debate
- bsh1 vs. blamonkey
- Vector vs. MisterChris
- Seldiora vs. Supadudz
- CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06
Thread
- I will stereotype debaters properly.
- MCU Characters: DP1
- When Utopia Crumbles: LIVE THREAD
- I am being banned for pure lies
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park
- How de-scalled are you?
- DART Bard
- Oromagi Covid Poem
- DART: Honest Trailers
- Starship Troopers
- Captain America: Civil War Mafia - Endgame
- DEBATE ART TOURNAMENT ROUND ONE
Miscellaneous
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@oromagi
I wholly agree. There was something about the previous one to which I was uncomfortable.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
For your series of rap battles, would you care to rap out a post to summarize them that the nomination can then link to?
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@oromagi
You nominated crossed's information hellscapes, since he has not given any feedback, would you mind pointing to a favorite example?
Created:
Posted in:
Grey wasn't a major threat, as he could not track our ninja who did the NKs. He could maybe town confirm people, but in doing so would out power roles (or he could follow me, who was clearly a town RB, who was going to be honest about every block).
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
@oromagi
Any thoughts to whom you would like to do your main HoF write-ups?
Created:
Posted in:
For users, there's an overwhelming margin of victory at almost three times the closest runner up, so if there's no objection we could just plug the top three into the HoF without further voting.
User
- oromagi (13)
- Ragnar (13)
- SupaDudz (13)
- bsh1 (5)
For debates, there's a sufficient spread, so anything with more than a single nomination moves forward into voting.
Debate
- bsh1 vs. blamonkey
- Vector vs. MisterChris
- Seldiora vs. Supadudz
- CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06
- Is Jesus the Messiah? (2)
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso
For threads, the difference of the most and least popular is too narrow. They all move forward.
Thread
- I will stereotype debaters properly. (3)
- MCU Characters: DP1 (3)
- When Utopia Crumbles: LIVE THREAD (2)
- I am being banned for pure lies (1)
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park (1)
- How de-scalled are you? (1)
- DART Bard (1)
- Oromagi Covid Poem (1)
- DART: Honest Trailers (1)
- Starship Troopers (1)
- Captain America: Civil War Mafia - Endgame (1)
- DEBATE ART TOURNAMENT ROUND ONE (1)
Likewise for Misc.
Miscellaneous
- ebuc's enigmas (1)
- crossed's information hellscapes (1)
- Rap Battle Supa v RM (1)
There will be some other small refinements before the next stage of voting begins.
Created:
Posted in:
I would say that concludes nomination voting. I personally had meant to add more, but got sucked into a game of Mafia.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Pattern
To be clear, this isn't about a villain being lynched. We accepted that the moment both Type1 turned out to be a hider, and had Grey followed me as planned. Three whole days to lynch Pie after that, which we were fine with.So your entire strategy to win as mafia is to hope town has too many lazy or inactives to ever pull a lynch off? I think your time is better off re-evaluating your scum play then blaming the mod for a common extension. I encourage extensions even if they dont benefit me. I asked for one last day phase when I was still a likely lynch candidate lol
Literally the opposite of what I said.
Created:
Posted in:
Final DASHBOARD
And what it likely would have looked like DP3
Projected DASHBOARD
X.oromagi Lady Tsunade Doctor ??? ???
TOWN CLAIM ROLE NP1 TARGET NP2 TARGET
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
@ILikePie5
You two really should just debate each other on either this specific game, or more generally the topic of extensions.
Created:
-->
@ILikePie5
He can have my slot. I think I prefer when I'm a replacement.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@MisterChris
@Pattern
To be clear, this isn't about a villain being lynched. We accepted that the moment both Type1 turned out to be a hider, and had Grey followed me as planned. Three whole days to lynch Pie after that, which we were fine with.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
We The Scummies resign.
Unprecedented moderator interference in giving town a last minute bonus extension when they refused to lynch within the day phase, damaged the integrity of the game.
Victory should come from merit, not outside interference Deus Ex Machina. And while we hope we would have pulled off a victory anyway, it seems better to end the game early and move on to one untainted.
With Naruto being named "Number One Unpredictable," it is at least fitting that this game garnered an unpredictable ending.
-Kisame Hoshigaki, Madara Uchiha, and Pain
Created:
Posted in:
I've got to say, it feels dirty that it took us longer than the day phase to finally lynch him.
Created:
Posted in:
That's hammer.
To make sure this is on the final page so easily accessible...
DASHBOARD
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ebuc
Thanks. I've added a link to your post, to explain what is meant by your enigmas.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@skittlez09
Dashboard
Added Rock Lee
Created:
Posted in:
While I for some odd reason believe in RNG, they don't override logical vetos, or even intuition on who is acting sketch.
Created:
Posted in:
I can always revise based on which way Pie flips. While the estimated 30% chance he's scum is better than we have for anyone else, he's also been pretty useful to town, so I can imagine things going either way (yeah, I'll lynch off of likelihood without certainty).
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Pattern
I in part asked people for advice on the block to gather reads from their suggestions.
Anyway, I just ran a RNG with a seed from the first post this DP. Croc did not come up from it (I think I would veto it had he... As I've said before, I want to block someone who is reliably active enough to get up to something in the night).
Created:
Posted in:
Dashboard
Updated for formatting (it bothers me... wish this forum could hold tables), and to carry people's nighttime claims (it could also maybe carry their best reads from the day?)
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@crossed
@BrotherDThomas
@ebuc
Your contributions have been nominated in the Miscellaneous category. Any response?
Created:
Posted in:
Vote Tally
User
User
- oromagi (12)
- Ragnar (12)
- SupaDudz (11)
- bsh1 (5)
- Speedrace (1)
- Discipulus_Didicit (1)
- blamonkey (1)
- Ramshutu (1)
- semperfortis (1)
Debate
- bsh1 vs. blamonkey
- Seldiora vs. Supadudz
- Vector vs. MisterChris
- CalebEr vs. Intelligence_06
- Is Jesus the Messiah? (2)
Dustandashes vs. Virtuoso - PGA2.0 vs Whiteflame
- SkepticalOne vs. PGA2.0
- nvmarco vs. fauxlaw
- whiteflame vs. Tejretics
- Violent revolution is a just response to political oppression (1)
MisterChris vs. Speedrace - Fetuses as a replacement for the USD (NULL)
Not eligible due to already winning.
Thread
- I will stereotype debaters properly. (3)
- MCU Characters: DP1 (3)
- I am being banned for pure lies (1)
- When Utopia Crumbles: LIVE THREAD (1)
- Tyranny at Lafayette Park (1)
- How de-scalled are you? (1)
- DART Bard (1)
- Oromagi Covid Poem (1)
- DART: Honest Trailers (1)
- Starship Troopers (1)
- Captain America: Civil War Mafia - Endgame (1)
- DEBATE ART TOURNAMENT ROUND ONE (1)
Miscellaneous
- Ragnar is the natural alpha male of this website. (2)
- ebuc's enigmas (1)
- crossed's information hellscapes (1)
- BrotherDThomas' performance art (1)
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@oromagi
Glad to see you're still getting a laugh out of my debate on currency systems. It is however already in the HoF.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Vader
I kept forgetting to actually add anything from the Misc. category into the tally. Your above post is updated with it... I genuinely thought people would have more offerings for it.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@oromagi
Right now I am trusting Grey, and his investigations could prove useful if he guesses the right person.
I admit I have not properly considered Chris, he may very well be the best choice (if you'll pardon the pun).
If pie is scum, I doubt the scum team would have him do the killing again.
Pattern... The whole Croc amnesiac thing confused me (still a little worried he'll be eating a corpse), so he's a viable choice in case he's an arsonist priming people or something (worst case, I've blocked a vanilla, not costing us any power role for the night).
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@oromagi
Speaking of RB, who are your top picks for whom I should RB tonight?
VTL Pie.
Created:
-->
@ILikePie5
Reading that SirAnon came back for this game...
/in - Civil War Generals
I would however not mind if they're somehow crossed with Taco Bell.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@bmdrocks21
I just looked it up. It is a 33 minute drive from Antioch, IL (Kyle’s hometown) and Kenosha, WI.I think the distinction between states is rather arbitrary for this matter.
When I read descriptions about him fleeing across state lines, that is what I thought.
Granted, yes, he did cross state lines, but he also turned himself in. ... This isn't like O.J. Simpson having a disguise ready and leading police on a chase.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@ILikePie5
The lack of a mafia kill could also be that That1 waiver as I mentioned and scum chose to kill her rather than a Roleblock on me.
True.
Out of curiosity, who would be your top picks for who I should RB? Right now I am feeling like I should pass it through a RNG.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Crocodile
I'm feeling a strong dislike for both Croc and Water's plays right now. I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed.
cuz i don't know how to play the game and i only skimmed over the dp
Even if missing most of the DP, look at posts like #257 for a basic clue as to what's going on (any list of players analysis posts are also great!).
Created:
Posted in:
I'll be off for a few hours. I have to give a friend a ride home from the airport.
Created:
Posted in:
-->
@Greyparrot
Town rarely has lots of stuff. We have claims of soldier and mimic (both so rare they are not listed on Mafiascum.net), and a confirmed "Strongarm Vengeful," plus a hider which is uncommon.
If not RBing, what are your guesses as to what I did to Pie?
Created: